Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Bad seed company experience.

Posted by aptosca CA9 (My Page) on
Sun, Dec 4, 11 at 13:51

I don't know if this is allowed on the GW or not but thought I should give people a head's up warning about a seed company on Amazon.

I have been looking for broccolini seeds for years and had pretty given up finding any when I spotted "Sweet Baby Broccoli" seeds from Hinterland Trading Co. The price per 50 seeds was good at .79 cents. The $3.50 S&H cost was a bit much but I was willing to pay that to get these seeds.

Got them yesterday and the postage stamp says it only cost them .88 cents to ship, so the rest of the S&H was pure profit, but real kicker is they sent the WRONG seeds!!!

I can return them and get .79 cents credit and eat the $3.50 plus pay the cost of return postage. Yeah right!

Just FYI.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

Guess the rest of the cost went to them for their packaging the order.


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

Best to check out the Rate & Review Vendors forum here. amazon.com provides you with options for refunds and conflict resolution with all their vendors. Also keep in mind that part of their shipping and handling fees goes to amazon, not to the vendor.

Here is a link that might be useful: R&R Vendors Forum


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

I've never dealt with that particular vendor before, but Amazon's policy is that if they made an error in your purchase, you should be refunded the whole price, including shipping, or they should replace the item with the correct one at their cost. This applies to any vendor that sells on their website also. If the vendor won't refund your shipping when they sent the wrong seeds, I would contact Amazon's customer service about it - my experience has been that Amazon's customer service is stellar.


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

Thanks everyone for your replies. I am waiting for a reply from the seed company. Probably not till tomorrow or the next day before I hear anything. I was just going by Amazon's standard return policy.


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

  • Posted by remy 6WNY (My Page) on
    Sun, Dec 4, 11 at 23:51

I am very suspicious of the sale of Sweet Baby Broccoli seeds. I've not seen them for sale anywhere. I did a few Google searches and all of them lead back to the Amazon seed sale.
Broccolini seed has never been available to anyone. It is for sale as a fresh vegetable only. The new Sweet Baby Broccoli is a new hybrid from the same parents as Broccolini, but it is not exactly the same.
Sweet Baby Broccoli is a very new product. I believe it like Broccolini is only available as a fresh product at this time. I doubt that Hirts/Hinterland Trading Co. on Amazon would be the company to have a corner on the market of seeds. I also doubt that a brand new hybrid would be for sale at such a cheap cost. New hybrid broccoli seeds do not come cheap.
Also if you go to the Garden Watchdog Site, and look up Hirt's, you'll see a bag of mixed reviews including ones about receiving incorrect products.
Remy

Here is a link that might be useful: Article with referencing to Sweet Baby Broccoli


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

remy - Thanks for the interesting information and article. I know - buyer beware! I have been wanting to grow this veggie since first having it in a restaurant a couple of years ago. I wish they would make it available to home gardeners.
Clare


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

There are several vaieties available that are knock offs of the origial variety marketed as broccolini.Happy Rich and Atlantis are sold by Johnny's http://www.johnnyseeds.com/c-504-mini-broccoli.aspx Osborne has Atlantis and Apollo http://www.osborneseed.com/catalog_view.cfm?submitted=yes&selectcat=5&selecttype=Rapini


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

  • Posted by remy 6WNY (My Page) on
    Mon, Dec 5, 11 at 19:10

Thanks Farmerdill. Just to be clear neither of those are Broccolini or 'Sweet Baby' broccoli, but at least Clare can get a similar product. I don't have experience with Orborne, but I know Johnny's is a reputable company.
Remy


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

Also thanks Farmerdill. I will check them out.

remy - Just to be clear neither of those are Broccolini or 'Sweet Baby' broccoli. What makes them different?

Clare


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

concur: Broccolini is a trademark not a variety. It is a trademark of the Mann Produce Company. Original name of the variety Asparation. All of these are hybrid crosses of broccoli and gai lan (Chinese kale). Sweet Baby Broccoli is a trademark of the Green Giant Company. Also a cross between broccoli and gai lan. Different seed companies have begun broccoli-gai lan hybrid breeding programs. "Synergene Seed & Technology, Inc. of Salinas, California has been breeding a broccoli-gai lan hybrid under the name �sweet baby broccoli�. Although their hybrid seed comes from cross-pollination of the same parent varieties as Broccolini�, it is not the product of the inbred hybrid parents specifically developed by the Sakata Seed Corporation. Therefore, the Synergene hybrid is genetically different from Sakata�s �Aspabroc� hybrid. As long as the Synergene hybrid is not sold or marketed under the names Broccolini� or Asparation�, independent growers are free to grow and sell the broccoli-gai lan hybrid." There have been several varieties introduced in the past several years and more coming. It is getting popular.

Here is a link that might be useful: Broccolini -Sweet Baby story


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

Farmerdill- Thanks for the information and link. I will check the article out.
Clare


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

I can't comment on the seed company. The shipping charge
is set by Amazon- The seller gets a little over half and Amazon pockets the rest. The seller should agree to do a complete refund including shipping. If they don't be sure to give them a Negative rating. I would also contact Amazon
for a refund for the incorrect product.
Mark


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

  • Posted by t-bird Chicago 5/6 (My Page) on
    Mon, Dec 26, 11 at 10:43

farmerdill - excellent info thanks!!

Can anyone describe to me why this veg is so sought after? Is it a taste sensation?


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

I always check the companies reputation before ordering. If I won't purchase from a company on eBay that has a rating lower than 99 percent positive there is no way I'm going to purchase from some company selling on Amazon with a 91 percent positive rating. And yes I do on occasion purchase seeds through Amazon. My last Amazon seed purchases where from Illinois Supply and Hirt's Gardens. Both have great reputations and shipped quickly. The shipping price for seeds from Hirt's Gardens is much lower at Amazon than at eBay or their own site. If memory serves they offered free shipping with an order over $ 5.00. Hard to beat that these days.


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

They did get back to me on Dec. 4th saying they would send the correct seeds right away. I still haven't received them. I learned a lesson the hard way.


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

One distinction between "broccolini" type baby broccoli and "Rappini" (or other spellings) - The Rappini are a sharp tasting version of what looks like a slender small headed broccoli - like mustard greens and the like. The Gai Lan cross is very sweet like the best first pick broccoli - but again, in individual slender stalks good for stir fry. I think the broccoli in the cross gives more of a head - Gai Lan makes little flowering tips - but it is very good and a fine substitute.


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

"happy rich" from johnny's is absolutely delicious.


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

Hi Guys :-)

I brought home some of thispurported delicious sweet baby broccoli and when my mom saw it she was stunned and drooling...
She said that where she lived in Greece her aunt would harvest the identical greens from cabbage.. From my understanding, she said the cabbage would have these type of flowers that look like broccolini or sweet baby broccoli..?

I googled away and found this discussion... and the hybrid of these veggies, not a growth out of cabbage..

Do any of you well seasoned experts have any idea if there is some type of cabbage that flowers greens that look similar to broccoli?

Thank you :-)


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

In your post you wrote "s & h"
Shipping & handling is used by many companies.
The shipping fees can be visible, however the handling charges can be excessive, this is where many companies gain a larger profit.
We as buyers see a small number, a seller with thousands of buyers reap big profits...


 o
RE: Bad seed company experience.

Zoi101, many members of the cabbage/mustard family will send up stalks with buds which briefly look like small, loose heads of broccoli just before they flower. I am not aware of any cabbage varieties which look exactly like "baby broccoli" when they start to bolt, but selecting for broccoli-like bud clusters is probably how broccoli came into existence.

Though I think it is a mustard, I especially like the buds of Tat Soi when it starts to bolt. The flowers are tasty raw, too.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Vegetable Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here