Return to the Fruit & Orchards Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
are fuyu & jiro persimmons the same?

Posted by bhawkins 7b, 8a (My Page) on
Sun, May 27, 07 at 21:25

i planted a fuyu because its my korean wife's favorite even though texas a&m said it was marginal for 7b/8a. & then i planted a jiro because i saw many people talk about what a great tree it was & it was supposedly hardy in 7.

i see on the raintree website they say its the same tree?

i must say they look very similar.

???


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: are fuyu & jiro persimmons the same?

I'll say they are not the same.

From Persimmon Fruit Facts :

Jiro
Fruit large. Resembles Fuyu, but more truncated and squarish in cross-section. Skin orange-red. Flavor and quality excellent. Ripens late October and early November, ships well. Often sold as Fuyu. Tree slightly upright. Most popular nonastringent variety in California.

Fuyu (Fuyugaki)
Medium-large oblate fruit, faintly four-sided. Skin deep orange. Flesh light orange, sweet and mild. Ripens late. Keeps well and is an excellent packer and shipper. Tree vigorous, spreading, productive. Most popular nonastringent cultivar in Japan.


 o
RE: are fuyu & jiro persimmons the same?

Not to blame raintree there, but the original people marketing these fruits also thought there were only 2 types of oriental persimmons. The non-astringent type they call all of them Fuyu and the astringent types are called hachiyas. Simple to describe, simple to print, simple to sell! So if it is Jiro, Ogosho, Fuyu, Hana Fuyu, Matsumoto Wase, they are sold as Fuyu. No tongue twisting challenging names for the English speakers!

We should strive to correct that there are more than 200 types of oriental persimmons alone, and several dozen of selected (or bred) types of American persimmons too. We even have several popular American by Oriental persimmon hybrids, and of course the name of those are more comfortable to the English speakers.

I have about 43 DIFFERENT kinds of persimmons grafted together in one tree and sure enough there are significant differences among them, from flower sizes to fruit color, taste, and ripening stages. My fruit harvest starts as early as mid August and it lasts until Christmas.

Anyway, here's my computer generated description from my own software:
Jiro
Other names include Ziro. The tree produces medium sized fruits. Firm ripe fruits can be eaten fresh. Non-astringent type regardless of pollination. A pollination constant non astringent (PCNA) type. Fruit shape is flat, with a squarish cross section. Best time to harvest is when fruits have dark-orange skin color. When ripe, flesh is orange-yellow in color when pollinated. Sugar content of the fruit is medium. It has rounded seeds that are medium to large sized. Cold storage of fruits are not recommended. The female flowers are medium sized. Cultivar originated from Japan. The fruits after cold storage have good taste quality. It flowers are of the intermediate type. It bears female flowers only. Tree ripened fruits have poor to fair taste. An intermediately vigorous tree. Its fruits ripen intermediately in the season. This plant is mainly used for fruit production. Frost resistance is low. Fruit production has high reliability. Fruits are primarily used as dessert. It has medium parthenocarpic fruit sets. It has none or very low grafting compatibility on Diospyrus lotus rootstock.

Fuyu
Sometimes called Fuyugaki. It produces medium sized fruits. A pollination constant non astringent (PCNA) type. Fruit shape is flat, with a roundish to squarish cross section. Best time to harvest is when fruits have orange-red to red skin color. When ripe, flesh is red-orange in color when pollinated. Sugar content of the fruit is medium. It has sub-triangular seeds that are medium to large sized. It has very good grafting compatibility on Diospyrus lotus rootstock. It flowers are of the intermediate type. Cultivar originated from Japan. Fruit production has high reliability. An intermediately vigorous to a vigorous tree. Tree ripened fruits have poor to fair taste. Cold storage of fruits are recommended. It has low to medium parthenocarpic fruit sets. The fruits after cold storage have good taste quality. Its fruits ripen intermediately to late in the season. Frost resistance is medium. It bears female flowers only. This cultivar is mainly used for fruit production. The female flowers are medium sized. Fruits are primarily used as dessert.


 o
RE: are fuyu & jiro persimmons the same?

I also got caught in the same thing, I bought a Fuyu from Bay Laurel but after getting it I noticed in the description they said "Fuyu ('Jiro')", so I really got a Jiro I guess. I recall something about how Jiro is supposed to be easier to grow, don't recall why though. I think that is why Bay Laurel sells Jiro and not Fuyu.

There is a similar naming problem with the PVNA types; "Maru" and "Chocolate" have been used as generic names for that type of persimmon. I have one of each name and am waiting for fruit to see how they compare - maybe they will be the same.

Scott


 o
RE: are fuyu & jiro persimmons the same?

Then there is Real Fuyu - while there are many Fuyu sold all over the USA, most are not the real deal. The real Fuyu is the original Fuyu from Japan and was obtained from the USDA germplasm. This real Fuyu will not be compatible on D. lotus rootstock. Many nursery that sells Fuyu are on D. lotus rootstock and are not the real Fuyu if you checked that they are on D. lotus rootstock.


 o
RE: are fuyu & jiro persimmons the same?

i was sold a bare potted fuju persimmon (labeled jiro) at a great nursery in Jan. 2011, and it has already become a beautiful tree. Unfortunately, the fruits are no more than 1/2 in. in diameter. Taste sort of like fuju, but pretty useless for eating. The leaves are much darker and thinner than the hachya persimmon I bought at the same time. These were the same size when purchased, but the jiro is twice as big 2 1/2 yrs. after planting. I'm so disappointed, though the tree is prettier than the hachya.

Also, though I did mulch the soil well, I've never fertilized the tree, and have only watered once all year. Does anyone know what this is? Photo below. Thanks for your help!
Culver City, CA 90232 (West side of LA)

This post was edited by diaph on Sat, Aug 17, 13 at 20:27


 o
RE: are fuyu & jiro persimmons the same?

Photo of the mystery jiro fruits.

Also, will it get huge (no room for a huge tree)--it's grown about 4 ft. this year--ca. 9 ft tall. Yikes! Should I take it out and get a real fuju?

Thanks again for your help!

This post was edited by diaph on Sat, Aug 17, 13 at 20:29


 o
RE: are fuyu & jiro persimmons the same?

I think that is fruit from your rootstock, the grafted tree likely died. Pretty sure it is not American persimmon, doesn't look like Kaki either I would think that is likely Lotus. Either graft it over or replace it.


 o
RE: are fuyu & jiro persimmons the same?

Thanks so much, strudeldog, for your prompt reply. This info helps tremendously!


 o
RE: are fuyu & jiro persimmons the same?

Thanks so much, strudeldog, for your prompt reply. This info helps tremendously!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Fruit & Orchards Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here