Return to the Bonsai Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Chinese Jade Bonsai

Posted by vbola none (My Page) on
Fri, Jun 22, 12 at 11:27

i brought this bonsai two months ago and the Gardner to me that its a 6 year old plant and very easy to maintain. asked me to water only once in two weeks. so i am following all the instructions given. i live in suburb of Philadelphia. initially i kept the plant outside for couple of hours in shady area. now the temperatures are raising high so keeping it inside the house only. but it is receiving plenty of sunlight.

now my issue is i observed the leaves are dropping. i lost 5 leaves so far...one leaf a day. is it normal??...i observe the plant everyday...rest all leaves are looking healthy..not wrinkled..is there anything i can do to prevent this. please see the pic and tell me..do my plant look healthy??...please help...thank u...


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

Looks like a classic case of nursery soil to me. I would get that tree out of the pot, remove the moss and any glued on rocks, etc. Place it in a well draining bonsai soil mix when you repot it back into that pot. It may be too moist.

Otherwise, that Jade looks pretty healthy to me. I am colorblind, so if someone notices discoloration that I do not...sorry.


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

thank you so much for the reply. i removed the moss and observed the soil. it looked like a very soft dust something that mixed with sand. i never did re-potting before. is there a particular brand of bonsai soil i should use?? now the temperature is about 95F..is this a good time to repot or should i wait for little cooler days??...


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a mid-MI (My Page) on
    Mon, Jul 9, 12 at 18:03

Your plant is Portulacaria afra. It has a lot of common names - mini-jade/dwarf jade/elephant food/elephant bush/ spekboom .... Late Jun - early Jul is the best time to repot. As suggested, a very fast draining, well-aerated soil is best. The soil I use:

Photobucket

Photobucket

Al


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

thank u so much..your photos are really helpful...you have a very beautiful plant...love it...how old is it??...


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

  • Posted by nil13 z21 Mount Washington (My Page) on
    Sun, Jul 15, 12 at 0:32

Portulucarias can take serious heat. We have some along our fence line that are 7 foot tall and can weather 110 degree days with low humidity and no water without a problem.

I agree that a gritty mix would be a good idea. Don't be afraid to prune it. I prune long internode shoots on my potted ones quite frequently. When I am starting the training on them I prune them up and clip all the leaves off so that it looks like a twig. They bounce back quickly with smaller leaves and denser growth.

Nice one tapla.:)


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

i re-potted it as per the instructions and there are so many new leaves come up now. it is getting good indirect sunlight all day long. but somehow it still drops one or two leaves everyday. i really don't know what more i can do to stop this. please help...


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

  • Posted by nil13 z21 Mt. Washington L (My Page) on
    Wed, Aug 8, 12 at 0:47

It sounds like it's throwing off old leaves. I wouldn't worry about it too much since it's sprouting new growth. Just don't let the new growth get leggy and keep the new shoots pruned. I usually strip off the big old leaves anyway to encourage new compact growth.


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

Hi there...as my tree still dropping the leaves i thought i will keep outdoors for a while and surprisingly it worked...didn't drop a single leaf from past four weeks...growing nice and healthy...but two days ago i brought it inside as the temp are becoming low (around 55F in the night) and now i see one leaf on the ground. i keep it near to my patio window and it is getting full day indirect sunlight. do you think it needs more light?? what kind of a light i can use indoors and for how many hours. please advise..thank you...


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

Mmmm...I expect it will drop a few leaves while it re-adjusts to the indoor micro-climate. I have a couple of P.afa plants and multiple Jades. Though this is the first winter I will be going through with them, the advice I've gotten from the cactus & succulent board has been dead on so far.

Water + cold = rot, and a sad succulent plant owner. You should decrease water as the weather gets colder & give it a little time. As long as it's in a gritty mix, gets plenty of morning sunlight, & continues to put on new growth, I would say it's doing fine =)

Doing a GW search on p. afra & jade (as I believe the culture is very similar if not the same) will give you lots of insight on how to handle anything that may come up. Hanging out at the cactus & succulent board will help too.

This past summer, I put all of mine outside on my patio & they did really well for me. I'm in zone 7a & have all of mine back inside. It is said they are cool weather growers, so as long as the don't freeze or fry, all should be well =)

Good luck!
Antoinette


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

My elephant jade bonsai regularly drops all its leaves when I bring it in, they often dont regenerate regular leaves again until outside again. Its about 8 and doin fine.
I wouldnt worry much, just dont overwater it.

Its tough as nails, and the cuttings root with ease.


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

Can't really comment on having to bring them indoors over the winter living in SoCal

But there's one suggestion I'd like to make & I say this about all plants
Might just be one of those IMIO things
But I don't believe you should move plants
i.e. from indoors to outdoors back to indoors etc & so on

Plant acclimate to their surroundings & constantly moving them & changing their surroundings/environment can't be good for them

Like one day they get full sun & the next they get filtered indoor light & one day they get 16 hours of sun then 10 the next day & 13 the day after that

I feel that that stresses them out as you're not giving them time to settle in & acclimate or adapt to any one growing condition because your constantly changing

Just my 2 cents


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

it dropped all its leaves....and the tiny branches too....it looks alive but no growth...no new leaves coming up...i didnt water it from past four weeks....its getting indirect sun light..and i arranged for a plant light too...i really dont know what else i can do...can't understand what's really the problem is.....how can i save my tree...please help....


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

It looks far from happy but it doesn't look dead
So there's a good chance of it bounching back
Jade is a pretty tough plant

Not sure where you're at or the weather conditions there
But I would suggest moving it outdoors / Somewhere where it'll get a good anount of sun
If it's not freezing out

I would consider jade more of an outdoor than indoor plant
Don't really know of to many succulents that do good indoors long term

Best Of Luck


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

i can't move it outdoors as the temp are freezing...always below 40F...if i can keep it safe indoors for another 3 months i can move it out in March....


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a mid-MI (My Page) on
    Sun, Nov 25, 12 at 11:45

What did you use for soil when you repotted? Did you inspect carefully for spider mites? do you know how to do that? Have you been fertilizing? with what? Did you bare-root when you repotted and were the roots free of root mealybug?

Al


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

You didn't water for FOUR WEEKS?!

No wonder it dropped all of its leaves. This isn't a Jade - not in the same Family, not in the
same Order even - and the culture is different. The leaves are more delicate and will drop readily
if the plant is allowed to go too dry. During the Winter indoors, I have a difficult time keeping my
Port's happy...but they do re-grow their dropped leaves once the sunlight increases.


Josh


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

I have always had Jad/ElephantFood in my garden but never considered it for Bonsai material. If this picture shows up you will see two different types. The one in the front with small leaves and grows more apical and has a red tone to the trunk.This plant is about 2 1/2 feet tall. The other in the back ground is very large probably about 4 1/2 feet tall with a large grey trunk about 4 inches in diameter. The leaves on this one are 1 to 2 inches long and thick. Because they are succulents and have such soft/wet tissue they break very easily. I think the larger one would have smaller leaves if it got more sun. We throw these away when ever they break pieces off or we trim it for size. I have seen them before used as Bonsai but never thought any one was serious about them. I mean would a Japanese trained Bonsai artist use a Jad plant? I've always been interested in Bonsai and just joined a club and will be taking some classes this January. If I took a Jad into the club would they laugh at me?


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a mid-MI (My Page) on
    Sun, Dec 9, 12 at 11:30

All you need do to see if anyone is serious about Portulacaria bonsai is use the words in bold to do a search, and look at the images. It is indeed a plant entirely suited to world class bonsai, whether the artist was trained in Japan or not. Crassula ovata, on the other hand, doesn't lend itself well to being a subject that makes believable bonsai. That said, I have a nonbonsai-growing friend that is happy to be lightened by a good bottle of wine or two in exchange for an annual pruning of her C ovatas and potulacarias, and I employ the same pruning principles on the Jade as I would on other trees. It's a very large specimen with a 6"+ trunk, and it looks quite believable as a very large bonsai, but lacks the grace and fine texture with which other trees can be endowed.

Once 'bonsai' is ingrained in the way you think, it will influence the way you prune anything, even if the subject is entirely inappropriate as bonsai material. It can't be helped, lest you simply maintain a hands-off policy and leave the plant to it's own devices.

Al


 o
RE: Chinese Jade Bonsai

Al is absolutely right! :-)

Iamdunn, in your pic you have Elephant's Bush (Port. afra) in the front, and a true Jade (Crassula ovata)
in the back. As Al wrote, the Port. afra is an excellent bonsai candidate; the Jade, not quite as much.

Josh


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Bonsai Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here