hatflyerMay 7, 2007

if i want a new shoot to get as strong as possible, does it help to pinch other shoots so the energy goes to the one i have?



Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

No, it won't help and will do the opposite. When you prune back a branch, it's hormones etc. go into overdrive and trying to reproduce what was cut, often coming back with two new branches. If anything, wait til your 'weaker' one has a few good pairs of leaves on it (~6) and then pinch it back to a couple of pairs, it may not fatten up appreciably (until later in life) but will put out more foliage.

    Bookmark   May 7, 2007 at 6:24PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo


The advice I've received, on pruning branches, from Atlanta Bonsai Society workshops, is:

The best way for a branch to become stronger (thicker diameter) is to let it grow unpruned, and prune out other competing, undesired branches, so that light and air can penetrate to the desired branch. If you want to keep a branch from getting too thick, keep pinching it back.

(this is from the Kenji Miyata and Tom Nagatoshi workshops March and April this year)

Your advice to hatflyer seems to be the opposite of that, and has gotten me confused. Which one is the correct method?

Kenji, specifically, in his workshop, kept talking about 'sacrifice' branches - unneeded branches left on the tree to thicken the trunk, and then removed when the trunk attained the desired thickness.

Thanks in advance for the clarification.


    Bookmark   May 9, 2007 at 2:26PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Will a Holly. make a good Bosnia?
I just bought a holly in a six inch pot. It just says...
Bonsai Beginner help: Juniper, Eugenia, and Fukien Tea
Hi there, I'm new to the Bonsai world (currently succulent...
New Bonsai Azalea Budding in Winter- Halp!
I just got an Azalea bonsai for Christmas and it was...
Pepper Bonsai help
Hi, I've just received some Bolivian Rainbow Pepper...
Japanese Maple Bonsai Tree Started to Sprout
Hello, I am a first time bonsai grower and I bought...
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™