Return to the Landscape Design Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Dry Laying Flagstone & Flagstone Type

Posted by Bosch CA (My Page) on
Wed, May 11, 11 at 17:08

I'm trying to replace my lawn with a native CA garden and planning to put a flagstone through the area where the yard used to be. I've never worked with stone and want to make sure I do it right because of the amount of work involved and looking for some guidance.

1) First off is the type of flagstone to use. I'm looking for 1.5'-2' pieces and the local rockery had three that caught my eye: Three Rivers Tumbled (looks good but after searching Google this stone will leech iron/rust even if sealed); Rustic Garden Tumbled (smooth and clean, but the traditional drab grey); Bouquet Canyon Thin (price is 1/2 of tumbled Bouquet Canyon, but at half the price there were some 2 inch thick pieces that should be affordable). Does anyone have any knowledge of Bouquet Canyon? Does it need to be sealed? Is it "brittle" and have prone to cracking? I was planning on just laying it down bare.

2) The soil where the lawn used to be gets "soft" when wet and the flagstones will need more support underneath. The options I'm considering are:

a) Removing the layer of lawn topsoil and replacing it with the harder adobe underneath and tampering it down before laying down the flagstone.
b) I have a pile of half inch/one inch rocks and was wondering if I could find a use by removing the topsoil, laying down these stones, then putting the flagstone on the stones. Or if some extra "cushioning" is needed, to pour some sand over the stones to fill in the gaps.
c) Remove the topsoil and do the traditional process of 1/2 inch gravel, fabric, stone dust, then flagstone. This is the most costly and time consuming and I'm hoping to avoid this.
d) Do nothing, just clear the weeds and level out the existing topsoil and lay down the flagstone.

Any advice would be appreciated, thanks!

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Dry Laying Flagstone & Flagstone Type

You may have made a list of the top mistakes there bosch. There is a ton of information on the interweb and books: do not spend any money before you have a more educated idea of how to proceed.

RE: Dry Laying Flagstone & Flagstone Type

You just want a flagstone path, or an area of flagstone?

I do think that in CA you can avoid option C, but I'm thinking that what you have is a drainage problem, not a support problem, and you might want to address that first.


RE: Dry Laying Flagstone & Flagstone Type

@KarenL - I'm just looking for something like this, in the center of the picture are those stone "stepping islands" -

I found the stones I want, about 1.5'x1.5' Bouquet Canyon Tumbled - after talking with the person at the rockery I'm going to dig a column underneath each stone about the width of the stone, and about a 8 inches deep, fill it with 6-7 inches of the rock from the pile I have as foundation, then put about a 1-2 inch layer of sand on top to level the stone out.

The soil not on the lawn area is hard-packed adobe that stays solid even after heavy rains - there's already some stones/bricks in the backyard placed on bare ground that don't budge.

I won't have any flooding issues with the house, if anything I might drown some plants come the next heavy rain.

@inkognito - I've searched all over the web and can't find anything for this kind of a "stone island" path...everything is about solid flagstone paths that are all flagstone from edge to edge. I just want some stepping stones to make a walking path with 4-6 inches between that will be filled with mulch (or over time, maybe some kind of creeping groundcover plant).

Thanks to both for responding.

Here is a link that might be useful: Sample Stones

RE: Dry Laying Flagstone & Flagstone Type

I kind of doubt you need to do that much digging, especially as your sand will immediately - I think - disappear as it just falls into the gaps among your rocks.

But sounds like you're working it out.


RE: Dry Laying Flagstone & Flagstone Type

I'm not a pro designer, but thought I'd respond since your inspiration pic looks a lot like the garden we had in our previous Calif. home (E. Bay adobe soil). I agree with karinl that you probably don't need to do much digging. We used only sand to set the stone on the adobe soil, then mulch was placed over the yard to hide the layer of sand.

It was still looking great 5 years later when we moved.

RE: Dry Laying Flagstone & Flagstone Type

  • Posted by bahia SF Bay Area (My Page) on
    Sat, May 14, 11 at 16:50

I don't know where you read/heard that the Three Rivers flagstone will leach iron, but it isn't an issue in the middle of a garden as a path, and it would be my first choice as the colors really pop, don't waste your time sealing it, just hose it off from time to time. I also wonder if you really need to pay the premium for a tumbled flagstone, the raw Three Rivers flagstone is cheaper and just as nice. In California USDA zone 9 locations, an inch or two of sand is all that is necessary for a leveling base of flagstone used as a stepping stone pathway.

If you have clay loam based soil that is too soft, you may have a drainage problem needing correcting, or are just overwatering the area. A clay loam soil is only too soft and subject to compaction after significant rains,(and this is really only an issue for planted areas, where you want to avoid soil compaction when the soil is wet, so you maintain good oxygen exchange and soil texture for plant roots). Even in the middle of winter after heavy rains, a clay soil is fully capable of supporting the weight of flagstone pavers without problems of movement, but the sand base will help make them more stable. Weed fabric below a base material is really only appropriate/necessary when you are wanting a solid area of flagstone paving and want to reduce weed growth at the joints; when laying out more widely spaced flagstone as a path, I'd think you would want some low ground cover between the flagstones. If you don't, then use the weed fabric and mulch with gravel or decomposed granite between flagstone pavers.

If you are trying to lay flagstone stepping stones on a slope, there is considerably more attention to a stable base necessary, and I'd suggest you get professional help to install it for better results.

I'd also suggest you go to your local library or buy one of the Sunset or Ortho gardening books that address landscaping and dry laid flagstone paving, they both cover all the issues you will likely face in your installation, and are generally a more reliable source of information than asking questions on the internet.

If you are really interested in the best methods for installing a lower water use garden using California natives, you should also do some reading up on issues of soil drainage, best time of year for planting, how and when to water, importance of mulching, etc., as there are better ways to do this to save time, money and water.

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Landscape Design Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here