Return to the Landscape Design Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

Posted by Gardenst8 6B NJ (My Page) on
Fri, Aug 17, 12 at 7:38

First post on this forum, was a passionate gardener prior to raising young kids- now most projects are for the enjoyment of the little ones-

Would like advice on how to best tackle an issue with the slope of my side yard- want to add a playset for the kids, but the land is aggressively sloped. We want to have the side yard regraded and add a fence. Raise the land up and create a more useful area.

Two questions:
The bottom of the slope is a runoff stream and large 50ft Pin Oaks line the bank. -stream is dry most of the time, except for after heavy rain. Question: If we build up the land ~3 feet away from the oak's trunk could it cause harm to the Oaks since there are shallow roots in our yard?

Second question:
What is the best way to regrade the slope to ensure the soil holds and does not wash back into the stream? I had one proposal from a company to line the sloped edge with large boulders, fill with soil and compact heavily- not creating a boulder wall, boulders would just hold the soil and allow water to flow between. Land would be raised ~14" and a fence installed.

We just had a patio added in back so soil is disturbed in picture- going to reseed once land is raised.

Thanking you all.

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

The area you are talking about is relatively small. The roots of mature trees extend well beyond that area in all directions. You're never going to get a guaranty about the effect of grade change on adjacent trees any more than you can get one for a heart transplant. Pay your money and take your chances, but they look good to me. It looks like you're only in need of something rustic to retain soil, so boulders (if they're big enough), fallen logs, RR ties, timbers, segmented blocks... whatever you can stand and your budget will allow. It looks like your house is above the area so you will not see the "wall" itself, making the material somewhat inconsequential. Some play sets may allow grade variation so explore that before you regrade. You might not need much grade change.

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

Thank you for the reply and guidance. I read a few articles stating changing the grade near oaks can cause damage since roots could be shallow. I would only raise the grade on one side of the oaks- but still fear I will be impairing water absorption.

It would be an expensive experiment. In my area, the cost to remove seven 50' oaks is probably as much as a heart transplant these days.

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

I can't offer any advice about regrading but did want to share what we did when installing a playset In a sloped yard. We went with an a-frame style and purchased one side to be a larger height than the other to accommodate the slope. This let us get an upgraded higher height set and it fit our yard without regrading.

Good luck with your project!

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

Large boulders + children's playset = not a good feeling.

Karin L

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

"the cost to remove seven 50' oaks is probably as much as..."

You wouldn't be affecting all trees equally. You might be surprised to learn how distant from the main trunk a tree's roots travel. It correlates to the height/size of the tree in a 360* pattern. You're not cutting roots, ending their activity at the cut. You're adding soil to a relatively small portion of the area they occupy. The vast majority of the tree's roots will remain undisturbed. Many of the roots beyond the zone of disturbance and the 9/10 of them outside of it will continue to function as before. If you were adding soil all around the tree in a wide band, the prognosis might be shaky, but here I don't think it is. I've seen trees survive many times worse treatment than what you're proposing.

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

As always, especially in situations like this where there could be some potential big buck problems created , it would be best to have an on site consultation from an arborist. The cost will be very small in relationship to the peace of mind.

You might also enjoy picking up either Sunsets book on outdoor playstructures or Taunton Press " outdoor idea book. Both have some great info about placement of structures and the desired open space requirements around a structure for safe playing.

Also , I don't know what kind of play surface that you are going to place under the structure but if it is playground fiber , which I feel is a lot more comfortable than just regular mulch, you need to dig down about 9 to 12 inches for a safe surface. I know that sounds extreme and this depth is in direct relationship to the height of the potential fall zone, but the deeper the better for shock absorption.
Again, the Taunton Book has some great info and nice examples of play structure set ups for all different types of uneven grades.

photo of a playstructure built into a retaining wall

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

That's such a nice photo! I was about to ask, what about a tire swing on an existing oak, and a ladder up to a tree-house with a slide down... Good luck with your project!

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

A slight tangent on the same topic .... night and safety lighting around a kids play space.

A lot of the times we see path lighting around a kids play area that is just begging to be accidently knocked over or mangled by a wayward bike . Most of these light fixtures are a 'bulb on a stick' or a 'lamp in a can'.

I found that Hadco makes a really tough fixture that can be ground or column mounted. They look like mini light houses and they are tough as nails.
The fixture in this photo is about 15 years old and is located in a back yard that has seen a lot of kid action in its years of service.

I originally saw these used on a dock in Sausalito CA and thought that if they could handle the salt air that they would do well in a foggy area up on Mt. Tamalpias. They weren't cheap but when you consider that they are easily going to give 20 plus years of solid use , they were worth the initial investment.

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

Appreciate everyone's input and suggestions. Very kind of you all to offer guidance.

Really liked the idea of using existing structures with a playset- amazing picture DD! Also appreciate the lighting suggestion. Never even considered adding lighting.

Assuming I could dig down 9-12" and regrade the area by reducing the high side by 12" and building up the low areas. This is something I am now considering. Just need to figure out how to frame out the area for the mulch.

I have a tree expert coming tomorrow to assess the area and get a quote on plantings and grading. Our township denied my application for a fence permit since one side of the proposed fence falls within an easement area. They did approve planting of trees to stabilize the bank but now denied the fence. So I will just add some type of plantings and regrade without adding a fence. Will look to add a fence later when I have the energy to argue with the township.

I am starting to think Michelle's suggestion for purchasing a playset that can accommodate a slope would be the easiest solution. Only playset company I found that could be altered for slopes was Rainbow sets-I still have to level out area for the clubhouse but that is only a 5x5 patch.

We still want to fix the sloped side of the yard to make a more useful play area. Will let everyone know what the landscape contractor / tree expert proposes.

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

I think you will find that working with the folks at Rainbow Play structures will be a good experience.
We've worked with them on about a dozen of their play structures and they have always been helpful.
I especially like their method of recessing their bolts and doing the little extras that make a structure safe.
When we have had problems they were Johnny on the Spot to come out and adjust or replace an item.

On one of our projects I donated an old computer keyboard to a playhouse and they set it into the wood railing and screwed it in safely for no charge.
A nice little touch that has earned my loyalty.

I'm also crazy for Barbara Butler's play structures. She will custom make anything but they are quite expensive. A great website to glean ideas from.

Here is a link that might be useful:

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

Thanks again. Barbara Butler does have some wild designs. Definately expensive but provides some really interesting ideas.

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

Landscape contractor proposed just adding clean fill and top soil, compacting and seeding. Also add some plantings to the edge of the area. Will this hold the soil?

The stream is never high enough to touch the proposed leveled area, but wouldn't the rain cause eventual erosion of the soil?

He agreed the leveling would not harm the pin oaks.

Thanks again.

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

"Also add some plantings to the edge of the area."

It's the plants at the edge that will stabilize the soil and keep it from washing away, but obviously, when they're new, there's a period of time before they will do their job very well. Select plants with this job in mind. Groundcovers seem like the category you'd be most likely to look for.

Check the last two sentences of my first post.

RE: Sloped yard fix and Pin Oaks

Yardvaark - truly appreciate the advice. I just reviewed the ground cover forum and will post for actual planting suggestions.

This is one of 5 landscaping projects for this year... My yard has been neglected since the kids came along...

Thanks again!

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Landscape Design Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here