Return to the Frugal Gardening Forum
| Post a Follow-Up
Tillers
| | |
Posted by simply_divine_joe z8 Pacific NW (My Page) on Mon, Feb 28, 05 at 11:16
| I'm interested in what you all think of 'mini' tillers namely the Mantis.
I hear they are a dependable machine an a good investmest at $300.00.
what do you all you?
kind regards,
simply divine joe |
Follow-Up Postings:
RE: Tillers
| | |
| I've heard both good & bad things about them. I had one many years ago. One of the mini ones. It did a reasonable job tilling up new beds & tilling my smaller established ones. However, I have also heard horror stories about breakdowns of new machines, difficulty finding local places to service them, & terrible customer service from the parent company. You might want to check out the Garden Watchdog website & see what they have to say. |
RE: Tillers
| | |
I have one of the older Mantis Tillers for a number of years now with no problems. I also purchased the dethatching and aerating attachements. I'm kicking myself because last year I purchased a new gas hedge trimmer from Sears when I could have just bought a trimmer attachment for the Mantis. Just didn't think of it at the time. I like my Mantis though I don't know how good the new models are. I've never had a problem startting it. I have always found it a reliable product. If you do purchase one I would recommend getting the wheel attachment so it will stay upright in between use. That was always the biggest problem for me, having to lean it against something while I raked the area just tilled. I no longer use it much anymore, as all the beds in my garden are done the way I like. Now I just use a long handled garden fork to aerate the beds and turn the vegetable beds in the spring. Does less damage to the soil and the earthworms that live there. There are other models to look at, including honda, kowasaki, etc., that are in the same price range as the Mantis. You can check them out at the garden watchdog. Another option is to look into purchasing a used small tiller. Take it to a small engine repair shop for evaluation before buying though, to make sure it's in good working order. This way you won't have to spend a lot of money and it will give you time to decide if you like the tiller or not, or whether you need a bigger one, or none at all. Good luck, whatever you decide. Hope this post helps. |
RE: Tillers
| | |
| The single problem with the Mantis is that you must never leave gasoline in the tank. Use it, drain it. Any gas left in it will gum up the carb and end up costing twice the purchase price in repairs over it's lifespan. I only got this advice in the third year I owned a Mantis. Too late. On the other hand, the electric model looks sweet. |
RE: Tillers
| | |
I love my Mantis Tiller. Got it 3 years ago off of ebay. Brand new with warranty from a wholesaler. Saved about 40%. My only complaint is that it is too hard for me to get started the first time. Once my husband starts and it runs a while I can usually re-start. But then I have never had any luck starting anything that requires a pull. So far I have never had to make any repairs and it gets used quite frequently. We use to till up rows in garden to cut down on weeds during the growing season. Sydneypie |
RE: Tillers
| | |
| I had my Mantis for about 15 years now, and the only complaint is it's a little hard starting. But pulling the cord to start is only a flick of the wrist so its not too bad. They do a great job hilling up potatoes and weeding around plants in the garden. |
RE: Tillers
| | |
I am looking into the Honda mini tiller. #FG100 It got an excellent rating from Consumer Reports. Went and checked it out. Looks like a winner compared to others I have looked at. The Mantis was #7 out of 10. It's rating is Good. Do a search here on gardenweb. I can't remember how I found it...might be in the forum that discusses lawn mowers. They have some good input on tillers. Found not so good ones for Mantis, but great ones for the Honda. This will be my first time buying one so I am checking out all I can. Good luck! ~MamaSpud |
RE: Tillers
| | |
| ~MamaSpud I've looked at other tillers and am a 'Toro' kind of guy. The other day I went to Home depot and decided to rent their Manti Mini Tiller and I was impressed. For a litte machine its a work horse. Although I used it the whole day and filled its gas tank twice it did an excellent job. What you need to be aware of is that the Mantis that I used was a 4 cycle engine type. The gentleman told me that I would be wise to use the 4 speed since it was strong enough to do the tilling that I wanted to do. Accordingly, if I used a 2 cycle that would be for flower beds specifically since it is a smaller engine with less power. A cultivator type machine. Home Depot would sell me one similar to what the factory would ship me however, in terms of assessories the factory would enclude assessories as well. The good part about this would be that HD would put the tiller together where if I received it from the factory I would have to put it together. I have been looking at tillers on ebay and will look again when I have time. They do have some good buys. Thanks for bringing that to my attention! Remember, look out for a 4 cycle engine and you will be pleasantly surprised when it arrives and you begin to use it. Happy hunting, simplydivinejoe |
RE: Tillers
| | |
| Having owned both the Mantis and the Stihl MM-55 I much prefer the Stihl - It is in my opinion a much better machine than the mantis ever was. |
RE: Tillers added
| | |
| One other thing - there is a video you can watch at the stihl website: www.stihl.com altho imho it does not do the machine justice |
RE: gas gumming up carb during storage
| | |
| You should try the gas preservative that stores sell. You put a little in each gallon of gas and it prevents gumming up. Using that prevented 90% of my small engine problems, it really works great. Some of the brands are pink, some are yellow. I use the pink so I can tell if I already put some in the storage tank of gas, since normal gas is light yellow to clear. |
RE: Tillers
| | |
| I've had mine for 4 or 5 years, and think it's great. It took a bit to figure out how to get the best results out of it, but I wouldn't trade it for anything. We have heavy clay--when it's wet, it won't come off a shovel, and when it's dry, you can't get a shovel into it. (dynamite works great, but it's sooo hard to round up all the chunks of clay and put back into the hole...) My mantis has broken up the clay down to about 18 inches. It takes some time, and rockng it side-to-side helps it dig. It WILL bounce, but it doesn't take you with it like some of the big ones do. I learned the hard way to use a weed eater and scalp the grass down to the ground before 'tilling, or you have to keep stopping and unwinding the grass/roots from the tines. The tines are reversible for deep digging or for weed control between garden rows. I purchased mine locally, and they threw in the edger attachment just like the direct order would do. The edger works great for making a slit to put edging materials into. I tried many "pound in" edging materials that broke before they ever got into the ground deep enough to stand up. With the edger attachment, I just wheel it around the shape I want to enclose, then slip the edging down into the slit. I've been lucky with the gas thing, because I've had no problem with it gumming up the carb. Then again, our weather is so screwy during the "winter", I may actually use it in the middle of Dec. or Jan., so it doesn't sit for months at a time. |
RE: Tillers
| | |
| I had one of the mini Troy-built tillers that I bought at a local Lowes or HD store. It was the pits. Starting the thing was an open invite for shoulder dislocation. It wouldn't score into the ground unless I worked the area somewhat loose with the shovel, then it would grind up the loose pieces while bouncing around like a maniac. (Yep,its red clay here) It did work reasonably well as an edger, but as a tiller I can chew the dirt with my teeth faster than it could till. I wouldn't touch another "mini-tiller" even if I was given one. Last year I turned the entire garden area with my landscape shovel. I now have my dad's full size rear tine tiller. It does a good job tilling organic material into the garden beds, and it will break up sod. My goal is to amend my veggie and herb beds to the point where no further tilling is ever needed. I'm reworking my entire veggie and herb garden into a more formal slightly raised bed pattern to start this process. I'll get some pictures of the work in progress....if it ever quits raining. |
Here is a link that might be useful: my gardens
RE: Tillers
| | |
| I bought a full-size rear-tine tiller from Sears a few years ago on a whim -- I went in to get vacuum-cleaner bags and came out with this monster for $200 as a discontinued model. But it takes every bit of strength I have to wrestle that beast around. Last summer I got stuck in traffic with a pawn shop out my right window. After about half an hour, I pulled over, parked and went in -- and they had a Honda four-stroke minitiller still in its original box for about $200. I went home that night and asked the guys on the Toolshed forum the pros and cons of this machine/what I should offer for it -- next afternoon I bought it for $75. Thanks to the TS guys, I expected the difficulties I encountered in assembling it, and knew to buy my own connector bolts since the ones that came with it didn't fit. Not bad at all -- I had it together in only an hour or so, and I am not normally mechanically inclined. This tiller is like having a manic Jack Russell terrier at the end of a leash -- it digs deeper than the big boy does, I can lift it and start it easily, and if it bounces around, it's still controllable. The big boy stays in the shed now except for heavy big projects like initial tilling of a large bed. The Terrier is my tool of choice for digging tree-planting holes or even digging out the foot-wide foundation for the 75 feet of drystone wall I've laid over the last 6 months... By the way, the TS guys will tell you that overtilling is really bad for your soil -- not only does it kill worms, the tines essentially polish the bottom of where they scrape, compacting the base below your loose soil and preventing water percolation. So I till once to loosen the ground and just once more to work in a stack of amendments -- after that things stay loose enough to use the Terrier for individual holes. LynnT |
RE: Tillers
| | |
- Posted by Tyrell Zone 9, CA (My Page) on
Tue, Aug 16, 05 at 10:27
I wish tillers had never been invented. Tilling is simply completely uneccessary. To some, this might sound like a radical new idea, to garden without ever tilling. But there is the simple fact of Nature's Precedent. Plants grew just fine for hundreds of millions of years before we came along. The gas that's now approaching 3 bucks a gallon is made from the remains of prolific plant growth in soil that was never tilled. I've gardened since 1972 without tilling, hoeing, raking, or weeding. I simply mow my lawn, take the bag over to the garden, dump the clippings, and spread them to about 3 inches deep. Even if a rare weed should pop up in the Spring through the scanty remains of last year's mulch, I just cover it with new mulch and say adios. Tillers cost money, use gas, cause air pollution, and need maintenance and repair. I need to mow my lawn anyway, so I'm not using one extra drop of fuel. And by using the clippings in my garden and flower beds, rather than dumping them in the gutter or a supercan like millions still do, I save the energy used to haul them to a dump, too. To paraphrase the old Dial Soap commercial: I sure am glad I garden by the mulch method. And oh how I wish everybody would! |
RE: Tillers
| | |
| I have a old gardenway tiller that im restoring 1970 something.It has a kolar engine and run great , The problem is the tines are missing dose anyone know where i might find a replacement set and how much i should expect to pay? thank you dave wareham ma |
RE: Tillers
| | |
| Tyrell has the right idea, if you're willing to spend $300 on a tiller, you're better off putting that money into purchasing mulch (or finding it free, wood chips from tree trimming services, bagged leaves from your neighbors, etc) and never tilling. You save on maintenance of a tiller, space to store it, hassle of running the tiller, you water less, you weed less, you make less noise/air pollution, you fertilize less (and when you do it stays in your soil longer). Mulching is the easiest way to improve clay soil. Wet conditions are improved by mulch since it increases air space and allows water to soak in better. Dry conditions are made fewer and farther in between because the mulch keeps the clay closer to the optimal wetness level. In time the mulch breaks down into beautiful soil that is incorporated into the clay by worms and other soil organisms. If you are skeptical, try mulching (layers of newspaper + 4-8 inches of wood chips, shredded leaves, etc, depending on material and plants) only part of your garden, and maintaining the rest conventionally. Keep track of how often you have to water each half, and how well the plants do in both. Especially, be sure to mulch again in the fall, and compare the two areas. I bet you will agree that the soil you end up with the following spring does not need tilling and never will again. |
RE: Tillers
| | |
Well, looking through this thread, I"m wondering if I should dump the finished compost on TOP of the garden and leave it there, shovel it in , or til it in? I can't use a tiller due to back and neck troubles. In new vege beds that are srarting this season (raised beds), should I put compost down before adding soil, mix it in or top dress it? I really can't use a tiller any more due to back and neck issues. Nancy |
RE: Tillers
| | |
| My advice to anyone who uses a tiller...is to rent one not buy one. I can rent a mini tiller at my local hardware store for less than $15 for a half day and that includes the gas. It fits easily in the trunk of my Honda Civic so getting it to and fro is no problem. Why buy a machine that will sit in your shed 364 days a year? Just my 2¢ |
RE: Tillers
| | |
| I have a Mantis, and love it. It is great for tilling up spots of red clay and then adding amendments - it takes time to make these spots of red clay workable. it is also great for trenching - ruunning water lines -etc. Last, it is WONDERFUL for turning my compost - in a 4X4 comopst bin. |
|
|
|
|