Return to the Container Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

Posted by tcleigh 7 (My Page) on
Thu, Aug 25, 11 at 22:27

Hello all--

Well, I finally did it. After reading about Al's Gritty Mix for the last two years, today I finally got up the motivation to track down the supplies and make some for myself.

Some other posters have previously expressed intimidation at the prospect of beginning the Gritty Mix process. Let me say that I shared this initial intimidation, which is probably why I waited so long to make Gritty Mix of my own. In the end, however, I'm glad I undertook this task and I look forward to it paying off with my plants.

In this thread I want to detail my personal experience with obtaining the Gritty Mix supplies and actually making the mix. I hope that some of the more experienced forum members will be able to identify any mistakes I made or supply helpful hints as to how to go about the process more efficiently in the future. I also want this thread to serve as somewhat of a how-to for those that are toying with the idea of making their own Gritty Mix, in effect de-mystifying the whole process. I wholeheartedly invite commentary and suggestions from anyone interested in this subject.

::

I began by locating the mix materials (see pic): crushed granite, turface, and fir bark. I'm happy to say that I was able to find all the materials in my vicinity. That is not always that case, however, and there are other threads that discuss different substitutes for these materials if they are not available in your area. I myself just moved to RI from GA, so finding these materials was a good exercise in getting my bearings in RI/MA.
Photobucket

Crushed granite -- I found this at a local feed store for use with poultry. It's called Gran-i-grit as you can see from the pictures. I made sure to examine the particle size before buying (see pic). I looked for Manna Pro brand, but only found Mount Airy. I don't think the brand matters at all. I got a 50 lb. bag for $10.
Photobucket

Turface -- I found this, like many other forum members, at a local John Deere Landscaping store. A 50 lb. bag sold for $17.
Photobucket

Fir bark -- Al discusses pine bark fines in his post "Container Soils: Water Retention and Movement", but many have used fir bark with good results and it was really easy to find fir bark at a local Petsmart. It's called Reptibark and it comes pre-screened in 24 qt. bags which sell for $12, if I remember correctly.

After I had gathered these materials, I went to Lowe's to buy the supplies to make a screening basket. The idea here is to wash your mix materials to eliminate dust and small particles which will retain too much water, defeating the whole purpose of the Gritty Mix. Here's what I bought at Lowe's:

--1 pine board (2x4x10) cut into 4 equal pieces (30 in. each)
*In retrospect, I probably only needed a 2x4x8 board
--8 three-inch wood screws
--Aluminum screening (found in the door/window section)

All of this cost me $14. I already had a staple gun and drill at home, but if you don't, you'll need some way of connecting the boards and screen.

Then I went home and assembled the screening box (see pics). This was a very simple process and anyone could do it.

First I assembled my materials:
Photobucket
I then used the wood screws to secure the planks to each other, making a perfect square:
Photobucket

I then laid out my aluminum screening and cut off the right amount. The screening basket will be stronger if you wrap the screening around the sides of the basket:
Photobucket

This shows the gauge size of the screening:
Photobucket

I then used my staple gun to secure the screening to the wooden box. Be sure to make the screen as taut as you can:
Photobucket

When you're finished, you're left with a screening basket:
Photobucket

As I currently have very little outside space, I chose to do the screening in my bathroom. I somehow convinced my fiancee that this was necessary, but, in the end, I probably won't do it that way again. It wasn't overly messy, but there is certainly that potential and if you can do it outside or in a utility sink, that would definitely be preferable.

I used a 2-qt. pitcher to keep my ratios (1:1:1) correct:
Photobucket

I set my screening box upside-down across my tub. I turned it upside down because it can hold more weight that way and because it made it easier to transfer the screened material to a plastic tub that I had placed underneath:
Photobucket

I then laid out 2 qts. of Turface and 2 qts. of crushed granite on top of the screening basket. I chose not to screen the bark because Reptibark comes pre-washed but other barks might need to be screened:
Photobucket
Photobucket
The basket easily handled the weight of these materials combined.

Then, using my movable shower head, I began rinsing the materials and working my hands through them to aid the screening process.

Here is a pic of the dust and fine particles you're trying to get rid of during screening:
Photobucket
*Note: Don't let these particles go down your drain! I used some surplus aluminum screen to cover my drain.

When I was done screening one round, I was too impatient to let it dry, so I transferred it damp into a plastic container.
Photobucket

I'll be using this mix in the next couple of days, but if you plan on storing for long periods, the mix should be allowed to dry.

I then added equal parts of the fir bark and my mix was complete! I was left with a decision to make: which plant to re-pot first. I sought out the Gritty Mix materials specifically for a ficus b. that desperately needs repotting, but it was getting late and I thought I'd save that for tomorrow. I settled on a strange little bald cypress tree. This tree was trunk cut for bonsai-ing 2 years ago, but I haven't had the time to devote to bonsai so I just let it grow out and I now like its unusual appearance. I need to do some pruning around the trunk base, but I'll take care of that tomorrow.

Anyway, the only ceramic pot I had available was a little too small for this specimen, but I thought this would be a perfect opportunity to practice root pruning, another thing I have long feared. I took the cypress out of its nursery pot and gently began working away the soil. When I had worked most of it away, I got the hose and washed the rest off. Unfortunately, I forgot to take a picture of the root ball before pruning but this is what I was left with:
Photobucket
Photobucket
I'd say I removed about 40% of the total root structure.

I then proceeded to pot it in the Gritty Mix and this is how it turned out:
Photobucket
Photobucket

The only thing I'm concerned about is the root coverage. As I said, the pot I transferred the cypress into was a bit too small, so I'm considering taking it out again in the next few days and do some more root pruning. I think this cypress wants to extend its roots, so a more severe root prune might be in order if I'm going to keep it in this pot.

Is it okay to leave a main root hanging out like that? It king of looks cool, but I certainly don't want to keep it that way if it's not healthy for the plant. Suggestions?

I have a lot of fig trees, succulents, and other houseplants that I can't wait to transfer to the Gritty Mix in the next few days!

Questions:

--I know gypsum was in the original Gritty Mix recipe. Is this something I can add later?

--Is it advisable to use a generic water-soluble fertilizer with plants in the Gritty Mix? Any other suggestions regarding supplements?

So far this has been a rewarding and promising endeavor and I encourage those of you considering Gritty Mix to go for it! It's really not that hard and it's all a learning experience.

Feel free to respond with comments, suggestions, alternative techniques, or feeding tips.

Buena suerte!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

Hello tcleigh,

I must say that i'm very impressed with all that you have done...

BRAVO!!!

You did a great job in collecting all of the great ingredients and putting together the screens as well!!

How in the world did you get your fiancee to agree to this in the bathroom? LOL You have a gift to be able to do that!!! I dont even think that i would do that in my bathroom...your bathroom looks so beautiful too! : )

I love everything that you have done and i have to say that you went right to town.

Pretty work!!!

As far as some of your questions about the roots etc.

I will let someone else with more experience add to your post and answer those questions!!!

I just want to say that you have done a great job!!!

I like to use Foliage Pro for fertilizing. You would probably like it as well. Sometimes it is hard too find, but you can alwyas find it on line...

Good Luck!!!

Laura in VB


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

Well you are certainly a detail person. I am sure all your details will help anyone contemplating making a mix for the first time. My only suggestion, based on my need to screen a variety of materials, would be to fasten the largest screen size to your frame, (also the strongest)cut out whatever number of smaller size screens needed, to insert on top of the permanent screen as the job requires. Al


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

wow Id have to bath outside if I did that to our tub. Looks like you did a great job. Leaving that root exposed wont hurt a thing. It will just grow bark like the rest of the trunk. I kind of like the look of trees that have a root like that. Makes it look well anchored down.

mike


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a mid-MI (My Page) on
    Fri, Aug 26, 11 at 19:32

Great job on the details.

A couple of points - I screen outdoors on breezy days and I don't use water - I think it's easier and faster ..... and you don't need to let the soil dry. I also measure the 1:1:1 ratio of ingredients AFTER they're screened. That's just what works for me, but whatever gets the job done & you feel is easiest is what's best. ;-)

Initially incorporate gypsum and use Epsom salts regularly in small doses IF you're using a soluble fertilizer (like Peters/MG/others) that DOESN'T contain Ca and Mg. If using Foliage-Pro, skip both Epsom salts and the gypsum - it's in the fertilizer.

Pot size is fine, but I'm not sure the timing was the best. I'd repot (it's Taxodium distichum, yes? - bald cypress) it in the spring before serious bud movement. It WILL fill the pot with roots quickly, and that will limit growth, so if you want to max the mass, go with a bigger pot ion the spring & repot yearly.

I would remove what was formerly the trunk growing under the adventitious roots that sprouted from the trunk at the next repot. Keeping your root system shallow makes it easier to tend. In the picture of the roots where your hand is showing, I would sever the lower trunk just below where the dark (black?) marks on the trunk end - just below the attachment point of the main grouping of roots.

Your figs/succulents/houseplants are going to love it. Once you get the watering down, you'll be on easy street. ;-)

Good luck - good job!

Al


 o
Your Cypress

Your strange little cypress is.... wait for it...
...a Coastal Redwood... :)


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

Very nice job! Looks like you have a very fine gritty mix. Your plants will enjoy it very much. Good work on making the screens too. They should be veryhandy for screening the ingredients.

As Al would say, "strong work". :)

Let us know how your redwood tree does in your new mix.

Margo


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

Thanks for all your responses, everyone! I'm very excited about potting more plants in the gritty mix after this hurricane departs.

As far as fertilizer goes, I think I'll order some Foliage-Pro so I can get nearly all my nutrient requirements in one place.

Al -- that's good advice about screening. Seems like a much less labor-intensive system than my tub method. Regarding the trunk/roots, I had a feeling I didn't take enough off, but I didn't realize I could chop off the old trunk altogether. That will certainly help keep things shallow and easier to maintain in the same pot.

imstillatwork -- I have to respectfully disagree with you on that one. Might you be biased based on your location? :) I purchased that little guy from a landscape supplier in GA. He, in turn, had bought all his saplings in FL, where the bald cypress is king. I grant that they look very similar when they're small, but if you compare various pictures, I think you'll realize it's a bald cypress (or maybe the pictures aren't detailed enough).

I kind of wish it was a Castal Redwood, though.


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

Now that the electricity is back on I had to look at this thread.

Bravo, BRAVO!

Mike


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

Great job!
Looks like Bald Cypress bark to me, too!

Josh


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a mid-MI (My Page) on
    Sun, Aug 28, 11 at 18:37

One last hint, though it's probably a little late. 1x4 lumber will do the job very well @ half the weight of 2x4s. That will become more relevant when/if you start shaking the sieves to screen out fines.

Again - good job on the details - wish you much success.

Al


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

Thank you for your pictorial, it's so helpful.
I'm in the camp of confused right now about the gritty mix, but do want to understand it all. I understand the mechanics, just not where to purchase the ingredients. I wish there was a store called "Al's Gritty Mix Market." LOL. So it would be a one stop shop. Thank you for your pictorial, it's so helpful.


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

Anita,
I see that you're in IL. "Oak Hill Gardens" (outside of Chicago) carries the small bark for the gritty mix. After Al recommended it, I got a bag the next time I was in the area.
Gail


 o
RE: My first Gritty Mix and screening (how-to pics)

Many thanks for this wonderfully illustrated and informative post. Like you, I have spent the last few months (not quite two years, like you) reading about the gritty mix and more importantly the fundamental concepts. I feel like I have gotten a rudimentary grasp on the core ideas although I certainly still have much to learn. However, as a beginner to container gardening in general and soils in particular, I found myself lacking the practical techniques to put those ideas into practice. Your post has definitely given me the tools I needed to set out on this path and you have my sincere thanks!

Nathan


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Container Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here