|
| I want to start doing the no-dig or no-till method of gardening starting with next year's crop. So, in order to prepare, I have added a ton of shredded leaves to the top of my vegetable garden bed.
What I'm not sure about is what to do with the plants from this year. Do I leave them in the ground so as to not disturb the soil and just hope they will decompose over the winter? Also, for next year, do I then put a layer of newspaper down over my existing bed and then start fresh new leaves, grass clippings, compost, mulch etc. and then plant in that new layer? Help, I've been doing research, but all I can find is information about starting a new bed and I guess what I need to know is how to convert my existing bed. Any tips or experience in doing this in Utah would be GREAT. Thanks! Malinda |
Follow-Up Postings:
|
| mallybills, I am not answering your questions, but I am asking a question myself. Why do you want to do no digging or a bit of tilling? I like to chop up residue and mix these along with any other organic matter lightly into the soil which helps me so much in dealing with residue and makes things nice at planting time and at fall enrichening time. |
|
| I'm not saying it's right but it works for me. First, the layer of wet newspapers are used when you have grass and/or weeds to smother. I will also use them to define a path thru a vegetable bed and then cover the paper with a thick layer of grass clippings. For fall clean up I have removed squash, pepper and tomato plants and put them in a debris pile we have for weeds. I want to remove diseased and things that might hibernate over winter. I leave plants like beans in place until spring. Kale, turnip, beets, carrots and spinach are still being harvested. Last year the spinach started growing again in early spring when we had a warm spell. Yum! Parsnips won't be harvested until spring after the ground thaws. Garlic has already been planted in a bed that used to have peppers and onions. I put organic fertilizer in the rows. In the spring, I will put composted horse manure on all the other garden beds. I have not been doing well composting grass clippings and leaves because the compost bin was near trees and shrubs. Roots infested the compost bins. Late in the summer the three part bin system was moved to the open and closer to the veggies beds. There are things like calendula flowers, dill, and borage that self-sow in the garden. I don't know if I would have less volunteers if I tilled or not. In the spring, I don't need to till. The ground in plenty soft. If a bed is too weedy from the previous year (we have a lot of creeping, runner spreading weeds and grasses), I cover the bed with black plastic for a few weeks. |
|
| g'day mallybills, sounds good to me so far, all our spent plants get tucked under the mulch eg.,. spoilt hay's or sugarcane mulch, so with leaves in place just lay spent plants cut or break them up a bit or if you have shredder run them through that once spread cover with mulch, around 8"s or so deep. too easy really len |
Here is a link that might be useful: lens straw bale garden
|
| What are planning to add in the way of nitrogen sources to compensate for all those carbons - leaves and newspaper? With all that carbon nutrient levels will decline and the soil pH can shift unless you balance all that out with some greens and other sources of nitrogen. I 'd suggest some reading over on the Soil & Compost forum here as your question is the focus of that forum more so than this one. And as wayne already asked above - why? While there are some advantages to no till there are also some disadvantages especially in zones with little to no cold weather/freezes. So first make sure that doing this in zone 10 isn't going to increase your pests and disease problems in addition to the declining soil nutrient and pH problems. When reading about unusual or controversial methods it is best to keep in mind that what works for one in a zone very different from yours may not work at all well in your garden's location. One way to determine how well it will work in your area is to investigate what local commercial growers do - till or no till and why. Dave |
|
| A lot depends on what's going on with your soil to begin with. If you're in a part of Utah where the soil has a high pH you could be waiting quite a while for the effects of soil organic matter + acid additions to change the pH of your root zone vs. tilling/incorporation. Surface applied applications of acidification helping substances can be volatile and lose it's effectiveness to the environment before it effects the soil. If soil pH isn't an issue then this doesn't matter as much (if at all). Dry/arid parts of Utah can have pH of 8+ in many areas. |
|
| He is not in Utah because it is Zone 10. When you bring in leaves you can be reasonably careless, they are just dried leaves. But with garden residual you have to pay some attention. Your tomatoes and squashes will have some disease by now. Bury them well. I prefer to bury all refuse in a single bed, and then use that bed for something that is disease-free the next year. |
|
| This year I tried putting all of my tomato, squash and pepper plants through a small chipper and within 24 hours the pile went from 70 degrees up to 160 degrees... Diseases dealt with. My thoughts on covering weeds etc with wet newspapers is that you gain the nitrogen from the decaying carcasses of the weeds below to make up for the carbon from the newspapers Janet |
|
| rotational composting does not increase pest levels, finished plants are still green when pulled and tucked under as are the kitchen scraps, so nitrogen no issue, the over application of nitrogen will make you new plants attractive to the bugs. we eat turnips and beetroot and get lots of top's to recycle. the case for me is there is no need for tiling ever. keeping mulch tick will take care of weeds. len |
|
| Hi Mallybills -- I use a serrated knife to cut the plants (especially big ones like tomatoes and broccoli) off at the ground level. That way I can put the plants, vines, etc, into the compost, and the roots stay in the ground and the soil isn't disturbed. If you layer lots of organic materials over top of the soil this winter and/or spring, I'd suggest still parting the materials and planting either your seeds or seedlings into the soil underneath. That's the way Ruth Stout does it :) As mentioned above, use newspaper if you've got lots of weeds to kill. Just use mulch if not so many weeds. No-dig is great because you can have things growing all year round, and harvesting all year round. Also, everything I"ve read says it's better for your soil (that's what you've been reading too, I'm sure.) I love the self sowing too -- each year you get crops that you never planted. |
|
| @jankenb - "This year I tried putting all of my tomato, squash and pepper plants through a small chipper and within 24 hours the pile went from 70 degrees up to 160 degrees... Diseases dealt with." I just found this online: ""For all of the bacterial plant pathogens and nematodes, the majority of fungal plant pathogens, and a number of plant viruses, a compost temperature of 131�F (55�C) for 21 days was sufficient for ensuring eradication." There are several exceptions. Two common tomato diseases, tomato wilt (caused by the fungus Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici) and Tobacco Mosaic Virus (TMV), as well as clubroot of Brassicas (caused by the fungal pathogen Plasmodiophora brassicaeI), all required 21 days at 149�F (65�C) to degrade. " |
|
| Which is a data point in favor of careful burial. I am no-till otherwise, but burying disease-prone material is good practice. You can still be no-till with, e.g., radicchio roots and other disease-free vegetables. |
|
- Posted by mallybills 7 (My Page) on Sun, Nov 25, 12 at 17:20
| Thank you to everyone for your responses. It was very educational and kind of everyone to take the time to share your thoughts. I'm excited to do the no-till in order to improve soil conditions. My soil isn't bad, I just want to give it every natural opportunity to improve. Also, I have a ton of leaves in my yard, so running them through the leave sucker (which breaks them up) and then throwing them on the garden, seems like a great way to do both things. Got all of the old plants cut down and broke apart existing stems as much as I could. Hopefully they will break down over the winter. Wish me luck! I'll post progress next spring on how things look. |
|
| I recently read a book that had a section describing the pro's of not tilling one's garden I need to reread it to further understand the pro's and con's. The one important item stressed is not tilling will keep all the micro-scopic tunnels in place, also the worm channels will stay intact. It has some great merits, however I am going to look into this further |
|
| It should be noted that there's a difference between farming and gardening. Farmers can drag steel through their soil multiple times each growing season. There's plowing and tilling and a few other things I don't remember the name of. In a backyard garden, you're not turning over soil five-six times each year. I have trouble believing that you do much harm digging in compost or peat moss in the spring. I certainly wouldn't worry about worm holes. If you have good soil, the worms will make new holes regularly. That's what they do. |
|
| Jon: I have to agree with you. I have, while digging the soil on occasion, actually quite often, have a worm exposed and throw it on some loose soil and cover it with a little more. Some times if I am workng in one spot long enough, an hour or more, if I find a better spot I will take the worms, I put them all in the same general hole, roughly sift them out and move them to a better spot. Often times the worms are no longer in the top inches I put them in so they can move more easily in soft soil than hard. I have little doubt worms, like people, would rather deal with soft soil than hard. |
Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum. If you are a member, please log in. If you aren't yet a member, join now!
Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum
Instructions
- You must be a registered member and logged in to post messages on our forums.
- Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review the contents and make changes.
- After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
- It is illegal to post copyrighted material without the owner's consent.
- HTML codes are allowed in the message field only.
- No advertising is allowed in any of the forums.
- If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
- If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.