Return to the House Plants Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

Posted by purpleinopp 8b AL (My Page) on
Wed, Jul 11, 12 at 15:27

I know this is old school, but I have a passage of text from a book to consider, not a link. Unfortunately the book seems entirely focused on outdoor in-ground planting, but this general info should also be relevant to plants in pots. The blue part is copied from Variegated Plants; The Encyclopedia of Patterned Foliage by Susan Conder:

Variegated plants originate naturally as random seedlings, or as sports - mutant variegated shoots on otherwise plain green plants. Some, such as Abutilon pictum 'Thompsonii', are virus-induced, in the same way that the streaked colours of 'Bizarre' tulips result from a harmless virus.

In red-or purple-variegated plants, chlorophyll, the green pigment responsible for photosynthesis and vital for non-parasitic plants' survival, is masked by other pigments, anthocyanins. Yellow and white variegations are caused by imperfect or absent chloroplasts, the granule-like plastids within a cell which contain chlorophyll.

In a white- or yellow-edged leaf, the green pigment functions normally in the inner layer of leaf cells, but the outer layer lacks chloroplasts, making the edges white, or contains a preliminary version of chlorophyll, protochlorophyll, creating yellow.

A yellow- or white-centered leaf, with green edges, has a defective inner layer of leaf cells. The attractive pink, red or russet spring flushes that some variegated leaves have result from anthocyanins protecting the vulnerable new growth from harsh ultraviolet light rays. Autumnal flushes result from an accumulation of sugar in the leaf tissues, caused by a drop in night temperatures which triggers the production of anthocyanins and anthoxanthins.

(All great stuff, but here's where I think it gets really interesting - and useful.)

The intensity of leaf colour is affected by the amount of light available. There are exceptions, but generally, variegated plants with glaucous foliage, such as rue and certain hostas, tolerate more sun than all-green kinds. Those with purple, maroon and brown variegations colour most intensely in sun, often becoming dirty green in shade. Yellow-variegated leaves colour best in full sun or light shade. White- and cream-variegated leaves, such as variegated apple mint, tend to prefer shade, especially where the soil is dry. With those that are happy in sun or shade, variegation is often sharpest in sun, but if it is combined with dry soil, smaller leaves and more compact growth result."

So, in a nutshell, some plants are more colorful or pronounced in shade and others in more sun. So which plants do you have that are as colorful as "the pictures out there?" And what is their sun situation? Any other general variegation comments? I love the way the same Coleus plants will look totally different in sun vs. shade.

For the 2 kinds of Dracaena marginata trees I have, I've seen the best colors with more sun, a few hours direct, time of day doesn't seem to matter.

I don't know if my older Sans leaves faded because that's what old leaves always do or from not enough sun for years at a time periodically. This year I put them out in a ton of sun and they are making tons of babies that are very distinctly variegated, so pretty and not the boring plant I thought it was all this time.

The maroon-ish Tradescantia zebrina I have seems to get darker in full sun but the grayish-green stripes get lost. When in enough shade to see the lines clearly, the overall color looks faded to me. I'd say this one depends on preference and available locations.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

Purple, it's ironic you brought up the subject. It's a subject I've been pondering over a lot lately.

Since plant book #1, most authors wrote, 'variegated plants need more light than non-variegated.'

But, I disagree. To a point

It depends on the plant. Of course, at the moment, I can't think of any examaples except Talinum/Jewel or Opar and variegated palms. Direct sun only burns these plants.
Certain variegated Orchids and Sans pale instead of pronounce creams and yellows.

Let's see...variegated Ficus colors are more pronounced in full/direct sun.

Ivy is another example. A couple Ivy leaves are pure white, yet getting less sun now than during winter and spring.

Dracaenas 'Stripped' do better in lower light..white/cream is vivid..when one Dracaena in particular got more light, reverted to green..

There are other examples, but I've got things to do. Dinner, etc.

Like they say, variegated plants are actually problem or deformed plants.


 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

Hey Purple,

Pls. tell us the copyright year of this info, as this could be quite old & science has progressed a lot in recent years, especially in some of these areas.

FYI: the Sans markings to which you refer are not regarded as variegations, just markings.

Variegation in a Sans. is very definite looking, let's see if I can find one of my own examples.

See how this variegation is distinctly striped?

Photobucket

Many folks don't actually believe that Toni, that variegated plants are 'deformed'.

From what I read & hear, some folks believe variegation is virus induced, some believe it's part of the characteristics in the plant's DNA, I'm not informed enough to really know, but tend to lean to the DNA answer rather than that of virus.


 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

There's much more to that section of the book, but it basically says there are different causes of different types of variegation, some virus, some genetic. I don't know enough about it to debate the science or question any of the info, but just thought it would make an interesting introduction for relating variegation experiences.

This is a beautiful coffee table book 1994. I bought it for the pictures. The author is from England and her credentials are as an author with no mention of any formal scientific education. I've always assumed she correctly related the science part to the best of her knowledge with info available at the time... but who knows? The book is written about outdoor gardening with temperate plants, as mentioned above. I don't know enough about the science to know if the same info applies to tropical plants or not. Feel free to add any modern enlightenment, anyone!

Wiki article on variegation has some similar info and touches on some other types of variegation. I wonder why Sans folks don't refer to the colors as variegation? According to Wiki and dictionary.com, they're variegated.


 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

Karen, nice Sans..Very pretty colors.

I don't believe variegation is deformed, an anomaly or induced by virus either.

After reading this thread, I Googled. Most authors start a variegation article by saying, 'variegation can occur for a number of reasons.'

Does anyone really know why plants are variegated? Is it similar to, who came first, the chicken or the egg?


 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

This kind of sums it up...
Variegation is usually the result of a cell mutation, and can be inherited (genetic) or occur randomly (chimeric). If genetic the variegation is usually stable, which means that if you propagate a green shoot from a plant with colored leaves or sow its seed, the coloring will reappear in the new plant. This applies both to green leaves with irregular variegation, say in white and yellow, and to those of a single solid color such as gold or purple.
A random mutation usually shows up as variegation. If you propagate from a green shoot or sow seed of the plant, the color will not recur. This kind of variegation is the most common but is often difficult to stabilize. Propagation must be from variegated or colored shoots. In nature these forms usually die out, being weaker growers because of the lack of chlorophyll, which plants use to make the food they need for growth.
Variegation can also be the result of a viral infection, showing as discolored veins or leaf areas. This form of variegation is relatively rare, but it is stable. A lot of variegated Camelias are the result of viruses.


 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

To Quote Toni;
"Since plant book #1, most authors wrote, 'variegated plants need more light than non-variegated.'
But, I disagree. To a point "

Many variegated plants do need more light than their normally colored counterparts however that does not necessarily mean an intense change such as from shade to direct sun. It could just be a closer location to a light source or a brighter room in the house. I guess that amounts to the same thing but you should get the idea.


 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

Hey Danny!!! How've you been?

Yes, I agree, many variegated plants need brighter, 'not necessarly intense sun,' to keep colors.

On certain occassions, either a plant/s were intentionally set in total shade, or accidently fell behind a shelf w/o my knowledge.
Once discovered, variegation was more colorful than when getting light.

I have two variegated Orchids..Phalaenopsis...one gets natural sun, the second under artificial lights..
The Phal in lower light is more pronounced..the orchid in bright-indirect lost variegation. The sun isn't harsh.

Same with some Philodendrons/Monsteras/Marantas/Stromanthes/Ctentanthes/Stromanths
.
However, all/most plants need light, whether it's dark shade or direct sun. Toni


 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

Virtually all reliable sources have been pretty consistent for a long time in explaining that variegated plants require more light than their all-green counterparts. And, of course, more light does not necessarily mean direct sun.

No one has mentioned the flip-side to this. The best low light plants are usually dark green in color. Examples are Dracaena Janet Craig, Aspidistra, Jade Pothos and Peace Lily.

~Will


 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

Dracaena deremensis seems to have much better color with significant amounts of direct sun.

Tradescantia spathacea looks much better, with wider, more colorful stripes since I backed it up some into more shade (just AM sun now.)

Can't get Cordyline fruticosa to make that pretty pinkish/purple stripe no matter where I put it.

Still looking for ideal exposure for the tiny pink Syngoniums I dug-up from the yard earlier this year.


 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

When you think about it from a phsyics point of view, a dark leaf will be more absorbent/less reflective, so it stands to reason will be able to function in lower light.

In my experience, though, it seems to be the least "interesting"/perceived to be original varieties that take the lowest light.

D. Marginata is a good example - D. Magenta is slightly darker than the basic version and yet seem to need more light. Ditto, Sansverieria Laurentii (with the yellow edged leaves) will take lower light than S. Zeylanica (with the plain green leaves).


 o
RE: Variegation

It's been a while since this discussion started, so I have some follow-ups on the plants I was working with when I last posted. Most of the plants giving me trouble eventually found spots with no direct light at all and finally started to look great. Syngonium, Cordyline fruticosa, Tradescantia spathacea, Maranta, Dracaena surculosa, and Dracaena braunii (formerly sanderiana, AKA lucky bamboo) look their best when only in shade here (while outside for summer.)

A Columnea is making me crazy. When I got it, it had pretty pink tints but although it's grown a lot, the pinkness has been MIA. After being inside in an east window for a couple months, there's a slight bit of pink on some leaf veins, mostly on the bottom of leaves. I'm going to try a little less sun this summer, dappled, under a tree.

I got some variegated Tradescantia fluminensis last summer but I think all that's left is reversions unless some survives outside. All of the pots for sale had plain green sections in them, I'm not surprised this happened. Has anyone kept one of these with the pretty stripes for a long time?

I don't have any same plants in both variegated and non-, so don't have any of those comparisons to offer. Who does?

What's going on with your variegated plants?


 o
RE: Variegation, which plants for more light, which for less

that's a very interesting subject.
i have mostly tropicals indoors and some go out to ultra bright NE balcony outside. lots of variegation.
i think indoor culture is quite different from outdoor and season to season and latitude - just all very complicated!
what i found is that a lot of time recommendations for these plants are from southern growers ... for outdoors! (FL). bright shade in summer in fl = bright dappled sun on the window sill for me in NYC. seasonal light differs a lot too.
so while i put my plants in some early sun, NE bright shade(no sun) outside in summer, in winter they stay in dappled sun west window or even full sun west.
one example is crotons: early summer outside in 3-4 hrs of sun cooler temps is great! but then they really color up in october too - no direct sun, 60-65F. while hot temps over 80F and direct hot sun in july -aug totally bleach out the leaves.
but indoors west partial 3-4 hr sun in winter does wonders for them.
caladiums are similar to that. they green in too much shade and bleach out in too much hot sun. while take 4-5 hrs of direct eastern sun indoors in summer.
i have many more: stromanthe triostar, alocasia african mask, etc - that are strictly indoors. they are supposed to be in bright shade only, but i keep them all in dappled , even direct early/late sun to maintain color/good growth indoors in winter and sheers filtered sun in summer.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the House Plants Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here