Roll don't till?

patmycanMay 6, 2014


I've been reading posts and gearing up for planting a new lawn, but I have some final prep work to do.

I have a spec home and will be starting a new lawn. Right now the dirt is pretty soft when I walk on it, so I'm thinking I need to firm it up a bit more. The lawn was graded last summer and settled a bit (mostly where the rain runoff goes), but other than that it seems pretty solid.

Right now I'm spraying the remaining weeds and then planning on raking and getting rid of them.

Since it is so soft, after reading a lot on here, I think the consensus is that tilling would be a bad idea. My only question is though, to firm it up before planting, should I roll it?

After rolling, I'm guessing I might need to spread some thin top soil for the seed to germinate in and then roll again?

Any advice is appreciated. Thanks!

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
dchall_san_antonio(8 San Antonio)

Seems like you're getting mixed messages.

You should never rototill in preparation for a lawn. Using the landscape tractor and box blade for grading, like your contractor likely did, is the way to prep for all landscaping. Rototillers buck, jump, and dig in leaving an uneven subsurface. The fluffy soil left above that surface is invariably leveled to perfection. If you picture that in your mind the rolling subsurface has a fluffy layer of different depths. When the fluffy soil finally settles completely (3 years), it will settle to the profile shape of the underlying subsurface. That leaves your surface bumpy and leads to unpleasant mowing experience and sometimes scalped grass. The tractor with the box blade works only at the very surface. Even it they lower the digger bar the tractor will not buck, jump, or dig in. It leaves a much nicer bed for planting.

You do not need more topsoil. When it was graded it was graded with a purpose in mind. That purpose is to drain water away from all the buildings and out into a gutter somewhere. As soon as you bring in topsoil, you change that drainage. Some people believe that just bringing in 1/4 inch of topsoil every year is necessary to reinvigorate their soil. I have pictures of lawns with a full 10 inches of topsoil accumulated over the decades of bringing in just 1/4 inch. The soil you have was left pretty perfect by the landscape grader. That's his job.

I'm not sure you can wait until August to do this job but it would give you a better result. Seeding now is likely to give you a lot of crabgrass and little real grass by July. Late spring is second only to summer for bad times to seed cool season grass. Late August is better because it gives the new grass about 9 months to get ready for summer heat. Fall seeded grass also does not have to compete with crabgrass seed for moisture and nutrients.

All you need to do is seed and roll the seed down to ensure it makes good contact with the soil. If it is in your blood to apply something on top of the seed, then use a compost. Apply compost at a rate of no more than 1 cubic yard per 1,000 square feet.

    Bookmark   May 7, 2014 at 3:49PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
poor top soil
I had what I thought was top soil brought in to fix...
Problem with St. Augustine grass
Hi! I live in the north of Portugal (Hardiness Zone...
Bermudagrass seeds from big box store
I had great luck with a certain name brand seed last...
Grass & pine straw in winter
Part of my yard St Augustine grass, much of which is...
Help! My lawn needs to recover from years of neglect.
I posted this on the organic lawn forum as well. We...
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™