Return to the Container Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

Posted by yellowthumb 5a Ontario (My Page) on
Wed, Aug 12, 09 at 0:29

Hi,

I have been reading many good things about Neem oil. So I made a mix of 10ml neem, 1 liter of water and 3 ml of Dawn's dish soap. I applied this mix to all my plants very late in the evening to avoid any sun damage.

After two days, all other plants are fine, except my Michelia Alba and Magnolia champaca. The new growth on the Michelia Alba are mildly damaged. It's having morning and afternoon sun after 3pm. There are brown to black spots on the back side of the leaves. It's hard to see from the upside of the leaves. Not all new growth were damaged. Some not at all. So the damage is not even. The Magnolia Champaca took the hardest hit, maybe because it's located in the full sun. The small leaves are kind of distorted and brown/black on all edges. All small leaves were damaged.

I got my neem oil from a local garden center sold as a leaf shine. Our weather is kind of warm and humid those days.

I just finished reading a good post by Al on the house plant forum.
Is there anything wrong with my neem application?
YT


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

I suspect your mixture was a bit on the strong side.
I saw similar symptoms once when I used far too much dish soap as a sticker in a one gallon sprayer for roses. Usual recommendations for using dish soap is a half to 1 teaspoon per gallon - or a couple of drops in a liter. I have also read some good things about neem oil but it also likely - that to avoid being fried, oils of any kind should be used very sparingly on plants subjected to full sun.


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

Be care yellowthumb!

I think there is a warning on the bottle for certain plants that are not that tolerant of certain oils, along with many hairy and thin leaf plants such as violets, and succulants.

Do a test spot on a leaf that you will not miss if it should fall off.

I always mix neem a bit weaker in strength than the instructions call for, and it still does a great job. I too have lost a many leaves and buds, especially on my citrus do to the mix being to strong.

Did you know,that even too much dish soap can burn certain plants too.. Fyi, there is a residue left behind if too much is applied. I usually wait a couple of hours for the neem to work, and then give all my plants a good rinse of warm water. This way I have not lost a single leaf or bud from neem anymore. I can't tell you how many gardenia buds I have saved by rinsing after spraying, all the while giving the neem a chance to kill the mites attacking them. And how many I lost just leaving the neem on without a good rinse. It works...

I hope you are well and your summer is still going strong..;-)


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a MI (My Page) on
    Wed, Aug 12, 09 at 17:15

My post suggests that you only use cold-pressed neem oil. I'm guessing your product was not, and it was the vehicle that did the damage. I've never had anything damaged when I apply as you described, using the cold-pressed product.

Al


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

Thanks everybody.

It maybe too strong on the soap side. Given the soap is super concentrated. After mixing, I can see there are lots of foams. Guess too much soap.

Is it a good idea to rinse after applying neem? I thought it's the neem that deters the insects as a anti-feeding agent. If you washed it off, it may not be as effective.

I asked the dealer about the neem oil being cold pressed or not. No answer. I guess not. Cold pressed is much more pricey to produce than steamed.
I just ordered the dyna-gro neem oil and Dr Brooner's organic peppermint pure castile soap. This is the soap that recommended by many others.

Here is the instruction from dyna-gro site.

"Mix 1 1/2 teaspoons of neem oil per quart of water (1 oz per gallon) to make a spray mix. Add
about 1/3 teaspoon (1 1/3 tsp per gallon) Dyna-Gro Pro-TeKt, liquid dish soap or other surfactant
to get the oil to emulsify in water."

I am going to try 5ml of neem, 1 ml of dish soap (or till the foam starts to form) and a quart of water.
I am wondering anybody used the pro-tekt as the surfactant.

Thanks everybody
YT


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

I would suspect that Dawn was part of the problem. It's a detergent, not a soap. It will strip the plant's protective surfaces right off. Other people who have used it have defoliated entire plants.

For a soap, use Murphy's or maybe Ivory. Don't use any detergents. Or, try using one of the saponin based items like EarthJust Assist or Coco-wet.


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

Thanks.

I thought Dawn was a soap. I guess it's pretty hard now to get any real dish soap from any grocery store anymore.

I have the coco-wet, are you sure it can be used as a sufactant?


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

I just did a research on coco-wet, yes, it's a all natural surfactant from spray-n-grow. I guess this should be safer to use on plants than soap based surfactants. I already have a small bottle on hand, this is perfect.


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth - Ne

I just got a quart of dyna-gro neem oil, even enough to cook for a family of two. I am wondering what's the shelf life of neem oil. Dyna-gro recommends putting into room temperature to prevent solidification. But others recommend putting into a refrigerator. How you guys store it?


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a MI (My Page) on
    Wed, Aug 12, 09 at 22:01

Fridge until I need it. Then zap it. Then back in the fridge 'til I need it again.

Al


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

Oh, I never thought about that, but oils do get rancid relatively quickly. I'll move mine to the fridge....hubby will love that! I have mix components all over the dining room, plants starting in the hallway, African Violet leaves rooting in plastic bags on the fireplace mantel and now Neem in the fridge. Sure, this is how everyone lives, isn't it?


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

I have insect specimens in our freezer. :-O


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

I have insect specimens in our freezer.

You are such a nerd ;)


 o
RE-: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

Oh, I never thought about that, but oils do get rancid relatively quickly.

While this is purely anecdotal, I have a quart of Dyna Grow Neem Oil on my shelf that is 3 years old and is still fine. I just went and gave it the smell test ;)


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

Me too.....

The same thing! Dyna Grow Neem Oil...
Thank God it is still good. Since I picked that stuff up, the price of a smaller bottle now cost 2x more the the oringinal big bottle I have..Sheesh

The smell test past for me too.:-)..


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

Hmmmm - maybe the type of oil it is prevents it from getting rancid. Even better. No need to stress hubby over this....I'm sure I'll stress him over something else instead :-)


 o
RE: Neem Oil application damaged my Michelia Alba new growth

It's probably a good idea to put it in a fridge. Just to keep all the active ingredients as effective as possible.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Container Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here