Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
drayven_gw

New question about urine as fertilizer

drayven
15 years ago

Using urine as a fertilizer is not a new topic here and after much reading the consensus seems to be that diluting it to between 1:10 amd 1:30 is optimum.

However I cannot find any information about the FREQUENCY of application.

Admittedly this will depend on the plants being fertilized but nowhere is there a baseline given for what diluted urine actually is.

Is it close to a 10-10-10, or 5-10-5, or 10-0-0. These are just random examples but if I knew what the closest equivalent was then I could calculate the correct application rate.

The plants in particular I am interested in using this on are corn, muskmelon, watermelon, broccoli, and tomatoes.

Any help or links would be greatly appreciated.

Comments (47)

  • tomacco
    15 years ago

    I feel very weird about having searched this out for you... but here it is :)

    "Urine has a fertilizer value of N/P/K 18:2:5 (2)"

    Full PDF about use of urine to fertilize cabbage at: http://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/jf0717891?cookieSet=1

    Main page is: http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jf0717891

    The source for that was:

    Lindén, B. Human urine as a nitrogen fertilizer applied during crop growth to winter wheat and oats in organic farming; Department of Agricultural Research: Skara, Sweden, 1997; Serie- B, Crops and Soils Report 1.

  • drayven
    Original Author
    15 years ago

    Thanks, that is just what I was looking for.
    If anyone else has any experience or suggestions please let me know.
    I'll update the thread at the end of the season with results.

  • daylilyfanatic4
    15 years ago

    Well the whole idea is strange to me but I wouldn't use it on tomatoes to much nitrogen corn will probally be very happy with it but I'm not aure I'd want to eat the corn well thats just me.

    hope this helps

  • tomacco
    15 years ago

    Definitely sounds like you need to cut it down with water. If you do, most anything could use it.

  • cabrita
    15 years ago

    We use it at 1:10 dilution, it works great and it is a very good price....;-). Saves water too! (from less toilet flushes). Not sure why people find it so strange or repulsive. After it is diluted it does not even smell bad. Actually, the urea you buy as fertilizer is made from urine is it not? Tomacco, thanks for finding the reference and the NPK value, this is very good. I always assumed that it only had N and 0 for the P and K, nice to know it has some P and K as well as N!

    As far as the frequency, when the little bottles get emptied out, we start over, try to remember what was fertilized and just start again. Really I just go by what plants look like and who needs it, I do not use it much on the solenacea family, except maybe just at the beginning for vegetative growth. I have read to water with it once a month per plant, but it depends on the plant and how rich your soil is already. We do use it more on the brassica family, since they are such heavy N feeders.

    You can use it straight - undiluted - on the compost pile or tumbler to heat things up a bit, we call it the liquid gold compost activator, LOL.

  • farmboy66
    15 years ago

    funny u should say u wouldnt eat corn from urine fertilizer,would u eat from animal manure?think about where an egg comes out of?u may b a vegetarian thats cool but animal(human) waste products are an intricall part of nature if handled with prober methods,everyday things u use can b tracked back to manure/urine.plastics,crayons candles,etanoyl,pharmasuticals,make up,coal,if u have ever ate catfish or shrimp they r bottom feeders what happens to fish poo,huh,im not a total organic gardener but i know what i did with the wastes of my animals when i had livestock,i put them on my fields where you ate my bread(wheat,rye)drove your car etanoyl(corn).hey enough blowin off on my part,tell a farmer ty for keepin me alive ,all this bad press about not taking care of mother earth is bs, who do u think bad stewardship of the land would affect first?

  • cyrus_gardner
    15 years ago

    why should horse urine be ok but your own urine yuk?
    I am not a chemist but I know that human urine can even kill germs that cause infection, when applied on cuts and wunds.So the chances of being harmful is slim, plus, it breaks down and plants only take up its nitrogen.

  • tomacco
    15 years ago

    I would think the concern would be... splashing veggies with it directly, and then eating your urine as a sauce? :)

  • boggybranch
    14 years ago

    Do not use as a fertilizer...yet, but do use it as an activator for the compost pile.

  • pnbrown
    14 years ago

    Right, fertilize with diluted urine when plants are growing (when soil temps are sufficiently high, at peak season I use it onces a week or more) otherwise sequester in bottles to chelate (for direct application it's best aged before diluting)or use in compost as suggested. I sometimes saturate planting furrows with it undiluted in early spring when there will be time to be metabolized by microbes before planting.

  • gardenlen
    14 years ago

    we sue it daily, generally mixed with dish pre-rinse water we have about 16sq/meters of garden and fruit trees mainly citrus they miss out most of the time(about once a year) as we need this on the gardens more i can't realy say but i suppose the gardens would get an application a week maybe 2?

    len

    Here is a link that might be useful: lens garden page

  • jimster
    14 years ago

    Not only does it save on toilet flushes, it also saves on needless trips back to the house for bathroom breaks while working in the garden.

    BTW, urine is sterile, at least when it is fresh.

    Jim

  • drayven
    Original Author
    14 years ago

    It seems that there are more people doing this than I originally thought.
    Let me ask one more follow up question for others doing this:
    Since urine is so heavy in Nitrogen do you ever mix something else with it or amend the soil differently to compensate or do you just use the urine as an all purpose fertilizer and merely adjust the amount that is applied?

  • pnbrown
    14 years ago

    When I make compost or manure tea I add it to that. My sandy soils tend to be light on nitrogen so having a quick-acting heavy N fertilizer is useful. In a heavy more fertile soil I'd probably be a bit more circumspect.

  • pjames
    14 years ago

    For me the frequency of application is dependent on the amount of beer I drink while working in the yard.

    I am thinking about saving in a jug indoors as a compost activator.

  • jimster
    14 years ago

    I have been told by a friend with first hand experience that human male urine works as a deer repellent.

    Jim

  • margocostas
    14 years ago

    I use it on my compost heaps. I got a lid that goes on a bucket so I can collect it. I have bad knees and can no longer kneel or squat, which makes hiking and backpacking more challenging than it used to be.

    I may start to use diluted urine in my garden. Unless you are sick it should be ok. I'm a microbiologist in a hospital, we culture the stuff. Chances are very slim that there is anything in there that is not out there already. The bad stuff is in human and animal feces but there are some that make "humanure". They put "night waste" on gardens in some countries, which obviously would be riskier. Urine is differant.

  • west_texas_peg
    14 years ago

    I collect it to use on my compost piles.

    Peggy

  • gardenlen
    14 years ago

    g'day drayven,

    mine gets mixed with pre-rinse dish water that we create or call value added water, this just so we can share as much of the urine value around as we can, i have used it neat.

    and yes often it saves me the trip to the bucket for a pee just do it right there in the garden.

    len

  • californian
    14 years ago

    Dog pee kills grass. Is that because its not diluted?
    I read that during the civil war they would mix human urine with the gunpowder, supposedly made it more powerful. The best urine for the purpose came from alcoholics.

  • drayven
    Original Author
    14 years ago

    Californian,
    Yup. Urine was used in the creation of Saltpeter. Check it out:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potassium_nitrate

  • steelshepherd
    14 years ago

    You can't assume the NPK of urine. Digesting protein produces urea.

    "Deaminating Amino Acids-
    When amino acids are broken down (as occurs when they are to be used in energy production), they are first deaminated-stripped of their nitrogen-containing amino groups. Deamination produces ammonia, which the cells release into the bloodstream. The liver picks up the ammonia, converts it into urea (a less toxic compound), and returns the urea to the blood. The kidneys filter urea out of the blood; thus the amino nitrogen ends up in the urine."

  • glib
    14 years ago

    Also note that urine (18/2/5) mixed with wood ash (0/2/5) in equal amounts will give a near perfect fertilizer for vegetables (18/4/10). Limited to acid soils because of the high pH of wood ash. Never spend a penny on compost, mulch or fertilizer.

  • drayven
    Original Author
    14 years ago

    glib, that sounds almost too good to be true but the math seems to work out.
    For something so simple and essentially free why isn't this more widely known and used? Especially in developing nations and areas.
    Is there some downside besides the ph that isn't apparent?

  • cyrus_gardner
    14 years ago

    I use it mostly on compost and plain garden spot, when there is nothing planted yet. You can fertilize non-veggies, like corn, potato, flowers, etc with it. But to do this you have to DO IT in a bucket of water(at an inconspicuous place - hehe, be watchful!) , to dilute it before application.

    Gardening is really fun!

  • pnbrown
    14 years ago

    Drayven, I think we can be confident that the use of ash and human effluent as fertilizer is common in "developing" countries. China is one of those so-termed, after all, where they have forgotten more about horticulture than we'll ever know. In other places, the use of wood-ash via slash-and-burn is common. Whether the separation of urine from feces as a risk-free way of getting at urea fertilizer is common I don't know. Probably in many places a plentitude of convenient containers for the purpose is lacking....

  • gardenlen
    14 years ago

    g'dy drayven,

    it's called "the yuk" factor. and some fear hype getting round that doesn't stack up.

    len who uses his all the time for years now.

  • midsummersgarden
    14 years ago

    My husband is going to love this little tidbit of information, especially when drinking cold beers on a hot day in the garden.

    Myself; well, eek-neighbors.

  • greenmulberry
    14 years ago

    The reason dog pee kills grass is indeed because it is not diluted. It is like dumping concentrated nitrogen fertilizer in one spot. If you go around after your dog and spray where they pee with a hose, you will not have the grass death.

  • steelshepherd
    14 years ago

    Pee from beer will be relatively low in nitrogen. Tell your husband he has to eat brats with his beer to boost the nitrogen content.

  • hp_MA6b
    14 years ago

    Urine as a fertilizer can be applied either fresh or aged.

    The N value of fresh urine is very high. It will burn roots and leave on contact so be very careful
    when applying fresh urine. Not recommended for inexperienced people.

    After about 6-month (shorter in summer, longer in winter) inside a container (like an empty milk jar), urine becomes 'aged'. Aged urine has N/P/K values around 1:1:1 to 3:3:3, depending on what you ate. I got these values from a chinese gardening book. The book also lists the NPK values of urine/feces from animals such as cows, horses, chicken, bats, etc.

    A further reference is the following book (download for free from josephjenkins.com)
    THE HUMANURE HANDBOOK, 3rd EDITION
    A GUIDE TO COMPOSTING HUMAN MANURE
    by Joseph Jenkins
    ISBN-13: 978-0-9644258-3-5
    ISBN-10: 0-9644258-3-1
    Library of Congress Control Number: 2005902104

    Here is a link that might be useful: download for free book

  • tomakers
    14 years ago

    jimster said, "I have been told by a friend with first hand experience that human male urine works as a deer repellent."

    It will repel woodchucks and rabbits also. Or, so I am told. ;-)

    Tom

  • glib
    14 years ago

    Unfortunately, not around here, tomakers. My rodents must have a cold or something.

  • the_gurgler
    14 years ago

    At a school my friend is attending in Guatemala they apply collected urine weekly to their garden. The safe garden that the cafeteria meals are prepared from. ;) So, it is not unheard of. I agree with Len I think it just the yuck factor or fear of the unknown.

  • tomakers
    14 years ago

    It doesn't work if you don't eat meat (I forgot this caveat in my previous post).
    It does seem to work for me, but I also use dried blood around the garden hoping to get the same effect.
    This year I should have no problem, as I have 2 cats on patrol. I can't believe the number of mice they find! They leave the, usually headless, carcasses on the steps to show us what a good job they are doing.

  • pnbrown
    14 years ago

    Ingesting traces of urine (even well-aged urine) is hardly anything to be worried about, considering the traces of all kinds of organic and synthetic compounds that we constantly ingest. And that we probably should make more effort to avoid. I'd a long way rather eat fresh organic produce with traces of urine on it than eat stuff with msg on it, or stuff that's been irradiated, or sprayed with various pesticides.

    Which bottle would you drink, if forced at gunpoint, one filled with sevin, or one filled with your own urine? Eventually, we have to make that choice, because there isn't enough fertilizer to grow food for 7 billion people. Check out the dotearth blog at nytimes for more discussion...

  • pjames
    14 years ago

    CSI probably couldn't find enough urine stuck to the plants once it rains or you water a few times.

    I was at Lowes yesterday and checked the price of regular 13-13-13 fertilizer. A bag was like $25. Makes a good case for using compost and adding some urine.

  • tn_gardening
    14 years ago

    I add urine to my compost pile just about every night. :-)

  • lisazone6_ma
    14 years ago

    My husband is going to love this!!

    Wait till I ask him to start saving it in a jug for me lol!!

    Anything "natural" is good imo. And like others have said, I'd rather have pee on my veggies than pesticides!

    Lisa

  • rdback
    14 years ago

    Sounds like I should start a compost pile around back, behind the workshop 8^).

  • lazyhat
    14 years ago

    I think the immediate question if what would your Family think if they saw you urinating in bucket and hauling it outside, or better yet the nieghbours seeing you letting one rip into your garden! They probably would think nuts.lol

    But I dont really see anything wrong with it. But probably best not to use urine inside the house on your houseplants. Because the smell. If someone came over they might ask you want why your houseplants stinks like piss. :S

  • imrainey
    14 years ago

    I can answer that one.

    My husband has thought I was eccentric since I was in my 20s. Now that I'm in my 60s he is no longer surprised when he sees a watering can and a long stemmed funnel (I think it's for automotive uses) in the bathroom off our bedroom.

    I let him pee any damned place he wants to. And he let's me pee standing up into the funnel. Ain't love grand?!

  • jctsai8b
    8 years ago

    I know it is general good for leafy vegetables, Tomatoes, squash , is it good for beans and other vegetables? what is your experience

  • Edison Pearce
    3 years ago

    Urine is the ultimate organic fertilizer. I have found that a urine/water mix at about 1:12 (approx. 1 1/4 cup per gallon) is good for all stages of cannabis. Once flowering begins, 2 tbl. of diluted Blackstrap Molasses is added to each gallon of 1:12 mix. At full flower to finish, 1 1/4 of wood ash tea is added as well. I've never seen anything rival the results I have witnessed. Old Hippie '63

  • Edison Pearce
    3 years ago

    Also, urine is safe to use every watering. It will almost always out perform Miracle-Gro at 1:12 and I have not experienced any sort of nutrient burn often associated with Miracle-Gro or other commercial fertilizers. It is really liquid Gold. Check out some controlled experiments on the internet, especially those ongoing in Uganda, Africa. This is truly a revolutionary discovery.

  • daninthedirt (USDA 9a, HZ9, CentTX, Sunset z30, Cfa)
    3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    This has been discussed lots more recently than a decade ago. Indeed, urine is an excellent source of nitrogen, but be careful about dilution to prevent burn. Also, and this is important, don't use old urine. I knew a guy who peed in a pail and, months later, he'd pour it on his plants, expecting miracles. That doesn't work. The urease that is floating around degrades the urea in it pretty quickly. That's where you get the ammonia smell from urine. That smell is nitrogen that isn't going to end up on your plants.

    By the way, this isn't a revolutionary discovery. There is a long history of recycling of human urine as fertilizer.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting