Return to the Container Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
All perlite for plant wall?

Posted by freedee 6-7 (My Page) on
Fri, Oct 2, 09 at 22:34

On the edge of my deck, I had a "plant wall" installed in lieu of a railing. I bought railings on Craigs list from a woman who changed her mind after she had these iron railings made, and I got them for a good price. What I now have is a regular railing, with a second railing parallel to it. There is a foot of space between them. My friend will try to post photos. (I tried for a couple of hours to post them and it didnt work.) I will try to describe what Ive done, and what I plan to do.

Ive already started to line the cavity between the railings with landscape fabric. Ive installed a drain on the bottom. I got 32 large bags of perlite. I was going to fill the cavity with perlite. I would open small holes all over the landscape fabric and insert plant plugs, (very small starter plants).

My question is can I do this with perlite only, should I add other ingredients? I will be installing a drip irrigation tube in the cavity. It will on a timer, so drying out should not be an issue. I read on this site that people sift perlite to get rid of the dust. Is that a good idea?

It will be in the shade of deciduous trees. I plant to grow ferns and spike moss. I am in central NJ, zone 6-7.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a MI (My Page) on
    Sat, Oct 3, 09 at 0:27

It will probably work, but be ready to apply lots of water & fertilizer. Rinse the perlite very thoroughly before you plant in it. Flushing/rinsing well reduces the level of fluoride considerably.

Al


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

I soooo glad you responded! I started reading your information on the movement of water in container plants and it made me think. Im paying all this money for tuition for my kids college. I think I could get an education here on line, from you, which is just as valuable.

Heres the whole story. Im in trouble (again). I had this thing built and I really dont know what Im doing, but Im not going to panic. What Im trying to achieve is something like Patrick Blanc, the French architect, does. Ill post a link later. He doesnt tell what his system is, but it works. Someone else in Europe did a similar thing on a public building and it failed, at great cost to the local taxpayers. I read some of the local reactions to this event, and I fear for his life J. This is what I learned from this. 1) Yes, what Im trying to do can be done successfully. 2) Its got to be done the right way.

Heres what Ive got so far. Part of the wall that is straight across on the bottom, part of it goes on top of steps. All of it is at the same level on the top. On the straight part, I put curved flashing on the bottom that is pitched so that it drains into a gutter. We tested it, and it does drain. We lined the cavity with landscape fabric that sits on top of the flashing. If you would draw a cross section of this, the landscape fabric would form a "U", only it would be 3 feet tall and one foot wide. Inside, at the bottom of the landscape fabric, I laid a perforated drainage tube with a sleeve over it. This is the stuff they usually use in French drains under ground. I bought 32 4cubic foot bags of perlite, (I got a good price on them.) I started to fill the cavity with the perlite. The dust was intense. I read about screening the perlite. I think that might be necessary. I could imagine that dust clogging the fabric tube that is around the drain, rendering it useless. How would I go about removing the dust? You mention rinsing it. How can that be done on this scale? And what the story with fluoride?


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

Here's what I'm going for, on a smaller scale, of course.

Here is a link that might be useful: Blanc plant wall


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a MI (My Page) on
    Sat, Oct 3, 09 at 15:57

You're too kind - thank you.

I've grown lots of plants in just perlite for more than a year, and they were very happy - as long as I kept after the fertilizing. ;o) Perlite does have a fairly high fluoride content, so those plants that are sensitive to fluoride would react negatively - if you were using it as the sole media component. Rinsing the product thoroughly removes much of the fine material and the fluoride, so it's a good idea.

I'm not sure how you could go about screening it. I don't think I would want to screen >125 cu ft of it by hand, but perhaps you're more energetic than I. ;o) If you know someone at a grain elevator, they might do it for you - it's worth a try. I suppose if you felt like tinkering, and could engineer the right set-up, using a fan to winnow it would be an option. Rinsing could be achieved by pouring it into a garbage can with holes covered by screens & running water through it.

We want pictures as you progress!!!

Al


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

I just got a wild idea! What if I put a screen over the suction tube of my shop vac, and vacume out the dust and while it was still in the bags?

What plants are sensetive to floride. I'm going to plant ferns and spike moss. Maybe some bergenia too.

I've got pictures. I spent several hours trying to attach them to my post. I gave up on that. If anyone is in central NJ, come by and see it.


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

OK. The shop vac idea didn't work. :( It got clogged after 2 seconds.

Here's what did work. I took an aluminum steam pan, the kind that caterers use in chaffing dishes. I get them at Sam's club. I cut out most of the bottom. Left about a 2-inch border. Covered the bottom with a flexible screen. I shook it on top of another steam pan. It wasnt fast but it worked. I still have a lot more to do.


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

Freedee, if you ever get it right, I would be willing to pay you to build me one..Unbeleivably beautiful that site is..
Funny how many ideas like that start in Europe ha?
I had my friends over to show them, and they can't get over the idea..

I hope you get it right and then post pictures..I wonder if anyone else in the states has this, or any malls. If not you'll be the first..:-)


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

I would love to post pictures. I spent several frustating hours trying. I give up. I had friends who are good with computers try, and they couldn't do it.


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

Can you down load onto to photobucket?

It is a free memmbership. Once you do that I will show you..Deal?:-)


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

I signed up for photobucket. I uploaded a photo. What do I do now?


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

hover the mouse over the image and a box pops up. copy the text in the part labeled html code into the message window and the pic will show up once you hit the preview button.


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

let's see if this works

Here is a link that might be useful: Plant wall


 o
I'm getting frustrated

I don't think this is working

Here is a link that might be useful: try again


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

Hooray, it worked. Now I'll try to post more photos. It seems the problem is that one shouldn't copy everything that copies when you click that spot. I have to copy it paste it somewhere, then copy only part of it. I'm going to try more photos

Here is a link that might be useful: view from the corner


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

view from the corner

Photobucket

You got close, but you want to copy the text from the html code box and put it in the message window, not the 'optional link url' box.


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

When I click on the html code box I get 3 lines of stuff. Should I put all of it in the message box, or just part of it?


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

Mike, these are not all that uncommon, even here in the US. My previous employer was a wholesale grower that had a business segment dedicated to green roofs and 'living walls' and the technology involved with the two is pretty similar. We designed and built samples of both for several national trade shows.

Obviously a very lightweight growing medium is preferred for either situation :-) All perlite can work - it is used a lot with a number of green roof installations in various parts of the globe - but you can also devise a custom mix that that offers a little more substance. One way to think about this is that the growing media for these conditions is little more than a root anchorage and all other growing requirements - nutrients, water, light - must be supplied by the grower.

FWIW, we established our demo living wall as a flat surface and it only became vertical once the plants became rooted and established :-)

Here is a link that might be useful: Google search -


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

all of it. what you paste into the message window looks like this:

[a href="http://s816.photobucket.com/albums/zz90/freedee/?action=view¤t=plantwallrailinginside09007.jpg" target="_blank">[img src="http://i816.photobucket.com/albums/zz90/freedee/plantwallrailinginside09007.jpg" border="0" alt="view from the corner"]


 o
update

In case you were wondering what happened to me, and I hope you were :), here's where I am.

I spent 5 days in Belmont Ma, (near Boston) with my best friend helping her turn a yard overcome with ivy, into a fern garden. Its not done yet either.

I have made a drainage system for the bottom of the plant wall. For the straight part, I just put some flashing on the bottom, and pitched it towards the drain. Inside the landscape fabric, I laid a 4' flexible drainage tube with a sleeve around it, the kind that is normally used under ground. I am trying to fill the landscape fabric with perlite. There is one area that I'm having trouble sealing off the opening in the landscape fabric. If I had this to do over again I would have avoided doing the part that was on the stairs. If I would have only done the straight part, I would be done by now, maybe.

I have more photos but I'm still having trouble posting them. (Stop laughing!)

I am sifting perlite and it's getting old! And so am I. Is it really needed? I'm getting only a 50% yield. So what do I do with the rest of it, the fine part? If it's really best for my plants, then that's what I'll do, (she says stretching her fist to the sky).

The reason I wanted to go with all perlite is that I thought it would be hard to take this apart and replant this. I don't want a material that will break down in two years. Now I'm worrying about breaking down myself. (I enjoy being dramatic) Maybe replanting it is not that big a deal? Maybe I should put some organic material in there, something I wouldnt have to sift. If I put organic material in there, and it breaks down, then what? I know I cant just add more organic material and get it all the way down there, but so what?


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a MI (My Page) on
    Mon, Oct 19, 09 at 21:32

What size is the screen you're using, that only leaves you with half of the product? You could use the fines for hypertufa projects or donate them to someone who WILL use them for hypertufa. Perhaps suggest it on Craig's List.

Al


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

I looked into hypertufa, this is so neat! I really want to do that. I thought I have too much perlite. With all the tufa project I would like to do, I don't have enough.


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a MI (My Page) on
    Tue, Oct 20, 09 at 11:25

So where's the downside then? ;o)

Al


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

The only downside is the sifting of the perlite, but this tufa stuff, that's for me!

Tapla, I want to kiss you. (Don't get too excited, I'm a little old lady.)


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a MI (My Page) on
    Wed, Oct 21, 09 at 15:43

Well YEAH, I'm xcited! I'm onna role lately with the XXXs and OOOs ..... appearing from (I hope ladies - yikes!) posters that must have been happy about something I said. I just makes you feel good when someone takes the time to express their thanks - especially if IN their thank you, there is something that makes you feel they are really excited or more enthusiastic than usual about what they found in what I wrote.

After you get done with your wall and have a few hypertufa projects under your belt - we want more pics! ;o)

Al


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

I'm having a problem. The lowest part is leaking pearlite. I put some flashing and caulked the part where the drainage tube goes down. I think the flashing moved when I was putting in the landscape fabric. I started to fill it with perlite, it was fine. Then when I filled it some more, the perlite started to come out of the bottom. I sprayed "Great Stuff" in the opening. What a mess. The great stuff was sticking to the perlite and an opening remained. On Monday, Ill have someone to help me. Ill block the area off, vacuum out the pearlite in that area, and clog the leak. Wish me luck. Does anyone know if great stuff has any detrimental effect on plants?


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

Here's a photo of the drainage on the steps.

drainge on steps


 o
RE: All perlite for plant wall?

  • Posted by popi NSW Aust (My Page) on
    Sat, Jan 15, 11 at 22:31

Freedee

How did you wall turn out ? Was it a success, with lots of plants growing happily ?

I am researching Patrick Blanc and want to know it all.

Regards


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Container Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here