Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Asparagus companion- strawberries?

Posted by dirtslinger2 5 (My Page) on
Fri, Jan 16, 09 at 22:09

That is my deep thought for today...would strawberries make a decent companion for asparagus? I recently bought some strawberry seed (alpine alexandria)which is a non runner which would likely be of benefit?
Strawberries seem to have a smaller rootsystem, and grow low.

I've been trying to think of anything that may work- the only other would be garlic.

Thanks.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

Can I ask why you are seeking a companion for asparagus? It generally prefers it's own bed and is most often planted that way. It doesn't really tolerate competition for water, root space, or for nutrients. And the ferns at 3 feet in height will hide/shade anything low growing anyway.

Some will occasionally stick a tomato plant or 2 in with it as the tomatoes supposedly repel asparagus beetles.

Dave


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

Why... really, for fun. I've found strawberries fairly good at mulching out weeds when planted close.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

Well, in my opinion any other plant in the asparagus bed is a weed because it takes away nutrients from my precious crop. Which is really too small for me. :( I should expand it this spring.

Gah! So much to do!

But if you want to and don't mind a slightly reduced yield, have at it! Just make sure to amend the soil well.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

Why... really, for fun. I've found strawberries fairly good at mulching out weeds when planted close.

Then assuming that asparagus to eat is your goal, I'd suggest you use heavy organic mulch such as compost or straw or old hay in the gus bed instead. Not only will it reduce the weeds but it will feed the gus as it decomposes. Plant the alpine berries someplace else and that way you'd have the ideal growing conditions for both rather than risking production for both.

Dave


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

  • Posted by glib 5.5 (My Page) on
    Sat, Jan 17, 09 at 13:26

I don't see it that way, I think it is a decent idea worth trying. Alpine strawberries are tiny, understory plants, with shallow roots. The gus roots will be a lot deeper, and asparagus needs to be mulched anyway.

Would anyone object if he were to call the alpines a "living mulch"? There are a lot of people who plant clover under their cabbage. That provides N but takes away everything else. I myself mulch garlic (another tall plant with weed problems) with lettuce, and garlic makes it a tiny bit easier for lettuce by providing a bit of shade in June and July. And all it takes, in reasonably rich soil, is a bit more water and a bit more N.

Vegetable companionship works not only chemically but also at the level of providing shade or mulch. So long as they don't try to poison each other, like, say, onions and beans, it should work.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

Normally I'd agree with you glib - living mulch is a good thing in some circumstances. The problem here is the specific crop - asparagus. It simply won't tolerate competition and thrive. Even with my older well-established beds of gus, it they aren't kept groomed of any competitors the production falls off markedly.

But hey - it's dirtslinger2 garden and we learn by experimentation. ;)

Dave


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

If 1 year asparagus roots were planted this spring do you see any reason garlic couldn't be planted between them in the fall? Would the asparagus roots/tops get big enough to compete if I only did it this year?


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

If I plant a row of asparagus and the next row of whatever (would be different each year) is 2.5' away, will that be far enough that it won't compete with the asparagus for nutrients or get shaded too much? The asparagus would be the south-most row in my garden.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

I have no experience with growing asparagus at all, but I can tell you that Alpine strawberries (mine at least) grown from seed are certainly not "low growing" at all! They got to be about knee high. I inter-planted bulb onions with them and they shaded out the onions.

Had to move the onions to another bed.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

If they're non-runners I don't see the strawberries competing with the asparagus, which have staggeringly far and deep reaching roots - try digging up an established crown. Shade and roots from trees are what stunt the growth of some of our asparagus. I'd worry more about getting berries, with those big ferns shading them.

Garlic needs a lot of sun to bulb well, and seems a bad companion for asparagus.

I've planted lettuce, chard and arugula between our asparagus and they do well. The arugula has been self-seeding for two years, abundantly.

I like your general idea of using alpine strawberries as a ground cover.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

hey dirtslinger2, we have a large established bed of gus, aprox 20 ft by 60ft, the center of the rows are about 6 ft apart,, we have had great success with strawberries in a portion of it, we find the harvesting schedual of the two is about the same as we have to do a picking atleast every 2 days durring production, we let the indian runner ducks in ONLY until the fruit starts to set on the berries, they really have helped with our west coast slug problems(slugs seem to love strawberries as much we do), for us the spear production starts near the same time as the berries. as it is such a large bed we also grow a few squash in with the gus durring the summer, perhaps it reduces the gus production but seems to shade the understory weeds and we water both with soaker hoses, durring the rare dry spells, we have also tried pole beens, corn, with success, we restrict our interplanting to just portions of the gus patch.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

Bucktales,
If I were you I would make the asparagus the northern most row. In just a couple of years my asparagus plants were topping out at 6-7 feet tall and are very dense, they will throw a lot of shade.

Every asparagus "how to grow" link I have ever been on has commented on how asparagus should be grown without any competition. Of course everything I have ever read says how asparagus requires this and that in order to produce, and yet it grows wild all over the place without any human assistance. Ditches have weeds, poor sun, too much water...yet you can find asparagus plants in ditches througout the county that survive year after year.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

Thanks paulns, I'll find another spot.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

chinamigarden - thanks, I had no idea they got that tall. My northernmost row was going to be a trellis the whole length with peas, cucumbers, pole beans, etc....

Not sure what I should do now...


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

Bucktales,
I put mine on the west side of my garden. I get full sun from 6:00-5:00 pm before the asparagus starts to shade anything.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

chinamigarden - good thought. I'll have to try that. Thanks again.


 o
RE: Asparagus companion- strawberries?

I know your message is a little old,but I have been reading,
Old Time Garden Wisdom (a gift from friend). In the good
neighbor planting section, for Asparagus is list: tomatoes, parsley,
basil and nasturtiums .


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here