Return to the Container Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Leaf symptoms - what am I doing wrong?

Posted by milocrab Hong Kong (My Page) on
Wed, Dec 14, 11 at 19:45

I tried to read up as much as I could before starting, but my plants aren't doing very well, and I have not a clue which part went wrong. Please take a look at these leaves:

This is a collard seedling, one of the leaf started to get small yellow spots and the tip curled. I had other leaves that curled ended up drying and shrieveled up.

This is a Mustard Tokyo Bekana, I have serious trouble growing this type, NONE of them are doing well, their cotyledon dies as soon as the first true leaf emerge; then the true leaves go down hill whenever a new leaf emerge...

Here are some background information:
The growing medium is turface, akadama, perlite and peat; plus a bit of lime. I added vinegar to the water to adjust the PH to ~6.4. I began applying a weak solution of FP 9-3-6 as soon as the first true leaf appears. They were grown under two T5HO, placed within 3-4" from the tubes. Temperature is mostly around 75F.

Initially, I thought I over-watered as I watered everyday; and ended up with the top layer of the mix getting moldy. Now that I have corrected the problem by watering only twice a week, the mold is gone, but the leaves are still dying one after another. I have these lights on a timer, they come on at 6:30am and off at 7:00pm. I turn on a fan when I wake up in the morning, but there is still about an hour without it. Without the fan, temperature gets up to 91F. Can the one hour of 91F cause the leaves to curl and wilt?

Then I read about water PH; and found some information that says it is better to lower the PH to 5.0-6.0 for soiless mix; out of this range there will be nutrient lock out. Could my PH be off causing some nutrient lock out?

One last question, do you think I'll be better off pulling out the plants to start over again? I was thinking perhaps the roots were already hurt when I over-watered them at the start. Thanks.

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Leaf symptoms - what am I doing wrong?

I forgot to mention, I live in Asia and I don't know where to get pine bark fines; that's why I chose to use turface, akadama, perlite and peat as my soiless mix. However, this mix holds on to the water too well, I have them in 8cm cups and they don't seem to dry off for many days. Therefore making watering more often with weaker solution not possible. I would love to be able to water everyday or every other day. Can I take out the peat completely? Is the purpose of peat just to add water retention?

RE: Leaf symptoms - what am I doing wrong?

milocrab, you have got me all over the globe - Hong Kong, Asia, Australia!
About your seedlings; the growing medium appears too heavy for a tiny mustard seed and you may have compounded the problem by your watering program. A seed needs to be in a moist environment to imbibe moisture in its own sweet time. If the medium is too wet the seed will rot.
As the seed germinates it uses up its stored energy to produce a root and shoot. These are necessarily small, definitely immature and very sensitive to the environment. Application of fertilizer and exposure to (sun)light must be done carefully and gradually or the seedling can easily die.
All of the leaves in the photographs show a nutritional problem; either a shortage of elements or else a problem with uptake if the elements are present. Overwatering can prevent uptake by displacing oxygen at root level
The bleached areas on some leaves can be caused by sudden and perhaps extreme exposure to (sun)light; or damage due to the activity of the "blotch" (as opposed to the "serpentine") leafminer.
91°F "even for one hour" to us can mean "for an entire hour?" to a seedling as it pulls on all of its meagre reserves to cope with this environmental stress.
Allow me to reproduce from memory, a poem by Kate Brown from my kindergarten school days.
"In the heart of a seed, buried deep, so deep;
A dear little plant lay fast asleep.
"Wake!" said the sunshine,
"and creep to the light".
"Wake!" said the voice
of the raindrops bright.
The little plant heard it
And rose to see.
What the wonderful
Outside world might be."
We had to mime as we recited and it is a pleasamt memory.

RE: Leaf symptoms - what am I doing wrong?

Hi Ronalawn82, thanks for your reply. I used to live in Australia, but now moved to Hong Kong. I had problem registering with my HK address because we don't have postal codes, so I used my old Aussie address instead. :-p

I think I'll have to make another batch of soiless mix to make it less water retentive, and start over again. Perhaps just half perlite and half akadama and leave out the peat and turface altogether. I'll also replace the lime with gypsum and Epsom salt, since there is no peat, the PH of mixture should be around 6-7.

Another thing I can think off is the fan, might be too windy for the seedlings.

RE: Leaf symptoms - what am I doing wrong?

I had a similar experience with vegetable seedlings a few years ago in a good quality packaged mix of milled bark, peat and perlite. I believe my problem was actually over fertilization. You pictures don't look like classic fertilizer burn, but something is drawing water out of the seedling which suggests an imbalance. If I were you I would leave the lime, gypsum and epsom salts out since Foliage Pro supplies calcium and magnesium. I would water with distilled water and leave out the vinegar as well. These days I am using a mix of peat and Turface for germinating seeds. I water every two or three days and only add the tiniest bit of FP to every other watering. I never have problems with soggy soil or fungus using this method.

RE: Leaf symptoms - what am I doing wrong?

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a mid-MI (My Page) on
    Fri, Dec 16, 11 at 11:44

I think you're over-thinking things. I agree with Robin, in that I would suggest you leave out the lime, gypsum, Epsom salts & stick with regular applications of the FP fertilizer.

There's little sense in using all those wonderfully gritty ingredients if you're going to clog thee pores with peat, so I'd skip that. You may also want to consider adding back in a fraction of screened Turface - depending on what you find your water retention needs to be.

I looked at this thread a few days ago - the first impression I got was that there was a high level of TDS & heat in play. I didn't take it as a light intensity issue, but I thought that it might be related to ambient temperatures + the relative heat gain from the photo load. Combining those with a high TDS count, or even those conditioned w/o the high TDS is enough to cause the symptoms you have.

Using only the same ingredients you mentioned, I would strive to eliminate the fine particles or at least wick the pots (to help eliminate excess inter-particular water) and structure the soil so you have enough intra-particular water retention.


RE: Leaf symptoms - what am I doing wrong?

Thank you so much for the suggestions! I'll definately try again without the peat and lime (or gypsum). With the temperature being too hot (~75F, measured at the top of the container), there's nothing much I can do to lower it further since the T5HO is hot and I need to place them close to increase the light level.

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Container Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here