Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

Posted by tomatotomata 10 (My Page) on
Mon, Oct 1, 12 at 13:12

I know some of you will say "all of them", but I'm looking for the ones that are MUCH better. You know, like tomatoes in the summer.
You see, I have very limited space, and I don't want to waste it on carrots, for example, if they will be no better than store bought. I will be growing in pots.
What I'm considering are peas, beets, lettuce, brussel sprouts, carrots, spinach, celery. I don't have room for all of them, so I'll go with the ones worth the space. tia


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

The only ones on your list that I would waste time and effort trying to grow in pots would be lettuce and spinach and maybe carrots.

The production on peas grown in a pot would be minimal, likely enough for one meal. Peas is a crop that demands a lot of space for minimal production even in a big garden. Beets would get you maybe 6 beets, 1 brussel sprout plant would need a VERY BIG pot and are very slow growing plus need some frost to taste best, and celery is difficult to grow even under ideal conditions much less in a container.

So it isn't "taste better" that would be my concern but effective use of time and resources. Store bought frozen peas and brussel sprouts will taste as good as any you can grow without the wasted work.

Store bought celery and home grown celery taste exactly the same since it is 90% water either way. But home grown salad greens - consider mesculun , kale, and chard too - will always taste better than store bought and won't have all the recall risks associated with them either.

JMO

Dave


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

g'day,

for me homegrown always tastes better, at present our of our new gardens we are eating silverbeet and no store bought stuff is as fresh or tasty, but taste comes back to you, for me anything you grow is better as far as nutrients go plus you don't have to buy it.

maybe square foot gardening will work for you?

len

Here is a link that might be useful: lens straw bale garden


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

If I could only grow in pots I'd go for herbs first. Fresh picked are always better than bought. Then fresh salads:cut and come again lettuce, arugula, chicory, spinach, nasturtiums and mache plus radishes. Chard would be easy but you need a lot as it cooks down. It is pointless growing Brussels sprouts in pots unless you are content with only one or two servings and are prepared to wait months for even that much. Same goes for peas as dd says. If you do go for peas you'd get more yield from the types where you eat the pods as well as the peas. But still not much.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

Fresh peas are much better than store bought. They taste great raw, and just steamed to bring them up to temp, they can't be beat. In fact, I've had frozen peas in December that were better than standard store-bought.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

I learned in the garden that I preferred spinach raw in salads to lettuce. So I am planting 3 to 1 in spinach. And putting green onions between the plants to help round out a salad. Tonight, I am trying sweetpotato leaves raw in my salad for the first time - after discovering how wonderful they were cooked. I'm now doing sweet potato in the greenhouse, with lettuce, spinach, chard and onions outside for the winter in raised beds.

If you have not tried making your own seed strips for square foot gardening, you should check out this amazing link below.

Here is a link that might be useful: do it yourself seed strips


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

  • Posted by glib 5.5 (My Page) on
    Mon, Oct 1, 12 at 21:17

Peas and spinach are a waste in containers. They produce so little per square foot. Everything is best from the garden, but here in MI the farm market vegetable that most closely resembles those from the garden are carrots. I disagree re: lettuce. It is fairly productive, my lime oakleaf will give you 5-7 cuttings.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

I agree with Dave and of course, some things are subjective. Some people cannot taste a difference between their own carrots and storebought. My DH refuses to eat store bought and just goes without when there are none growing.

In containters, everything of course depends on container size. Some things I would probably try are sorrel, you cannot find that in the grocery store (at least not around here). Baker Creek has a stir-fry greens mix that is tasty. I might plant a bulbing fennel with some of the lettuces. You could probably also sow some green onions in with lettuces. Cilantro and parsley are must winter time herbs for me.

If you want easy, healthy, fresh in the winter time, you can also look at doing your own sprouts.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

  • Posted by jolj 7b/8a-S.C.,USA (My Page) on
    Mon, Oct 1, 12 at 21:59

I have friends who did taste test & fooled more then a few gardeners with some vegetables.
But tomatoes are the hardest to fool someone with, because the fruit looks much different when store bought.
A vine ripen tomato is true red, not pink.
I was cutting a vine ripen tomato at work & a lady ask what kind(variety) it was. She was 26 years old & said she never seen a tomato that red. I am not sure she believe me.
I told her I waited to pick it until it was at the peak of ripeness. That it was a Parks Whopper, just home grown.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

If you like sweet/tender carrots, there's a lot of varieties unsuited for shipping (or long-term storage) that are rarely grown outside of the home garden. They can be rather interesting.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

I agree that "Fresh peas are much better than store bought."

I have converted many people that hate peas in to pea lovers by sharing fresh from the garden peas.

My X-wife hated peas with a passion, she didn't even like the smell when they were cooking, but she had never had fresh.

I was cooking some fresh peas when she came home one day and she said why don't you cook that stuff outside. Not from the smell but from knowing that they were the dreaded peas.

In a few minutes she asked why they smelled different, I just said fresh.

When we sat down to eat supper she decided to try one spoon full of them. She was hooked! She actually said that she thinks she may have had a sexual experience! LOL

After that I would have to cook them while she wasn't home, so that I could get a whole bowl full!


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

Thanks for the input. I guess I'll go for greens, and maybe some green onions. Thanks again. OP


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

Are you growing in containers? Peas and lettuce taste so much better home grown. You can grow lettuce in perlite in a vertical garden to save space.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

Tomatomata, Snowpeas (the shorter varieties) grow extremely well in 5 gallon pots. I use square section pots and line them up in a row touching each other. After germination I put about six sticks in each pot (4-5 foot prunings are fine), Beets and lettuce also grow very well in pots. Of the spinaches, the oriental mikado spinach does very well and silverbeet gives a big crop. Most vegetables will grow well in pots of 5 gallons or larger provided they are watered every day and fed well. I used to grow carrots in pots but good carrots are very cheap here so I prefer to use my pot space for other vegies.

One vegetable that you have not mentioned but is a star for me is broccolini.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

If you like arugula, it is so much better fresh than store bought. We grew it for the first time last fall/winter/spring and loved it in salads, cooked in soups, used in pesto, or saut�ed. It isn't cheap, so growing your own saves money. It is so good for you that it is great to have a good supply. We grew it in zone 7 under garden fabric (in a warm winter) in a 4x4 raised bed and had plenty all winter. We even ate the flowers when it bolted in the early spring (and they are sort of pretty too!)


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

Peas also have the added benefit of replentishing nitrogen in your soil helping whatever you plant in that spot next spring. Around mid september I cut off the tops of all my tomato plants, plant peas and let the peas use the tomato vines as supports. I've never actaully borught I pea into the house - my kids pick 'em and eat 'em before I have enough for a meal.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

Remember that the OP is growing in pots. So the effect of legumes on replenishing nitrogen doesn't really register. I still can't see that peas are worth growing if you are restricted to pots because you need so many plants to get a worth while crop. If you only want a handful to nibble fine, but if you want multiple meals and some for the freezer you would need a heck of lot of pots.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

I am really not an expert on anything; but, when I looked at hydroponics, I got the impression that tomatoes and lettuce were the most viable. I think your options are limited. My understanding is that a tomato will keep producing under grow lights for ever..and cut lettuce will re-grow...most other plants have a designated season and 'burn out'. I think maybe hot peppers may be an option....my two cents...


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

As far as I can see, rereading the OP, these pots are not going to be indoors. At least there is no mention of that. My impression was that the question was about outdoor growing in zone 10 over the winter. So leafy vegetables that can take a bit of coolness and produce a usable crop in a pot would seem to be the order of the day.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

Haven't seen it mentioned yet so I'd vote for cabbage family veggies: cabbage, broccoli, cauliflower, kale. Homegrown these are sweet, mild tasting and wonderful. No comparison to store bought. Especially good if you can let them go thru some cold weather (frost or near frost), but that may not be an option in zone 10.

While these plants can take up some room, there are container/small versions of many of them. And kale can be grown/harvested like other greens (cut and come again).


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

Two different themes here:

What crops are most practical for pots is one, whether "homegrown" produces better-tasting produce is another.

Regarding the latter, IME, once soil is built up to a quite live enriched state, any homegrown produce tastes noticeably better than most bought produce. OTOH, if one's soil is quite poor, that will not be the case.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

  • Posted by jolj 7b/8a-S.C.,USA (My Page) on
    Sat, Oct 13, 12 at 22:22

I agree, pnbrown.
Any fruit of any plant grown in rich soil, then picked fresh will taste better then any fruit that sit on a shelf for a day to a week, no matter what soil it is planted in, but especially a poor soil.


 o
RE: which homegrown winter vegies taste better than store bought?

Green beans in green bean cassourole!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here