Return to the Container Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

Posted by Natures_Nature 5 OH (My Page) on
Thu, Feb 13, 14 at 12:36

I am having TDS readings of 1500-2500 ppm when testing the 511 mix via the pour through method. My other plants that I treat exactly like the 511 mix, in peat/compost/perlite are reading 300-1000. What would cause the TDS to skyrocket like that, the tannins in the bark?

I purchased a bag of "forest pine" uncomposted pine bark mulch that I pulverized to proper size. I measured five parts of that, one part of peat, one part perlite, and a tiny sprinkle of lime.

What TDS does your 511 mix read?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

I've done the pour-thru for pH reading, but not TDS. Is that method considered really accurate for TDS? Do you use a meter or some special device or what to measure?

As for your quandary, we all know that heightened irrigation water alkalinity and fertilizer volume are the typical contributors to TDS. In your case, are you sure there isn't an external contaminant around that pot? Do you Windex or does the exterminator spray near your 5-1-1 pots?


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

"I've done the pour-thru for pH reading, but not TDS. Is that method considered really accurate for TDS?"

I know it's fairly accurate with pH, I'm sure it gives you some a rough estimate..I use a Normal TDS meter(not sure if it's .5 ec or .7) that came with a water filter.. Some gardeners useTDS meters to measure fertilizer dosage, etc.. I figured it would give me rough estimates.. It has to say something when all your pots with 511 or any cut with bark are reading extremely high and all others are reading fairly low.


"As for your quandary, we all know that heightened irrigation water alkalinity and fertilizer volume are the typical contributors to TDS. In your case, are you sure there isn't an external contaminant around that pot? Do you Windex or does the exterminator spray near your 5-1-1 pots?"

Every pot was treated the exact same, I'm positive no contamination.. It seems as if the bark is leaching a lot of solids..

Anyone with similar results?


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

I always associated TDS with inorganic particles only -- salts, minerals, chemicals, etc.

Sounds like homemade pulverizing of your bark might be contributing a lot of superfine particles as opposed to the "processed" or "sanitized" stuff we buy bagged from stores.

I would be interested to know the results if you flushed your 5-1-1 with a healthy amt of distilled water, then did a reading.


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

"Sounds like homemade pulverizing of your bark might be contributing a lot of superfine particles as opposed to the "processed" or "sanitized" stuff we buy bagged from stores."

No, the runoff from the 511 never has superfine particles. The peat/perlite mix has much more "soill in the runoff.. Out of the bag the product is almost like pine nuggets 3/4-1" maybe even up to 2".. I had to screen and break down all of the bark, there are hardly any fines in the mix.. The runoff is, however, brownish in color. It reminds me when I make white oak bark tea, the dark tannin color.. That's what makes me think it's from the tannins.. But the leaves are slightly burning on the tips, just like fertilizer burn.. I wouldn't think tannins would burn plants like fertilizer.. Maybe the bark is contaminated with something? Maybe it is just the tannins?


"would be interested to know the results if you flushed your 5-1-1 with a healthy amt of distilled water, then did a reading."

I flushed the plants a few times.. Still reading 1000-2000... I have a good water filter, water reads 165 ppm out of it..


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

"Maybe the bark is contaminated with something?" I'm liking this theory.

Can you post a pic of your 5-1-1 mix? Maybe also post a pic of the bag your bark came in?


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

Unfortunately I cannot take a picture of the 511 mix, i only made enough for a few pots. I do have a picture of the pike bark I purchased in the link below.

I don't know why I didn't do this yet, I thought about it but never got around to it, im going to fill a pot up with the pine bark and do the pour through test and see what it reads.

Here is a link that might be useful: Lowes forest pine rustic mulch


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

Ok now im really stumped.. Just filled up two pots of pure bine bark, did the pour thru test and came out to be 230 ppm, which sounds right, given my water is 165ppm to begin with. i really thought it was the bark.. So then the only other possible reason would be fertilzer, which i dilute so heavily it's stupid, which is the reason i didnt put that as priority number one. So I had a little fertilizer I left in the bottle, I said it had to be it.. So i tested the fertilizer expecting high tds and it was a mere 250.. I fertilize organically making my own fertilizer, mixing 1/8th teaspoon dry kelp, bat guano, espoma biotone. The ppm of the fertilzer never goes over 1000.. The bark just tested 230. How the hell am i getting our thru tests of 2000+? Perhaps the microorganisms are breaking down the bark, solubleizing the tannins or whatever solids? Very strange...


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

What did you use to 'pulverize' the bark chunks into smaller bits?


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

  • Posted by nil13 z21 L.A., CA (Mt. Wa (My Page) on
    Thu, Feb 13, 14 at 18:09

now treat some of that bark with your lime just like you did before and run the test on that.


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

"What did you use to 'pulverize' the bark chunks into smaller bits?"

I filled a five gallon bucket halfway with pine bark and went at it with a garden fork.


"now treat some of that bark with your lime just like you did before and run the test on that."

Nil, how come I didn't think of that? Yes, it was the lime and CRF(espoma biotone). The lime read at 2000-3000ppm.. I tested the fertilizer a few days ago, from what i remember it was around 300-400ppm.. So I'm thinking it was the damn hydrated lime everyone curses.. Now I know. I was going to leave the lime out to.. But everyone talked about the precious ca/mg balance,etc.. I wonder if the dolomite lime would skyrocket the tds like that.


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

Repeated flushing can still preserve the 5-1-1 mix and plants, right? All is not lost I would think...


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

Fortunately, I only dry mixed 3/4 teaspoon per gallon of 511 mix. The bag is called "horticultural hydrated lime", it calls for one tablespoon of hydrated lime per gallon of water, water plants once a year. It doesn't say anything about mixing it dry in containers, just for outdoor gardens. Im wondering if it's even usable in containers, or is it to caustic? My plants are showing signs of burn on the tips of the leaves, the new growth is looking normal, though. I flushed the plants thoroughly. They should be fine..

This is my first time using the 511 mix, I normally use a peat/perlite mix with success. I was hoping I would be blown away by the growth on my 511 plants, unfortunately the damn hydrated lime burned them and stunted them from the start. I always try to experiment with multiple setups and always try some new setups, yet stick to my proven setup as a control. My peat/perlite mixes are doing great, even the few that were cut with the 511 mix, it just so happens I didn't lime the peat/perlite, the only thing I limed is the 511 mix.. I wish I would of left some 511 mix that i didn't lime, i bet them plants would of did real good! I could always topdress/water with lime/fertilizer after they get established.. Next time, next time...

Thanks for the help guys!


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

You definitely don't want hydrated lime.....only Dolomitic Lime.

Josh


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

Why do garden stores sell hydrated lime as "horticultural lime" ?


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

  • Posted by nil13 z21 L.A., CA (Mt. Wa (My Page) on
    Sat, Feb 15, 14 at 11:13

yeah, calling hydrated lime, 'horticultural lime', makes it sound good for containers. Now if you have very acidic soil it can be useful because you don't need as much. I find it useful for deodorizing the dog run and that's about it.


 o
RE: High TDS pour through method on 5-1-1 mix

Next time you see your local nursery or garden shop calling hydrated lime "horticulural lime", explain to them how caustic this stuff really is. I used about 1/3 of the normal dosage of lime(not even a teaspoon per gal of soil) and it's burning my plants, that is anything but horticultural. On top of that, the directions for CONTAINERS say mix one TABLESPOON of hydrated lime per gal of water, water your alkaline loving plants once a year with this solution. I can't see how this is good advice, if im using less than a teaspoon and its burning my plants, how the hell they expect you to apply a tablespoon? That would of completely fried my plants.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Container Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here