Return to the Fruit & Orchards Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Organic options for Brown Rot?

Posted by franktank232 z5 WI (My Page) on
Tue, Jun 25, 13 at 17:38

I'm really worried...i just got done ripping all the sweet cherries off my trees...from horrible cracking, to non stop brown rot..it was ugly... buried everything. I plan on cutting down 2 of the trees (out of 3)... Not so sure sweet cherries like 15 inches of rain in 50 days.

Speaking of brown rot, any organic solutions to at least reduce it some? I'm worried a lot about the plums, peaches, and pluots that so far look fine..

I found this article about calcium sprays:
link


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Frank, thats an interesting article I had not seen, thanks for the link. There is no silver bullet for preventing brown rot organically, if you look at that study for example it reduces infection by something like half. I have found sulphur to be the best option overall, and Serenade and Saf-T-Side oil also provide some help. I think its good to mix it up and also combine where possible. I usually do Serenade and Saf-T-Side together. Sulphur is not compatible with oil so I do that on its own. It sounds like calcium would also be a good thing to throw into the tank.

Along with the sprays a very open pruning regimen plus making sure the stone fruit trees are planted in full sun is important. Plus gently pick off any fruits that are rotting to keep the spore count down.

This year I am sort of giving up and using a propiconazole spray or two. I don't have the time to do all the organic brown rot sprays, you need to keep it up all summer.

Scott


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Scott-

I think i want to try this calcium spray, but have no idea what to use. I have a bottle of sulfur, so i'm good there.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

I've been meaning to post this for a while. I heard while visiting EL a few months ago that they're having nice but very prelim results using Regalia (OMRI) for brown rot. I believe it stimulates the plant's natural immune defenses against disease.

So far I'm not having brown rot issues (young trees, resistant varieties, early picking off the rare brown rotted fruit) but I will give Regalia a try when it becomes an issue in a couple seasons. The data on it seem a bit mixed (UC Davis data vs the company's own data?) but either way I think it is worth considering unless someone already has had poor results with it?

$99 for 1 gallon preorder at GrowOrganic. Mix @ 3 Tbs/gal.

Here is a link that might be useful: Regalia company site


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Hmmmmm....looks a little out of my price range... a combo of sulfur plus calcium might just do it for what i need...i'd really like to spray the donut peaches and the pluots.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Frank, you need some foliar calcium. One source is below, I just bought some and I will be using it. This is a large quantity, sometimes its hard to find backyard quantities of these chemicals.

The only positive studies I have found on Regalia are the company ones so I'm a bit hesitant to spring for that. Studies are important because each year varies a huge amount in terms of how much rot there is and you need some controls side by side to see how its doing. Either that or try it yourself with your own control..

Scott

Here is a link that might be useful: 7 Springs foliar calcium


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Persian,what is EL? and the meaning of all of your other abbrevs. help us newbies understand thanks.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

With so many universities now evaluating organic controls it's probably worth it to wait for a more objective evaluation.

Years ago I believed that the organic movement was reliably ethical as far as companies promoting products. That was years ago. I think it was probably a realistic assessment back in the '60s. Now organic has it's own "industrial complex".

I agree with Scott that the article about calcium sprays is very interesting. At some sites brown rot is a kind of a borderline problem with many stone fruits so this might be a breakthrough. The calcium could probably be applied with the two post petal fall sprays. I may start putting some in the tank.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Very good points especially about organic becoming an industry. I understand the reluctance with the mixed data too--especially considering who is coincidentally having the better results--the company itself as opposed to the universities. Plus it's pricey. But if it actually works that would be great. And maybe we won't need much if not crazy infested...

I'll be staying tuned to hear how it continues to perform for the good folks in EL. They seemed pretty excited about their results so far.

MrsG apologies for the abbreviations. EL refers to the nursery Edible Landscaping in Afton, VA. OMRI refers to its organic status. UC Davis is University of California in Davis which is pretty active in the US academic fruit world.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

PersianMD2Orchard wrote: "UC Davis is University of California in Davis which is pretty active in the US academic fruit world."

And is the school where my daughter played basketball! (Just thought I'd throw that in)

I have horrible problems with Brown rot on my Necs and Peaches. Monterey Fungi fighter works very well but is not organic. Without it, I lose 60-80% of my fruit.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Score!

:-)

Scott


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Thanks for the pic. Brought a big grin to my face.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Frank,
Tilt or Bumper which are propiconizole based fungicides are listed for stone fruit and a qt. would be very reasonable for the home orchard. I use it commercially but after seeing it has brown rot on it's label it will be sprayed on my fruit trees. My green gage plums and flat peaches are 95% lost to brown rot every year.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

nevermind on regalia, update is performance poor this season although it was exceptionally wet


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

I don't spray anything for brown rot. I've found that a regimen of
proper orchard hygiene eliminates brown rot for me. Last year, I had a lot of brown rot on my apples, because i didn't properly maintain my orchard. This year, I have, and I've had VERY minimal brown rot.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

I tried the clean-up method and it didn't work for me. On apples I can believe it could help but on rot prone stone fruits its much harder.

PersianMD, thanks for the report on the Regalia.

Scott


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Up here rots on apples are usually of minimal concern. It is stonefruit that has me spraying in summer.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

When I grew watermelon commercial I had problem with blossom end rot so calcium after bloom. Then grew tomatoes field pick your own by 5 gallon bucket blossom end rot sprayed at 100% bloom. Later I grew Peaches they rot on end I called blossom end rot so sprayed all with calcium that was end of my blossom end rot.
When came on line in 2001 Peach blossom end rot was called Brown Rot. On peaches I spray at complete pedal fall and 2 spray after 7 days each. On acre tomatoes it takes one quart per spray of liquid calcium I buy liquid form calcium in 2 1/2 gallon jug about ever 5 years keep calcium from freezing important and settling I keep in closet shakeup twice year plus before use in spring seem to work. I mix quart in 25 gallon sprayer thats more than need now but spray all out flower grass and shade trees they get left overs.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Gator, you do three calcium sprays total on peaches all season then? I will be doing calcium in every peach/plum spray next spring but I'm not sure how much to do during summer.

Scott


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

The orchard hygiene has worked for me on all my stone fruits
and apples and pears.
You can achieve the same results with blossom end rot, without having to spray, by feeding calcium nitrate to your fruit trees and melons. I did it this year for the first time, and have had no blossom end rot at all.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Rayrose, what varieties of stonefruit do you grow? Are we talking normally wet seasons? Hard to believe that calcium could be such an all out panacea and not well utilized in commercial production as calcium sprays are a very common prescription for apples. But everything has some point of being discovered, maybe this was somehow overlooked even if I can't imagine how.

Maybe I will test it out on one of my nectarine trees.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

I grow peaches, plums, nectarines, apples, pears, figs, watermelons, cantaloupe, blueberries, and tomatoes. The only thing that got blossom end rot with the calcium nitrate was the tomatoes, but I fixed that with 1/2 gallon of milk, which I fed to my 5 plants. Works every time. We had a very wet and cold spring, which created a lot of pollination problems. Poor bees didn't know whether to come or go. I fed all of my trees with calcium nitrate (15.5-0-0) in march and will do it again in august. No other fertilizer. Also tilled it into my melon patches in march and side dressed with it, when the plants started to run. Did the same thing with the tomatoes, but obviously tomatoes are calcium pigs, so hence the milk.
One thing that has helped with the melons, is that I have lots of bees, and tons of blooms, and haven't seen one poorly pollinated melon yet. I have 2 melon patches with 140 hills of melons and 16 hills of cantaloupe.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Scott
I do three sprays with calcium when there good many pebal fall on ground. I watch for PC and OFM flite while spraying 1st spray I use a pressure washer to spray trees this blow any moth into flite thats in tree if see any refill tank and spray Permethrin. 7 days later spray calcium again if see moth Permethrin again third spray 14 days after first cover spray. I do spray more than the 3 because of watermelons tomatoes and cantaloupe in garden I spray all garden crops and fruit nut trees. I only think early sprays are helpful, but hard pick time by calendar.
My Peach crop ends by June 1st I don't have chill hours for any summer Peaches after June 21st .


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

My soil always has lots of calcium (and K) as I spread firewood ash to keep the pH near 7. Doesn't seem to help my brown rot but maybe the spray would. High calcium in soil does not at all assure it in the fruit, as I understand it.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

 photo calcium.jpg

I came across some calcium chloride...probably a rip off for the amount, but it looks to be very soluble in water...yet i have no idea how much to use (say per gallon)...


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

I'm surprised it has a freshness code.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

This made me remember that I have some calcium chloride, its added to cider to keeve it. I bought it from some mushrooming store, see link below. Mushroom growers use it to dry out mushrooms. This stuff is in larger quantity than your little canister, Frank.

Some website I found says 3-4 lbs per 100 gallons, so do the math - half an ounce or so by weight per gallon.

I wished I had thought of this, the calcium stuff I bought was really expensive and I have a couple pounds of the stuff below in my basement.

I wonder what commercial growers use, pure CaCl2 or some other formulation.

Scott

Here is a link that might be useful: Calcium Chloride pellets


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Working off memory from looking into it for bitter pit last year....

Calcium chloride is the cheapest source but is an extremely corrosive salt... tough on gear, fences, etc and I believe a higher potential for foliar damage if mix or conditions off. Up here here they spray it on dirt roads in summer for dust reduction (pulls humidity from air) and on all the roads in winter (continues to melt ice at lower temps than sodium chloride) but man does it eat up the cars!

I know I saved a link with a lot of good info but can't find it now...I think it was out of University of Michigan.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

My little container is 5.5 oz...so that should cover me for awhile. I won't need much..i'm going to cover the plums tonite.

I know i've seen it used as road salt..just would imagine it would be chunks of it ...would need to crush it somehow or dissolve it in water for awhile?

Corrosive on cars? just what we need up here...i've seen 5 year old cars with rust.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Doing a little more research and it looks like thyme oil has a lot of anti-fungal activity... Not sure how exactly you would mix it and if any off flavors would result...but its another possibility...

link

I would think a few sprays of sulfur (4?) and 6? sprays of calcium chloride would really knock back the rot... I'm not looking for 100% coverage, but it would be nice to get my pluots through so i can actually eat some ripe fruit.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Scott-

Have you sprayed yet? What about just mixing lime and water? I plan on spraying the calcium chloride tonite.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Another organic possibility may be increasing Si levels in the trees. Study have shown that Si carbonate applied to row crops worked about as well or better than fungicides for many crops (melons, squash etc). It may work on fruit trees as well.

It has been quite a while since I read that article, so you'd have to do some research to find the quantities they were applying. But it seems like a real possibility and probably worth a try if you can find a source of Si.


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

I found this about mix rates...this shows 1.5 to 2lbs per 100 gallons..this maybe what Scott was reading:

link

I'm going to spray the plums and apples...it looks like many light sprays is better then heavy sprays...


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

Frank, I found the calcium chloride rate on some random website (Colorado I think).. I haven't had a chance to spray yet, its been raining non-stop. Hopefully tomorrow.

Scott


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

I think this was the link I mentioned previously ...UNiversity of Wa not michigna

Here is a link that might be useful: nutrient sprays for fruit


 o
RE: Organic options for Brown Rot?

That sucks about the rain. Its turned very hot and dry here...a lot of my lawn is all brown...this being a huge change from the 15 inches of precip that fell in May/June... I hope it continues!

Any idea of sulfur and calcium chloride can be mixed?

I figured about .33 oz per 1 gallon on the CaCl.. I'm going to try weekly sprays..hopefully it doesn't burn anything... None of my pluots are nearing ripening...so i got a lot of time left before they turn...same with the plums.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Fruit & Orchards Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here