Return to the Container Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Posted by spygrrl 5b Chicago IL (My Page) on
Sat, Jul 16, 05 at 16:34

While trying to find out the minimum size of a container, I ran across some confusing information.

I've been looking on this forum to discover the minimum size container for an indeterminate plant. Whild doing so I came across a post that said a 10" diamter pot was 3 gallons, and a 12" diameter pot is 5 gallons.

Is this correct? Last year I had download a table from the internet re: soil to fill various size pots. I've copied it below in casy anyone would find it useful. According to this table, a 10" pot holds 5 quarts, and a 12" pot holds 12 quarts. Even if these figures allow for not filling the container completely to the top, 12 qts is only 3 gallons and leaving an inch or two at the top of a pot won't explain a 2 gallon difference.

Is this chart wrong? Am I confusing apples with oranges and misunderstanding somehow by thinking in liquid measure?

Any help would be much appreciated. (Hint: that means you, Tapla) LOL

Thanks in advance,
Mel

How much soil do I need?


How many times have you wondered about the amount of potting soil you need to fill a flower pot? This should help: Happy Planting!

Pot Diameter in INCHES.....Soil needed in QUARTS
8".........3 QT
10".......5 QT
12".....12 QT
14".....18 QT
16".....22 QT
20".....28 QT
24".....36 QT
30".....72 QT
36".....96 QT

Window Boxes
6' x 6"x 6".....3 cubic feet
4' x 6" x 6"....1 1/2 cubic feet

every 2' of window box: add 1 cubic foot of potting soil

I apologize for not being able to credit the source of this information; usually I try to save the details of where I found helpful things, but I must have been in a hurry when I saved this because the reference isn't there.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Here's the information I used, I finally found the original file: Container Vegetable Gardening from Iowa State University. (This is a PDF file and requires Adobe Acrobat to read) or View as HTML.

The information in this bulletin is for standard clay pots, so taller nursery pots could hold more given their hight.

Best Wishes
Amino-X


 o
RE: oops

Ooops View as HTML

Best Wishes
Amino-X


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Join the confused crowd :) First off any list that tells you a 10" pot absolutely holds 5 quarts of soil is just giving you a very loose guideline...it's not gospel. A 10" pot that is 9" deep is called a "trade size 1000" - 2.5 gallons (by one manufacturer)....actual volume is 2.3 gallons and one cubic yard of soil will fill approximately 90 of them. A "#1 Trade Gallon" is a "300" and is 6 3/4" x 7 1/4" and is called a gallon but its actual volume is .75 gallons. A 400 #1 at 7" x 7" is the closest to true gallon volume at .98 gallon capacity.

To make it even more confusing, some pot charts list the soil capacity in "cubic inches" and others list it as how many pots needed for a cubic yard of soil... and other charts don't even tell you the size of the pot.

The depth of the pot will increase or decrease the amount of soil it contains. And because a pot is called a 1-gal, 3-gal, or 5-gal doesn't mean that is it's actual size (which I think the government is trying to do something about now). Anyways, a 12" x 11 1/4" nursery pot is a "2000 #5 4-gal" with actual capacity of 3.9 gallons... not 5 gallons.

I could go on and on and on... and it would change with manufacturers and the type of pot being used. There's a standard, a thinwall, a thinwall with a wider lip, etc etc etc... and they all hold a different amount of soil.

Now that I have totally confused you even more with useless information, which I am sure tapla could have explained much better, just remember that just because it is called a gallon doesn't mean it holds four quarts and just because a pot is 10" doesn't mean it holds 5 quarts. After all...there are pots that are 10" diameter but only 4" tall and there are pots called 10" pots but they are actually 11" x 8". :)

Bottom line is... just make sure you have a large bag of soil so you don't run out. ;) And if that "indeterminate plant" you are talking about is a tomato everyone (and all the books) say to use a 5 gallon pot...minimum, but I know people that put them in 3-gallon pots. So.... ?


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a MI (My Page) on
    Sun, Jul 17, 05 at 14:07

Sorry, Spygrrl! I wasn't ignoring you. I didn't see your reference to me in the original post. Truth is, I kind of skipped over it because there's no definitive answer to what you asked, except by mathematics or physically filling, then measuring the container's volume. DaisyLover did a good job of explaining how widely container volumes vary. Some of them are even semi-conical (I think it's just to confuse us.). ;o)

I know it's no help, but after awhile, you'll be able to look at a container & determine how much soil is required. If you have more than a few containers - know what I'd do? I would invest in the components to build a soil superior to what you can buy in a store & keep an ample supply on hand. I always keep several kinds of bark on hand (I use partially composted pine bark for the floral plantings), a huge (4 cu ft) bag of perlite, and a bale of sphagnum peat. When I need soil for containers, I'll mix up a batch of about 6 cu ft. What I don't use, I put back in the pine bark bags until I need it. By using this system, when I run out of soil, a new batch is only 15 minutes in the making. Usually, I make several batches in spring when I'm doing lots of planting. The leftovers from the last batch I make are usually enough to carry me through the rest of summer & winter.

Getting back to the volume thing - If you want to do the math, I can give you the formulas to calculate the container's volumes (formulas vary by shape) in cu inches, which can then be easily converted to gallons. Let me know.

Al


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

that's what I figure, tapla. grab a calculator and do the math. Some of those decorative pots are smaller at the bottom, and so on. All are different.


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

  • Posted by bjs496 z9 SE Houston (My Page) on
    Wed, Oct 12, 05 at 18:10

If you divide the diameter (d) of the bucket by two you get the radius (r). If you multiply the radius by itself and multiply that number by pi (3.14) you get the area (a) of the circle.

a = (d/2) * (d/2) * 3.14 or
a = r * r * 3.14

If the sides of your pot are sloped, you can take the measurement at the bottom and top and average them.

Now, when you multiply the area (a) by the height (h) of the pot, you get the volume (v) of the pot.

v = a * h

Don't forget to measure to the height you would normally put soil. Also, take all of your measurements using the same scale (ie, inches, feet, centimeter, etc). If you take all your measurements in inches, divide the final number by 1,728 to convert into cubic feet.

I've long since given up on trying to figure out volume by quarts, liter, or gallons... all the mixins are sold by cubic feet anyway. If anyone wants an excel spreadsheet that will calculate the volume when the diameter and height are entered, email me.

happy calculating
~james


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Hehe. I just keep at least 5 2-cu. ft sacks of potting soil on hand at all times. If I can get it marked down (Lowe's put my favorite one on clearance--I bought it all--SCORE!!!!), all the better.

My rule of thumb is that the container should be able to just cover the upper part of the plant--or be at least as wide as a tall plant plus a little extra for "tall". That, and the bigger the container, the better (within reason) for growing things like cut flowers and vegetables. I put my tomatoes and chrysanthemums in the Gardener's Supply Terrazza planters, and they thrive. The containers are easily as big as a footlocker. I have them on casters so I can push them around as needed.


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

I know this post is "way old" but I thought it might be helpful to clear up an old trade myth. Container pot sizes aren't a measure of volume, more to the point, they should be referred to as sizes. I.E., #1, #2, #5 etc., etc.. Somewhere back in time the trade grabbed on to the gallon designation and it stuck, like a perpetual "old wives tale" that just won't go away.

Roughly speaking, here are some average volumes for nursery containers;
Listed by order are the pot size, how many pots can be filled by one cubic yard (27 cubic feet) and how many cubic feet it takes to fill each pot.
#1 191 .141cu
#2 96 .281cu
#3 69 .391cu
#5 34 .794cu
#7 26 1.038cu
#10 19 1.421cu
#15 14 1.928cu
#20 10 2.7cu

Regards,
Dan


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Hi Dan,

I know there is a mathmatical formula in determining the volume of a container, but these measurements you provided are very enlightening at first glance. Upon some reflection, I'm wondering how the units and fractional units as you provided have practical meaning for home gardeners or commercial growers? What am I missing with the utility of containers classified and designated by #1, 2, 3, and etc? Thanks.


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Hello Legacy,
Not precisely sure I understand your question so please forgive me if my answer isn't what you're looking for.

The reason I use the designation of numbers instead of gallons is as others have specified. I.E., a one gallon container "should" be able to hold one gallon of soil, which it invariably won't. Although a #1 container will typically hold close to .141 cubic feet of soil. The practical applications for both home gardeners and commercial entities is that they can figure out how much soil they'll need in order to plant up "x" amount of plants when transplanting much quicker by multiplying the number of transplants times the cubic foot capacity of the containers. 20 tomato transplants going in to #1 pots will require apprx. 2.82 cu' of soil, or just shy of a 3 cubic foot bag of potting soil. Or, knowing ahead of time that my bare root shipment will come at a time when planting in the ground isn't plausible, I can get five 2cu' sacks of potting soil for the 12 #5 pots they'll need and have it waiting in the garage for when they arrive.

I work in the "green industry" and get a lot of confused looks from people who want to know how many "pounds" of soil they'll need, or how many containers a 32qt bag will fill. All I can say is, the green industry really needs to stop confusing folks with measurements that aren't practical, lol. Weight changes according to moisture levels as well as the density of the mix. Qt and gallon measures would be fine, IF, containers were actually manufactured to work more accurately with that type of measure. Some are, but they still use fractional portions of quarts and gallons so you still have to use the math unless you keep a handy-dandy chart with the pre-calculated measures for the containers you use most often.

I guess the long and the short of it is, I don't use gallon terms unless I have to because it's just not correct and it perpetuates a misnomer.

Regards,
Dan


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

I see and I can see how it can be crucial for growers to have sufficient supplies and raw materials on hand without being tied up by costs or excessive unused inventory.

I just read the same problems recently with respect to how coir has been marketed. Producers, distributors, and retailers use different measurements, and a dutch producer is pushing for uniform certified standards for coir (kind of like certifications and training endorsed by Microsoft in the early days) to ensure quality and making product comparison easier for buyers and consumers. I see perlite having the same problems with standard unit measurement as it is also sold in different volume units.


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Yes, unused materials sitting around can be a problem. Not just because the overhead ties up funds, but because soil loses many of it's necessary qualities when it sits around, especially if it dries out.

It's kind of odd, that a world wide community can be so strict on plant nomenclature can at the same time allow so many inconsistancies in other trade matters to bog it down. I'm just waiting to see a bag labelled with cubic centimeters... that should make for some fun calculations, lol. (I'm still stuck in Standard US measures)

Regards,
Dan


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Couldn't you seal the bottom of the container, fill with water, and then weigh the water that filled the containers. Couple of calculations might give you volume?????????


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Even simplier, seal the bottom as suggested (ducktape works great for this temporary seal) then fill up the pot using gallon jugs and count.


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Duh... i think too much.


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

As I understand it, we got into this "gallon" reference when the nurseries boomed at the end of WW2. Our government had contracted with canners to pack millions of one gallon cans of foodstuffs to feed the armed services. At wars end there was a very large surplus of one gallon cans available cheap that were grabbed up by the nursery growers. Since they WERE one gallon cans that was what they called them. When the surplus was gone and new cans were ordered a tapered can that would stack was a lot more practical. The advent of plastic made a tapered can much easier (and cheaper) to produce. The name "gallon" persisted even when the container would no longer hold a gallon of anything. Some time ago the weights and measurement people started looking into "false size claims". Since then the industry has been trying to eliminate any reference to "gallons". Hopefully in the near future the industry will decide on names for sizes that can be standardized and make sense to us all. Al


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

Now that's an interesting piece of history! That would explain the straight metal cans I had to cut open for customers when I first started working at a small nursery eons ago. There weren't many of them left in the nursery at the time, but the only thing the other employees could tell me about them was that they were an old style container that weren't being used any longer. I didn't realize I had touched a piece of WW2 nostalgia. That's cool!

Thanks Al,
Dan


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

  • Posted by donn_ 7a, GSB, LI, NY (My Page) on
    Mon, Jul 9, 07 at 11:18

I find it convenient, for potting mix calculations, to keep NSI's (Nursery Supplies Inc.) website bookmarked. They're one of the larger manufacturers of nursery pots, and have a chart for each of their lines on the website. The chart lists, by their item # (which is stamped on the bottom of every pot), all the salient dimensions and capacities for each pot.

Here is a link that might be useful: NSI Grip-Lip Pots


 o
RE: Understanding Container Sizes and Their Volumes

I found DaisyLover's post very helpful.

I have been in the same confused boat, and they mentioned the exact size I was wondering about! (10" x 9")

Here is a formula I found:

Volume in inches: pi x radius squared x height
1 Gallon = 231 cubic inches, so divide by 231.

Source: http://thehotpepper.com/topic/37942-need-to-convert-inches-to-gallons/

BEFORE that, I tried these 2 websites, but it shows different measurements for DRY and WET volume. I didn't know there was a difference...
Find cubic inches:
http://www.online-calculators.co.uk/volumetric/cylindervolume.php
Cubic inches to gallons:
http://www.metric-conversions.org/volume/cubic-inches-to-gallons.htm


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Container Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here