SF Bay Area, clay soil tree recommendation?

LNJ14January 6, 2014

Hi all,
We've recently decided to chop down a wild-grown siberian elm after I found out how poor tree it would be to leave growing next to our balcony and to the road below on a steep hillside (few small limbs have already fallen, and it's only like 20ft tall). I actually liked looking at the tree.. but when I found out that it's not very stable⦠need something different.

We would like to replace that tree with something worth planting and keeping. except we have a tall order on the requirements:

1. hard, compacted clay (like cement blocks in summer, can get mushy and soft in the rainy winter.. although hasn't rained much in the past 3 years hereâ¦)
2. steep hillside (30% grade)
3. don't want it growing much taller than like, 20-25ft
4. very very dry summer, (usually) very very wet winter
5. temp range typically 40-78F year-round, with few extremes into the low 30's and occasional 90-100F "Indian Summer" days (usually only lasts a few days in the fall).
6. tree will be planted in a middle of a 50yr old juniper hedge, where the elm is currently residing
7. tree will be approximately 25ft away from the house (downhill) [note: I originally wrote 15ft, but it's actually about 25ft from the house, with a 6ft wide balcony sticking out towards the tree]
8. harsh west sun, little AM sun (sun rises behind the house in a steep hillside so it'll be in the shadow until the sun is high enough in the sky)
9. drought tolerant

  1. evergreen or deciduous, no preference. But I like green leaves (not much of red-hued leaves year-round)
  2. windy environment

Any thoughts? We thought about various myrtle, but then realized it might need too much watering in the summer which will hurt the juniper. oh I also need to mention it has a tall monterey pine and redwood (~30-40ft high right now) about 15-20ft from it on one side.

Tough order, I know.. but was hoping may be someone has a good idea for me to start looking things up.

also for stuff like this is it better to consult a landscaping specialist or an arborist specialist?

This post was edited by LNJ14 on Wed, Jan 8, 14 at 16:42

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
blakrab Centex(8a)

What if you drove some thick bamboo poles into the clay when it's wet & mushy, stacked some cut Siberian elm branches behind it and then filled it in with dirt & compost to create a small terrace there. Obviously, topsoil is always better for any plant to grow in. And a terrace will also capture some water, that would otherwise just always runoff.

I would then recommend a Texas Persimmon (Diospyros texana). This large shrub/small tree not only produces copious crops of deliciously sweet berries, but is also a highly heat/drought-resistant xeriscape native that can still withstand low temperatures down to 5ð-10ð F. Moreover, it is an attractive ornamental complete with creamy bell flowers, multicolored trunks and rugged hardwood that can be used for woodworking.

I think it would fit all of your requirements. Note that is is dioecious though, so you need at least a male & female of each to bear fruit... Therefore, you would be best planting another 1 or 2 somewhere else on your property, as well.

Here is a link that might be useful: favorite underused trees

    Bookmark   January 6, 2014 at 9:18PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
hoovb zone 9 sunset 23

20-25' could be a medium to large shrub rather than a tree, so do not limit yourself to just trees, widen you search to larger shrubs as well. Most trees would come in larger than 25'. 15' from your home is also very close. Are wildfires an issue in your area? That is something to consider--you want any foliage as far back from the home as you can get for fire safety, but at least 10'.

Also check the SelecTree website that Cal Poly has. Use the "select tree by attribute". You can enter your requirements and come up with suggestions. For example Callistemon viminalis might be plenty big enough

Here is a link that might be useful: Tree Selection Guide from CalPoly

    Bookmark   January 7, 2014 at 5:57PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Thanks for the suggestions!

blakrab: Diciduous is ok. I'm surrounded by evergreens, so it's nice to have some diversity. not sure if we have any other open space to plant more though (property is overrun by coast live oak which sprout like weeds here. Every year I pull out about 20-30 saplings, and seems like I'm making no dent in the growth density here... every few years I have to have one cut down since they start crowding eachother too much). I'll take a close look at the Texas persimmon. Is that anything like the persimmons you find sold in stores? (orange fruit)? There are few of those in the area. if so, may be there'll be enough in the area without having to plant another in our lot...

hoobv: it's a pretty densely vegetated hillside property, so fire is always a concern. But never really thought bout tree-fire exposure (we're usually more concerned with shrub/grass fire). I said 15ft, but just looked at the survey map, and it seems like it's actually more like 25 ft from the house. making a terrace is an interesting idea.

the tree can be taller, as long as it's the type that is conducive to shaping/height reduction management. but taller tree usually means faster growth (may be) and hard to manage?

and thank you for the tree selection guide. I'll ahve to take a look at that.

An arborist who just came by recommended chinese pistachio. He said around here, it doesn't get much bigger than about 25ft or so, and has great fall foliage, drought tolerant.. doesnt require too much water in the summer so won't hurt the juniper either (I called it juniper, but arborist said cypress, so... hmm). The tree sounded good until I found out that it has a potential of growing to 60ft.. i'll have to do more research on that tree.

    Bookmark   January 8, 2014 at 4:40PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

So, I was speaking to the arborist, and he said that the elm tree is "California Elm". Not the weakest elm, but not the greatest either and he recommended replacing it with something else.

I'll start another thread on this topic, but thought i'd mentioned what I found out here too..

    Bookmark   January 8, 2014 at 4:52PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
blakrab Centex(8a)

"Is that anything like the persimmons you find sold in stores? (orange fruit)?"

Yes and no. It is technically a persimmon, but it is more of a wild, uncultivated type. Hence, the fruits are much smaller and black, not orange. They average in size from a nickel to a quarter, but can be smaller or slightly larger than that range too. Yet, they will grow prolifically and are very sweet!

An orange Fuyu persimmon tree would also be great...except they can grow muucchh taller than your spot would allow and I believe also need more water/care.

Whereas Texas persimmons grow on their own out in the wild even under very intense dry heat without any added watering - so are still naturally ruggedized for a spot like yours. They also tend to grow from maybe ~10'-20' tall - again, perfect for your spot.

Their overall shape and trunks sort of resemble crape myrtles'.

So to recap, these native trees are so beneficial and worth propagating because of their amazing fruiting ability (and other desirable traits) combined with extreme heat/drought (& some relative cold) tolerance.. Now, that is a rare combination indeed!

Here is a link that might be useful: Not only do they survive, but they still even bear fruit in deep drought!

    Bookmark   January 8, 2014 at 6:30PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Desert Willow might be another choice. Drought/heat resistant - flowers all summer. Height to ~ 25'.
Redbud - heat/drought resistant - hgt to 25', flowers in early spring.
Prairie Flameleaf Sumac - 15-25' height. Heat/drought resist. Can develop sucker growth from roots. Dependable red fall color.
Or plant another Cypress (Arizona Cypress?) to match what is already out there.

    Bookmark   January 9, 2014 at 12:08PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
So happy that this is the 1st spring where I don't have......
Vole damage. Burying our fences underground 6 inches...
Can anyone ID this wood? (firewood)
It burns very slowly. It's perfect for nighttime, and...
How long does it take oak tree leaves to fully grow once they wake up?
When the leaves start to grow on oak trees on any tree...
Green-limbed Tree?
What kind of tree is this with the green trunk &...
blakrab Centex
Spring pics
Couple spring pics on a rare mild day: Chinese elm...
Sponsored Products
Darya Rugs Oushak, Red, 2'8" x 9'9" Runner Rug M1727-378
Darya Rugs
St. Ives Gold Six-Light 18-Inch Pendant with Royal Cut Clear Crystal
$830.00 | Bellacor
Bijou Silver Leaf Wall Sconce
Black Alfresco Indoor/Outdoor Rug
$24.99 | zulily
Pelican Bay Outdoor Ceiling Fan by Ellington Fans
$232.20 | Lumens
10' Square Blue Hand Knotted Wool & Silk Persian Tabriz Mahi Oriental Rug S438
BH Sun Inc
Bey-Berk SF82-09 Brushed Metal 4 x 6 in. Photo Frame - Tarnish Proof - SF82-09
$16.99 | Hayneedle
Asha Sumak Area Rug - 4' x 6'
Grandin Road
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™