Return to the Bonsai Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Brazilian Rain Tree

Posted by SamFelder none (My Page) on
Sat, Jun 28, 14 at 8:37

Hi everyone,

I am purchasing a small brazilian rain tree with the intention of growing it for a couple years and then turning it into a bonsai. I live in an apt right now (in MN) so I cannot keep it outside for the remainder of this year until I move. Does anyone have any experience with growing these indoors with a grow light (and if so any recommendations on which one)?

Also, after I move and can keep it outside during the *short* summer we have, will there be enough daily sun or will I still have to put it under a grow light for a few hours?

ps - I know I should probably just get something hardy to my area but I really like these trees and have wanted one for a long time!

Thanks!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

No experience with that particular plant, but.... Having grown plants indoors, you will need at least a few hours a day of light from a "HID" lamp. Hid means high intensity discharge. Two types are 1) metal halide and 2) high pressure sodium. Both run hot, are not especially efficient, but are very bright.

Fluorescent lights, even the high end expensive variety, do not produce a comparable amount of light and are not a substitute for sunlight, even at your relatively high latitude.


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Those two lights mentioned in the last post are absolutely unnecessary and dangerous not just to yourself, but to the trees. The right fluorescent set-up is more than adequate and give as much light as any tree could possibly need indoors or out. I've hesitated to say anything regarding that poster's other notes that have had some questionable ideas in them, but can't not say something now. Please be very careful. Some people have used the lights he talks about, but you must know just how to use them and under what circumstances with which trees, not to mention the expense involved, and they are just not needed, certainly not for B. rain trees, which can be treated like most other tropicals indoors, with high light for many hours a day and using e.g. humidity trays plus a good mix with good drainage.

This post was edited by moochinka on Sat, Jul 19, 14 at 22:49


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Fluorescent lights, even the best ones placed very close to the plant, are not bright. Don't take my word for it. Buy a light meter hold it an inch away from bulb, then two inches, then 6 inches then a foot... You will see that they actually make very little light any distance from the bulb.

Only danger from using the hid lamps is that they can get hot, i said that earlier.

Sorry for spreading my questionable ideas ..... Lol. I think if you go the growing plants indoors forum you will see that, far from questionable, they are actually the conventional wisdom.

And I have and have used a 400w hps lamp. Never hurt myself or a plant :)


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Not going to get into it with you, but how long have you been doing indoor bonsai?


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Four 2' T5 HO daylight bulbs, water tray in the bottom to maintain high humidity, and adding a small fan for airflow soon.

Will be adding some ficus cuttings and a Plectranthus as well, so we will see how everything is doing in a month or so.

After doing some research, it seems that the topic of artificial lighting/indoor bonsai is fraught with fairly polarized debate, though Jerry Meislik (www.bonsaihunk.us) has a lot of info on successfully growing indoor bonsai with both HID and fluorescent lighting (unfortunately not Brazilian Raintrees though).


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

My BRT.


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Jerry M. has a very professional lighting set-up and it's not really the kind of thing most of us would do unless we were very experienced - e.g. had lots of long lived bonsai - and relatively well off... you can do fluorescents and get really excellent growing conditions if you're doing everything else properly as well.


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

My Brazilian Rain Tree stays outside in the summer until late fall and I bring mine inside under T-5 lights in upstairs growing area.. It does well and I have had it for three years now.

I use a gritty mix and foliage pro for fertilizer.

It stay outside like others I keep it indirect light since the temps get close to the mid 90's. if I'm home, I'll set it out to get more sun, but when i leave to go on trips. I place in under a tree to protect it from to much sun... And being thirsty!!!

Just thought I would show mine...

Take care,

Laura .


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Very pretty!


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Thank you, Moonchinka!!

Mahalo!!

Laura


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

For those interested.. Here is a picture of the bloom...

Have a great night..

Laura


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Thanks guys,

Laura - Nice! I hope I can get mine to flower, and I will definitely move it outside for the summer next year (slowly adjusting of course).

Lots of new growth over the past couple weeks so I must be doing something right!


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Sounds good, Sam !!

What are your temps now daytime? Night?

Just wondering..

Thank you, as well...

Laura


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Avg Hi/Lo for July: 85/61 , Aug: 82/59 , Sept: 73/50

But it's the Midwest so plus or minus 30 degrees on any given day (last year we got 4" of snow in May!).

I know the BRT's don't like to go much below 40.


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

I disagree with winterfell up at the top. I have been experimenting with florecent and HID and flirecent both out preformed HID in lumems, as well as plant health, plant size, and root growth. The HID had more dense foiliage, however that plants under a 250 watt florecent looked great! Just a myth that florecent are not as good or what ever you want to say. But the fact is they run cooler they put out more lumens and build a stronger indoor plant.


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

Thanks for the Info , Sam!!!

Those temps sound like your tree would love to be outside for another month or so... I'm sure it would love the natural sunlight it wants. But I understand if you want to wait.. I will bring mine inside when temps get into the lower 50s too!

It's a beauty!!

Congratulations!!

Laura


 o
RE: Brazilian Rain Tree

400 watt metal halide...................36,000 lumens
400 watt high pressure sodium....44,000 lumens
Flourescent T5-HO........................5,000 lumens

You could use T5-high output, but you would need 6 to 8 bulbs to match one HID lamp. They will run cooler and deliver a higher lumens per watt (HID 52-65 LPW, T5-HO, 80 LPW) i.e. less expensive on electric bill, but replacing 8 bulbs at $20 a pop would chew up that savings, and then some!

That being said, the price of a 8 bulb T5-HO setup as compared to HID would be similar.

I personally would go the HID route, it has a less hassle per dollar.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Bonsai Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here