Return to the Container Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
'duh' gardener here ...

Posted by terratoma 6 (My Page) on
Tue, Sep 11, 12 at 12:25

Have read so many messages about those "infamous" pine bark fines that I'm almost afraid to try any for fear I'll do the "wrong" thing. And while I totally agree with the point that I can make modifications to best suit my situation, I'm really not comfortable with doing that until I get some experience. So I'm looking for a basic ("beginners") tried and true 5-1-1 mix ... which brings me back to the pine bark fines and their size. Believe it or not, the only hardware cloth available in the entire Roanoke (VA) Valley is 1/4" and 1/8", and I was fortunate to find those. I purchased Lumber Jack pine fines, put it through window screening (1/16") ane the whole shebang went through! Am now trying Jolly Gardener pine bark fines, of which about half goes through. Given what I've read, it seems that I shouldn't use much, if any, of that fine stuff because it will increase water retention too much.. (Right or wrong?) So allow me to make a guess: exclude any bark/fines that won't go through 1/4", as well as any that does go through window screening (1/16"). Any and all suggestions, advice and direction will be my best early Christmas present, I guarantee!
gary


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: 'duh' gardener here ...

Gary,
have you read the actual recipe for the 5-1-1?
You want to keep everything under 1/2 inch. Can you post a pic of the material you have so far?

Josh


 o
RE: 'duh' gardener here ...

I agree with Greenman28.

Any particles from dust up to 1/2" will work (I use up to 3/8".) I like the very fine dusty stuff because I need the extra water retention, otherwise the mix drains too fast for me. Don't know why you are messin' with any screen smaller than 1/2".


 o
RE: 'duh' gardener here ...

Thanks,Josh and edweather. Yeah, I've read Al's recipe so much I can recite it in my sleep. :0) But to be sure that I'm on the same page with you:
5 parts pine bark fines
1 part sphagnum peat moss
1-2 parts perlite (coarse)
dolomitic lime (no quicklime) 1 Tbsp per gallon/1/2 cup per cu. ft.
Following your suggestion, I was able to locate 1/2" hardware cloth; didn't realize I needed so had never inquired about it locally. Now I'll be able to keep the size of the pine bark fines under the threshold.
But my original question had more to do with the "fineness" of the fines to be used and the wide suggestions I've read in this forum led to my question.
Like you, many suggest using 1/2" (or 3/8" in some instances) down to dust. Then here are those that warn against using anything less than 1/16", citing the increased water retention as the particle size decreases. (edweather: I can appreciate your use of the dust to prevent too fast drainage.) Others state that the bulk of the bark be in the 1/16"-1/8" range, with more emphasis on the larger size, also citing the water retention concern, as well as noting that perched water disappears with particles just under 1/8" (I believe 1/10" was mentioned.)
So I reckon the concensus is that there is no concensus.:0) Josh: my son-in-law has promised to teach me the art of uploading pictures, per your request, in an effort to bring me into the twenty-first century!! Depending on his success, will post the pics!
Again, many thanks to you both.
gary


 o
RE: 'duh' gardener here ...

Frankly, you're going to have to experiment and get a feel for how the different mixes perform. I usually don't worry about the fines as much because everything dries out really fast here...I need the water retention for my own convenience. Also, some plants will perform better with more fines (in context) and some will perform better in a more uniformly coarse mix. When you have a lot of fines, you can consider leaving out the peat to bring things closer to a "classic" 5:1:1 consistency. Don't be afraid to experiment - whatever you come up with will be much better than anything you can buy pre-mixed at the store.


 o
RE: 'duh' gardener here ...

Yes, you will have to experiment. My first year I tested a batch of my double ground pine bark and it had almost 1 part fine stuff to 5 parts not fine......so it was perfect to use as is without any peat. That being said the mix still drained too fast and I need to water a little more often than I liked, so the next year I increased the fine stuff by a part. And yes it's all good because it will still be the best mix you've used regardless. You're definitely on the right track.


 o
RE: 'duh' gardener here ...

  • Posted by nil13 z21 Mt. Washington L (My Page) on
    Wed, Sep 12, 12 at 17:06

I think where you may be getting confused is that the "Gritty Mix" requires the serious sifting for particle size. The "Gritty Mix" and 5-1-1 are very different mixes.


 o
RE: 'duh' gardener here ...

Great ideas! I guess there is consensus after all: experiment! I should have known that was the answer but, even after nearly seventy years, I still don't always use common sense.
Based on these (your) suggestions, I'll weed out everything larger than 1/2", use everything that remains (<1/2" right down to the dust), plant, observe ... and learn! I'm sure I was overly concerned with the water retention issue; but there are additional batches of mix in my future (hopefully :o)) and I can manipulate the amount of peat if necessary.
Again, thanks to all; I feel that I have that right "beginning" recipe!
I have questions more about the actual planting in containers; I'm guessing that the forum protocol is such that I should start a new thread (is that what it's called?) I look forward to any help there.
gary


 o
RE: 'duh' gardener here ...

Excellent, you've gotten some great suggestions.
Just remember to fertilize adequately, and you should be very satisfied with the results.

Josh


 o
RE: 'duh' gardener here ...

Thanks everyone, for your suggestions. Next spring is really going to be an eye-opening experience for me, and one which I look forward to.
gary


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Container Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here