Return to the House Plants Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

Posted by suntower z5 WA (My Page) on
Mon, Jun 25, 12 at 2:15


We've had about six of these things over the years. I forget their name, but they're an incredibly common houseplant and we've NEVER been able to get it to grow.

What always happens is... they start out with lots of leaves at the bottom and then, little by little, the leaves start dropping from the bottom. New leaves keep coming out the top but the lowest leaves start to get dry edges. And then at some point they fall off where they join the stem. So eventually, the thing has a few fresh little leaves at the top and lots of missing things on the stem.

We try soaking, misting. We can't see any visible 'bugs'.

1. What are they called?

2.What do we have to do to get them to thrive? I'm assuming it's either a humidity issue or some micro-bug or... WHAT?

Or are these just plants that cannot exist in a house with central heating?

Is there hope?


Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

Here's the picture... didn't upload properly.

RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a mid-MI (My Page) on
    Mon, Jun 25, 12 at 8:55

It looks like you're over-watering, but over-fertilizing could also be the culprit. Both conditions impair the plant's ability to take up and efficiently move water, which is what causes the necrosis at leaf tips & margins. It's difficult to determine how the blame should be distributed. A portion of it belongs to you (for over-watering) and a portion to the soil (for being too water-retentive). Heavy (water-retentive) soils are very unforgiving of over-watering, while fast draining/porous soils can increase your margin for error to the point where over-watering is almost impossible, and they have the very significant advantage of being able to offer a much healthier environment for healthy roots.

All healthy plants start with a healthy root system. Without happy roots, a happy plant is impossible. Roots are the heart of the plant, but unless the importance of a healthy root system is pointed out, it often gets no consideration at all. Your soil is the foundation of every conventional container planting. You can make/use a soil that you can rely on to work FOR you and your plants, or you can choose on you'll be fighting against for the entire life of the planting.

To me, the choice is clear. I've posted hundreds of pictures of perfectly healthy plants - not a blemished leaf to be seen. I'm not saying that as a boast, because I give credit to a good soil and nutritional supplementation program - not to any special ability or a magical green thumb. Learn how to tell the difference between a good soil and a middling/poor soil, and you'll have taken a giant step forward in your quest for the ability to keep plants happy.

If you'd like to invest a little time, I think the reward for your effort will be well worth it. The links I left below should provide you with information you can put to use immediately. If you're willing to follow some simple instructions, your plant is still salvable. It can't be restored to perfect condition overnight, but by this time next year, you could have a plant that's been turned completely around.

What do you think?


RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

What is the identity of the plant?

RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a mid-MI (My Page) on
    Mon, Jun 25, 12 at 14:23

Hard to tell - maybe Castanospermum australe.


RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

I'm pretty sure it's a 'Croton'.

What I'm -not- sure of is how to get it to -live-!

I see all kinds of conflicting ideas on care: don't water too much. Water a lot. Keep moist. Keep warm. Not too warm.

There's -gotta- be some reliable 'trick' to this, right?

RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

I don't think this is a Croton (Codaeum), unless the curly leafed one & likely quite neglected if it is (sorry).

Crotons have some really specific care requirements, I've grown them well indoors (didn't have conflicting advice or problems).

Does this plant exude white sap when cut? Have you checked it closely for insects? I think I see white dots on some of its leaves.

We need better pix of the plant, perhaps one from above to tell what it is.

FYI, lower leaves dropping off a stem is not always abnormal (a bit like shedding hair), the older (bottom most) leaves go first.

RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

  • Posted by tapla z5b-6a mid-MI (My Page) on
    Mon, Jun 25, 12 at 16:28

I forgot to leave the links.

If you take cacti out of the mix, almost all plants respond very well to pretty much the same conditions. A soil that is damp (not soggy) after you water and a well-considered nutritional supplementation program. The largest variation is probably in light needs/tolerance. I have hundreds of different plants, all growing in the same soil and watered/fertilized the same way - all very healthy.

This link covers the basics anyone growing plants in containers should understand.

This one is specifically about the air:water relationship in soils. Taking the time to read and understand what's in these threads should put you in a position well advanced from where you are now.


RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret? need to post more pics...upright pics. lol. It's difficult trying to ID, sideways.

RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

FWIW: I am now 100% sure this is a 'Croton'. The leaf edges get papery... then after a few weeks the leave falls off at the joint. Again, new leaves develop at the top but over time the thing goes from being a 'bush' to a very feeble 'palm tree'.

I'm assuming that even if it gets 'healthy' it will -never- regrow leaves down that the bottom where they've already dropped, right?

RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

What I haven't seen mentioned or asked is this: what kind of light is this plant getting? I agree that it is a curly/twisty leafed croton. IME, crotons need to be in bright indirect light, like a southern window. Deviate from that and they drop leaves like crazy.
Don't soak, don't mist. Get it into a faster draining soil (yours is very heavy), water 'til you see it draining out the drainage holes and don't water again until the top inch of soil is dry.


RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

Why so sure it's a Croton? The papery leaf edges are a sign of not enough watering. My experience indoors w/ Crotons was as much bright light as possible & a lot of water (but MUST have very fast draining mix). I did always keep it on a pebble tray, I'm sure that helped a lot.

I've been able to grow them well indoors, cut them back to soil level when grew taller than I could accommodate & had them grow back in completely, full & lush.

RE: Leaves Always Fall Off. What's The Secret?

Suntower..If your plant is a Croton, the answer is no to your question regarding new growth on the bottom.

However, once you get it going, you'll have a pretty, Croton tree.

Is it possible to summer outdoors? You won't believe the difference between summering outside and keeping indoors.

Fresh, circulating air is important, otherwise, pests, especially spider mites, choose Croton as a home.

I haven't placed my Croton outside this year, 'mainly due to ants.' It's showing a huge difference, too.

Bright light..Crotons do not need direct sun. When grown outdoors year round, they adapt to full sun. As an indoor plant setting out in direct light can scorch leaves. Even after acclimation. Two of my Crotons died for this very reason.
Small-Medium Crotons endure bright, indirect light. Large, established Crotons, grown outdoors year round do well in full sun.
Soil, well-draining but fertile.
Fertilize, once a month during growing season with an All-Purpose or balanced fertilizer. Eg. 5-10-5 or 10-10-10
Temps. Crotons will thrive between 50-80F degrees, give or take a few either way.
Watering. Water throughly. In summer, soil should be kept moist, 'not muddy.'
Winter, soil must dry between waterings.

Fresh air is required throughout the year.

They need humidity, so mist daily, place on stones w/water just beneath the pot, and/or add a humidifer to your home.

Good luck, Toni

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the House Plants Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here