Return to the Landscape Design Forum | Post a Follow-Up

1 large shed or 2 smaller ones?

Posted by pam29011 6A (My Page) on
Fri, May 20, 11 at 18:02

Due to setback requirements in our town, I can either put a 12'x16' shed at least 15' from the fenceline OR a smaller shed (under 100 sq feet) only 5' from the fenceline.

Our yard is only 125' wide, so putting a big shed 15' off the property line will have it looking (and feeling) like it's in the middle of the yard. I staked out that area and trust me, it's not pretty :(

So I'm debating - would having two smaller, matching sheds look odd?

If you're wondering, "Why such a big shed, are you housing elephants?" it's to hold a riding mower, snowblower (in the off season), and a sizable collection of lawn & garden tools.

Alternatively we could put the shed sort of centered in the back of the yard, but that will cost a lot more to run electrical that far (about 150' from the house) and we do want lights/outlets in the shed.

Any advice from someone who has had to incorporate storage into a yard?

Many thanks in advance!

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: 1 large shed or 2 smaller ones?

Just two thoughts:
One: think about utilizing your side yard. Most side yards are wastelands anyway and with appropriate fencing can be made into an attractive spot for a shed that won't become the dominant feature in your backyard (because, trust me, most sheds are UGLY and BIG and make an awful lot of themselves). Side yards will need two sets of fencing; one between the front yard and the shed and another between the back yard and the shed.
Two: if your whole yard is only 125 feet wide, you might be better off paying someone to mow it, and not putting up sheds to house the expensive equipment. Sell the mower and put the money into regular maintenance.
Good luck with your project.

RE: 1 large shed or 2 smaller ones?

That is a good point about hiring someone to mow for us. But we are gardeners who like to be outside. Our yard is 2/3 of an acre, which is small in many parts of the country but middling to large here. I used to think I wanted 5+ acres but heck, I flew 100k miles last year for work (I'm not a flight attendant) so there's no way I could manage it. What I'm saying is, I don't have a lot of time to garden but I like to do it when I can, and having to drag all the stuff in and out of the basement is getting really old.

So, we will need to have a shed for the tree cutting/trimming equipment and all the long-handled tools (feels like a hundred, but probably only 30-40 of them).

Our side yard isn't much of an option because it's sort of an extension of our front yard, it's pretty :) I think I might try to talk DH into a single 8'x12' shed for the mower & snow blower, and have something like this built for the long-handled tools & such:

RE: 1 large shed or 2 smaller ones?

A yard 'only' (!) 125' wide and 2/3 acres should have enough space for a nice shed! I think the key thing, whether it is one or two, is to build something nice and not just buy a cheapo structure for the local big box or harware store. If I had that amount of space, I'd go for the larger structure. A few years ago when we were planning on replacing a decrepit old shed, we paid particular attention to sheds on the local garden tour that year. This large shed was 'to die for' - we thought at first it was a guest cottage! It was open and it was clearly a garden shed, but the most amazing one I've ever seen. The property it was on was about 1/2 acre but was otherwise a pretty standard late 1960s suburban bungalow (i.e. it was not part of on a $$$ house and property)
Image Hosting by

This was another nice one that directly inspired our shed:
Image Hosting by

And this is what we built (it's 80 sq. ft.):
Image Hosting by

So my recommendation is build the size that you want but build it nice and make it part of the garden and not just an isolated structure.

RE: 1 large shed or 2 smaller ones?

So I think more information is needed regarding the actual lot layout, since that is what drives whether the large (meaning really large) shed is do-able in a pleasing way. As woodyoak said, usually, but not always, a larger structure is more flexible in how you can design the space--you can do just about anything if you re-jigger the interior for it, whereas with the smaller structure may always be something that doesn't fit, or getting in and out is a pain, plus if you do only one structure you may tend to do it up right, with the types of doors and windows that are nicest, and it is the type of structure that can become the cute garden cottage and so forth. That said, it can be more functional to have 2 sheds if you organize them more seasonally, if one is closer to where do more of the work, if the locations "save" your prime space that would be used for the larger shed. So I think it's a layout-doodle thing to get the feel for where they would go, whether if you do 2 they have to "match," or can be different sizes and dimensions according to where they are in the yard and what their functions are (a tool closet can be done differently from something that has to hold mowers and such, and smaller structures can get away with looking more utilitarian or rustic). 12 x 16 is a pretty big shed, and I agree that you would want something that big to look like it's a planned carriage house or something and not a shack. Also 5 feet from fence, if that means must be 5 ', wastes the space behind. So can't tell whether it's possible to site the larger one so that the larger 15' fence setback becomes a pleasant usable space-- a destination--rather than just sucking up 15'.

RE: 1 large shed or 2 smaller ones?

  • Posted by natal Louisiana 8b (My Page) on
    Sat, May 21, 11 at 13:23

Our lot is much smaller than yours at 75x150. We built a garden shed/workshop near one corner of the yard. It's about 5' from the rear property line. We use the space behind the shed to hang ladders and pieces of wood. There's a small Suncraft shed on the side where dh stores the mower and gas cans. It's not visible from the house or screened porch.

RE: 1 large shed or 2 smaller ones?

WoodyOak and Natal- Your sheds are adorable. I want my husband to build one for a playhouse/garden retreat next summer and am collecting ideas for inspiration. Thanks for posting your pictures!

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Landscape Design Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here