Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

Posted by bart1 6/7 Northern VA (My Page) on
Thu, Feb 20, 14 at 22:00

Are the so called heat tolerant broccolis really heat tolerant?

I'm thinking of trying Sun King and Green Magic this year and was wondering if anyone had grown them.

The Burpee description for Sun King says you can harvest it from spring through fall, and the Johnny's description for Green Magic says it has superior heat tolerance.

Has anyone grown them?
Can you really harvest all summer long? Or does that only apply if you live in northern Maine!??!

Thanks!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

I've grown Packman and Marathon Hybrid throughout the summer here in inland SoCal. Love having fresh broccoli for stir fry all summer long. The trick, I suppose, is to mulch heavily keep moist, and to clip the side shoots before they loosen and flower. Once they loosen, the stalks get woody. Also, a diligent use of BT throughout the season to control the cabbage loopers.

I normally don't grow it in the summer because my water can be used more wisely, but when I do, it's because they sit below my plot of peppers in a different plotand got the runoff from the peppers' water.

You want to avoid planting brassicas with nightshades. In my case, they weren't.

Kevin


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

  • Posted by bart1 6/7 Northern VA (My Page) on
    Fri, Feb 21, 14 at 11:05

Thanks.

Packman is a favorite of mine but I don't consider it heat tolerant in any kind of special way. The description of these other two made me think they would still be producing long after Packman gave up.

I just wondering if the description was just to get me to buy seeds (it worked!) or if they will actually produce into July and Aug here in the Mid Atlantic?


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

I've left some broccoli plants in place through the summer and a few things deter me from the idea of trying it again. First was the taste becomes unbearably sulfurous once the real heat hits. If that is addressed with their increased heat tolerance, then good. But my second deterant was the insects- midsummer a lovely bug called the harliquin bug shows up and takes over any brassica it finds. It's like a prettier version of a squash bug and breeds prodigously like them too. Row covers would probably help. My question is would you really eat the broccoli when all that nice corn and tomatos and green beans and okra are all coming in? Just some thoughts to help you make your decision!


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

bart: I know what you mean. there's been spinaches and lettuces that have claimed slow bolting and I noticed they weren't discernible differences of varieties that didn't make that claim.

Like I said, I think with the ones that claim it, one would still have to make steps to keep the roots somewhat cool(mulch, moisture, shade cloth, etc) And stay diligent of checking on the side shoots every couple days and harvesting young.

Compared to Di Cicci, the two I mentioned are much more heat tolerant.

Sunnibel makes a good point. The pests in different parts of the country would definitely play a part. For instance, No SVB or harlequins here, but I bet you never heard of the tomato suck bug. They get to my indeterminates every year and assassin bugs are their enemy. No assassin bugs in my garden... ughhh!

Good luck.

Kevin


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

Kevin consider yourself lucky. Since several years ago San Diego has been home to the painted harlequin bug also known as the bagrada bug, from Africa. It is different than the standard harlequin bug but breeds prolifically as Sunnibel describes and brassicas are their favorite. The damage that they leave is particularly ugly.


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

It's of not much help now, but there are more heat tolerant varieties being developed on both the East and West coast.

I'm much more familiar with the East coast efforts to develop new varieties and trial existing ones which can be grown during the spring/summer in the cooler areas of the East coast.

It's still a project that's a little ways away from having a slam dunk, but out of existing varieties...Bay Meadows, Gypsy, and Belstar performed well. Bay Meadows was favored the most.


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

I have grown all three of those. Bay Meadows did well, Gypsy is an ugly plant but produced ok, Belstar is the worst variety that I have tried. Bay  Meadows 1 photo Baymeadows3.jpg Gypsy photo Gypsy3.jpg Belstar 2 photo Belstar4.jpg

Here is a link that might be useful: Dill's Brassicas


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

Nice heads Dill! No damage to leaves either! No loopers there?

Kevin


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

plenty of them, even more cabbage worms. Bt takes care of them.


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

Most years I have broccoli through summer. Cooler summers I get a bumper crop. 2012 was poor so in 2013 I used the black/white mulch and had a decent summer. I also transplanted some more right after harvesting garlic and had a good fall harvest.
I did trials last year but had an accident and most of the tags were spilled. So it has made me do another trial this year. poop.
Arcadia
Bay Meadows
belstar
Blue Wind
Fiesta
green goliath
green magic
tendergreen

Belstar and Tendergreen are just going to be planted in summer for fall.

I grow mostly heirlooms in other veggies but hybrids for broccoli. Happy Rich was a disaster here last year.


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

I've tried to pamper it through, but since broc freezes pretty well I quit working at it. Our favorite broc dish is broc beef stir fry, which works really well with frozen broccoli. So, I'm content with eating it cooked in the summer months. My strategy is to plant quite a few (last year nearly 100), get them in really early and freeze what we can't eat fresh. Then as long as the really hot days hold off, I keep cutting the side shoots for fresh eating.


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

100 broccoli plants?? How huge is your family?? ANd your freezer?

I get by with 6(8 max) and that gives me enough for 1-2 times per week in a stirfry with an occasional big pot of Broccoli, ham and cheese soup and some in a salad now and then. Then again, I can grow it year round here.

Kevin


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

Just for info, Green Goliath is a good open pollinated broccoli. Too erratic in maturity for commercial use but heads forming at differant rates can be an advantage to a home gardener. green goliath photo GreenGoliath.jpg


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

Dill: What do you mean? The main heads mature in a wide range of # of days?

Kevin

This post was edited by woohooman on Sun, Feb 23, 14 at 23:48


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

Yes. For production purposes one wants an entire field to head up so you get a maximum one time harvest. With Green Goliath, you may have ten days or so before the first head and last head.


 o
RE: Heat tolerant broccoli varieties?

Farmerdill, you have explained something that I didn't even know I had a question about, you are that good! :) My GG in previous years did seem to be all over the place in reaching maturity (the ones that did) and then this year I was growing something else and they all came right at once, making a broccoli glut for me. I vaguely attributed it to the weather, but now I know better, it was the variety. Cool, thanks.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here