best tree for barrier/living fence

annediNovember 19, 2013

We live in a mid-century modern home (1954) with a wall of windows that (now) faces a giant mcmansion to the north. We intend to plant a living barrier, not only for privacy/blocking out our neighbors a/c noise, but also to create an enclosed garden area. Emerald Arborvitae has been recommended and is most likely what we will go with; however, I wanted to ask the forum if there might be a slightly taller alternative out there. We don't want 50 feet tall, but 20 to 25 feet would be ideal. Since we are planting right near the property line (with our neighbor's consent), we do not want to go too far over 5 or 6 feet wide. Does any kind of evergreen exist within these dimensions? What about the Arborvitae Nigra?

Our home is in Northern Virginia, in a neighborhood along the Potomac. This area of our co-joining yards has been graded so the drainage/water flows in a shallow ditch about two feet in from the property line (on our side). The area can get flash-flooding occasionally, and the ditch can get some temporary (24 hour) water logging. To alleviate water logging, we have created a mound that is ~24 inches tall. We have seen other Emerald barriers planted this way in our neighborhood that do really well... I just wish they were about 5' taller.

The distance from our home is only about 15-20', so we don't want to lose yard space (in addition to not going over the property line). The neighbor's house is only about 8-10' from the property line. I wish we had 30 or 40 feet to play with/reforest the area, but we don't.

Some questions:

1. Does any evergreen alternative exist that would get to 20' tall, but width of 5 or 6'?
2. Would it be weird/ugly to plant different types of evergreens interspersed with the Emeralds (in a row) to create some variation/height? (Our current plan is to keep the row of Emeralds and plant some other evergreen varieties in a few feet from the property line to add variation).
3. If we planted Nigra or some other Arborvitae/evergreen, would trimming to keep them within 5' be realistic and/or healthy for the tree?
4. How do Nigra or other arborvitae compare to the Emerald? Are there issues we should be aware of?

Hoping to order the trees now to get them in by the end of November-- appreciate your responses!

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

1. in our area? not really
2. I'm a big fan of mixed property line screens, but they have to be well thought out or they look like Home Depot had a year-end sale and someone had a gift card
3. I'm sure someone will disagree with me (this is the internet) but I think trimmed/sheared arbs look like dog crap. There are plants that take a lot of shaping well, and then there are arbs and junipers
4. Nigra's fine, I guess. We planted a privacy screen for a client and ended up with a 50% loss, but I'm attributing that to not listening to their designer that they were drowning them all summer. So don't drown them. Other than that they're a perfectly fine, boring pointy evergreen that gets the job done.

Big question though - what's the deer situation like? If you're in Loudoun you can cross Emeralds right off that list, right this second.

    Bookmark   November 20, 2013 at 8:41AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
scary house help
Trying to help someone with this- yipes. I'm thinking...
Issue with Retainer Wall, fixable or redo?
Hi, first time posting here. I'm looking for advice...
John Turner
Rock landscape dilema
Hello, So I'm taking on a big project within the next...
Help with small retaining wall
I am starting to landscape my yard and am having trouble...
Help with frontyard design changes
Hi, I’m in the process of replacing turf in my front...
Sponsored Products
Cotswold Lane Outdoor Post Mount
Meyda Tiffany Deer On The Loose Arched Fireplace Screen
$693.00 | LuxeDecor
Under Bench LED Light by Hinkley Lighting
$76.66 | Lumens
Blue Round 12'' Over-the-Railing Planter - Set of Two
$24.99 | zulily
Martha Stewart Living™ Lake Carolina 2-Seat Bench
Home Decorators Collection
Mona Lisa Hologram
Home Decorators Collection
Black/Gray/Red Multicolored Lattice 25"T Spinner
$313.00 | Horchow
Prince Charming's White Horse
$29.99 | Dot & Bo
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™