Insect netting: SWD and Stink Bugs

10 years ago

Last year we had significant SWD (and honey bee) damage for the first time, 2 years ago stink bugs were the problem, and every few years we get Japanese beetle damage.

At the NEVFC conference "Dubois Agrinovation" had a display of "ProtekNet" insect netting. The nets are woven out of UV treated (5 yr) "fishing line", and have different hole sizes, the ones I am looking at are 1 mm X . 85 mm or 1.9mm X 0.95 mm. They can sew them into 36' wide pieces. The price is high, ~$1300 for a 36' X 328' roll which I would cut into 10 nets so $130 per net. Light transmission of 87%, 95% porosity.

The official hole size for SWD exclusion is 1mm X 1mm or less, but I pulled up the original paper and the 1.9mm X 0.95mm excluded 99% or so of the SWD, so it should be sufficient economically.

SInce we already bird net the trees I was thinking of just putting the insect netting over the bird netting as the fruit starts to ripen. The bird netting would protect the insect net from the tree branches.

So, if you could save 10lb of fruit per tree at $3.50/lb, and move the net from early to later ripening varieties on a 3 week schedule, they could pay for themselves the first year.
Since the pesticides which are effective against SWD and stink bugs all have significant PHI's and are costly the savings would be even greater.

What we don't know is how the nets would effect brown rot and whether you can spray thru the net. Will the nets increase humidity to much? will the rain plug the holes in the net preventing drying off? The nets increase the temp inside by a couple of degrees, reduce time to harvest, and may reduce color according to the article (which was on blueberries).

So I am asking your opinions, or if you know of someone who has tried this.

Eric

Comments (4)

olpea
10 years ago
Plum,

I once tried to use shade cloth to see if it would keep birds off of peach trees. It was a 50% UV cloth (allowed 50% sunlight). The biggest problem with peaches was that they were noticeably less sweet with the shade cloth.

The other problem was that it was hard to keep on the tree. It was a big piece of shade cloth, and I tried to keep it weighted down, but the wind always wanted to take it off. Unlike bird netting (which hooks on the shoots) the shade cloth was smooth enough it would blow off easily.

I tried the shade cloth on some trellised blackberries (for bird control). I tied the cloth to the trellis, so it stayed on better. But it caused another problem. The cloth caused the blackberries to get too hot. It cooked the berries under the cloth.

The holes on your netting are bigger, and look like they will release more heat (and probably stay on the trees better).

I guess my question, would it be enough to control SWD? I've noticed non-SWD fruit flies love to remain under the canopy of fruit trees (where it's shaded). If enough SWD could get through or under the net, would they have their own protected environment under the tree?
drew51 SE MI Z5b/6a
10 years ago
I looked into this myself. i found a site that sells smaller pieces, and they claim no thermal effect.
I was thinking of putting PVC or conduit piping around my raspberries, and using pipe clamping (They make it for nets to use with PVC) to secure a net.

Here is a link that might be useful: SFG Supply
Related Professionals
Ballenger Creek Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Kenmore Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Mount Wilson Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Blue Springs Landscape Contractors · Davidson Landscape Contractors · East Patchogue Landscape Contractors · Edinburg Landscape Contractors · Fairfield Landscape Contractors · Fruit Heights Landscape Contractors · Hayden Landscape Contractors · Hoffman Estates Landscape Contractors · North Ridgeville Landscape Contractors · Ronkonkoma Landscape Contractors · San Pedro Landscape Contractors · Merrifield Landscape Contractors
mrsg47
10 years ago
Drew your site is interesting and I bookmarked it for future reference. The weaves seem quite tight and my only thought is that spray (fungicides would have a hard time getting through). Mrs. G
drew51 SE MI Z5b/6a
10 years ago
I agree Mrs G. I don't need it...yet, just preparing if the SWD comes along. And I need a way to remove easily to spray and such. I would not try to spray through it. I don't have a drip system, so even watering would be difficult for my set up. I would consider setting up a system for watering, but I'm moving within 5 years at most, 2 years at least. I will look into watering systems once the move is over. Well I'm going to have a ton of plants to plant, and replace with orders. But I will have enough room to put in whatever I want, i can't wait!