Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
highjack

I Pcan'd a Phal

highjack
16 years ago

I know most people remember the pictorial and description Pat (pcan) gave of rescuing a totally rootless phal.

I decided to do this with a scrap I almost killed trying to transfer it to s/h without the required new roots growing. It only had a couple of short roots to begin with and I wanted to see if I could get the roots to sprout - I couldn't. I killed the two small roots and had zero roots left.

Here is the size of the phal today, which actually has more leaves today than when the rescue started.

{{gwi:150755}}

This rootless nub spent weeks in a small plastic bowl. I would soak the leaves in a fert solution about once a week. I would apply a rooting hormone to the base of the plant, wrap the base in moist sphag, put it into the bowl and slipped a plastic bag over the bowl. I placed it out of direct sunlight with a very tiny gap to permit some air exchange but to keep moisture inside the bag. I placed this in the path of the heater so it would stay warmer when the g/h was dreary (like today :>(

About three weeks ago when it was receiving it's fert. bath, I spied a tiny green nub. Today it looks like this -

{{gwi:150756}}

This plant lost one original leaf but grew two new ones during the process. It never did get dehydrated leaves but actually grew two new ones. You can see two roots but their is a third one on the reverse side. I didn't write the date down when I started this but it has been several weeks and it takes patience.

I wouldn't go to this much trouble for just any phal but if there is a special one, it would be worth it. The process would probably be faster in the summer than the winter but I hope not to find out.

Brooke

PS - It has also worked on the Phrag. Jason Fischer I almost killed in s/h. I was told many Phrag. bessae kids didn't like s/h and they were right, again. Jason and Passat will miss each other when they go to their respective areas.

Comments (30)

  • littlem_2007
    16 years ago

    hello, Brooke, congrats. I admire your patience and persistance. I have a catt. i am trying to save and i am losing. i think i will try your/Pat's method.
    sue

  • caliloo
    16 years ago

    Wow!

    That is awesome! I am going to try it with the phal rescue I have that only has 1 root. Maybe I will print your photos and hang them near it to inspire it to greatness!

    Thnaks for the lo down

    Alexa

  • xmpraedicta
    16 years ago

    Congrats!! What an exciting find and yes, I second sue's comment: that's some patience :)

  • ray_ratliff
    16 years ago

    Great job of bringing that little baby back!!!! If I may offer up a tip for the next time you need to rescue a small Phal, Phrag, Paph, etc. If the plant has no viable roots I make a full strength batch (plus a little more) of K-L-N using RO/Distilled water & let it soak leaves & all for 20 or 30 minutes (full strength K-L-N solution= 1 tablespoon/ gallon. I usually make 1.25 or 1.5 tablespoons/ gallon for rootless orchids). I know that some hybrids & species take more time to start producing new growths & roots, but I saw new roots forming on phals after about 2 weeks. An aerides that was in bad shape with no viable roots had 5 or 6 new roots sprouting about 4-5 weeks later. If you try using a K-L-N solution in the future, I'd love to know how strong you made your solution & long it takes for your roots to start coming out.

    -Ray-

    P.S. Some people have told me not to do this, but I do it anyway & have had great results. When I buy plants by mail order I tend to receive the plants with damaged/ dried up root tips (U.S.P.S. takes 5 days to deliver plants to me for some reason). So in order to quickly establish me in their new pots & medium I will let them soak for 10 minutes in a regular strength K-L-N solution (1 tablespoon/ gallon). In no time they start growing new roots like CrAzY! You'd never know that the poor things just spent 5 long day in some mail sorting bin drying out.

  • highjack
    Original Author
    16 years ago

    Ray picture this -

    Florida vs Kentucky

    During the winter heat is the issue. The poor phal has suffered through a very long winter and sometimes days of a propane only heated g/h. If I ever need to do this again, I hope it is during the warm months - not the ugly grey cold damp and (insert expletives here) winters of KY.

    Isn't K-L-N for the roots of a plant? Would a rootless whatever be able to use the product? I use a couple drops of Superthrive in my fert water but that was because it was just my regular container of fert. I didn't really expect the ST to do anything.

    Brooke

  • ray_ratliff
    16 years ago

    Yeah, I hear you with the winters! Regarding K-L-N for rootless plants. I have used it on plants that have had all the roots destroyed & it seems to have stimulated the growth of new roots (or maybe the plants were just super resilient, but I think it was the K-L-N) I love Superthrive! I am sure that they extra vitamins will also help to get root production up & running.

    -Ray-

  • littlem_2007
    16 years ago

    hello, all, what is K-L-N? I googled and did not get anything for plants. and where do you get it from? thanks.\
    sue

  • littlem_2007
    16 years ago

    hello, all, what is K-L-N? I googled and did not get anything for plants. and where do you get it from? thanks.\
    sue

  • sweetcicely
    16 years ago

    littlem,

    Googling "K-L-M for orchids" without the quotation marks will give you more than you want to know :)

    Sc

  • pcan-z9
    16 years ago

    Good save there Brooke!! You've got that little guy right at the point where I like to get them on a mount. The roots grab hold right from the very start. It's fun, I love fooling around with this stuff!! Congrats!!
    Pat......

  • littlem_2007
    16 years ago

    hello, sc, thanks. i will try that. i have used rootone and it works but no as quickly as has been indicated in these threads about K-L-N. I have heard of clonex also. has anyone used that for orchids?
    sue

  • ray_ratliff
    16 years ago

    Hi Littlem, I have used Powder rooting hormone & it produced very slow results. The liquid hormone with a good soaking really did the trick for me. The owner of my local Orchid Supply store suggested it a while ago & I have been very happy with the results =0)

    -Ray-

  • highjack
    Original Author
    16 years ago

    Thanks to you Pat for creating this method to save those little scraps. Without you posting about your success, I would have tossed this but I enjoyed watching these tiny leaves fight to live.

    Brooke

  • sweetcicely
    16 years ago

    Brooke, Pat, and Richard(ol) too,

    Thank you for sharing your techniques and pictures. They are all so hopeful, helpful, and encouraging. (and those little guys are Very Cute!)

    Sorry, Sue, I missed the typo--that should be K-L-N for orchids.

    Sweetcicely

  • mehitabel
    16 years ago

    Brooke, I think phals can absorb liquids thru the leaves at the right temperatures.

    Littlem, I use clonex rooting gel all the time. I've used it for about 4 years now, on catts, oncids, phals and encyclias. Whatever needs it.

    It's a gel, so it sticks to the plant. I paint it on tiny roots, root nubs, whatever the plant has going for it. If no root nubs or tiny roots, I paint it on the growing eyes for catts, enc, oncids, or for phals around the bottom of the stem. Then put the plant in a clay pot with a little lava rock and sphag and bag the top (or put it in one of those dome things).

    I also use it when I buy a new plant that needs a little oomph in the root department. A bottle does many, many, many plants.
    A lot of people say isn't worth it to try to save scraps. I say it depends-- some things, like the big whites, there are lots around, and you can always replace it cheap. Other things are harder to find and more expensive, and it's worth trying to save them. One save of a $20 plant will buy a bottle of clonex that can be used on dozens of plants.

    I've had two-inch scraps in March that set spikes in fall the same year, and bloomed within 12 months with 4-5 flowers. However, I don't get 100% on saving scraps.

    Hormex is a liquid root hormone that I use in the watering from time to time. I've also used it like Ray uses KLN-- as a soak, soaking the whole plant.

    With the hormex, I borrowed from a tip of Cynthia in AZ. She invented the system of mixing a strong solution of hormex and using an eye dropped to drop a drop or two on the tiny growing point or root nubs every day or two. That works a charm.

    KLN would work instead of hormex for the same uses, BTW.

  • ray_ratliff
    16 years ago

    Mehitbel, I am curious about how much Hormex you use per gallon & how often you include it when you use it for regular watering instead of soaks or localized treatments. I would like to experiment with some of my plants in the coming year to see if it gives me better root development over a once a year soaking at repotting time. I love this forum!

    -Ray-

  • mehitabel
    16 years ago

    Ray, I use it in nearly every watering-- every time I fertilize. I got the habit when I was growing Gardenias (notoriously root-problem plants-- they just die whenever they feel like it). They call them "suicidal" on the Fragrants forum. The gardenias grew and grew without any setbacks, just no problems.

    So I tried it on orchids, and I like the results on them, too. I've heard people say it retards blooming, but haven't found that to be true in my own experience, either for gardenias or orchids.

    I don't use it every single time, but only because sometimes I'm just too rushed or lazy, especially in summer when the hose is handy. But mostly. Use it at the dilution recommended for watering "houseplants" on the label. I use it at app 1/2 teasp/gal.

    I've used KLN the same way, too. I can't remember why I settled on Hormex instead of KLN-- was probably a shade cheaper, or more available. Wasn't quality, I'm sure. KLN is great stuff.

    It's "wasteful" in the sense that I could probably manage without it, but it's like using a screwdriver instead of your thumbnail to tighten a screw-- it leverages your time and trouble, so you get better results per unit of effort and time. That matters to me.

    About root development-- I was recently able to get the really high grade sphag, and just finished yesterday repotting every single last one into it. Roots were great on all even tho this is the end of winter. That's when the cumulation of all those months of unglorious conditions start to add up and show on the plants. Only two or three needed a smaller pot, the rest were *good* (She said smugly)

    It really felt great seeing all those fat white roots with me own een.

    If you do experiment with using KLN more frequently I hope you'll post your results here. People do like to know what works for others. Especially me :D

  • littlem_2007
    16 years ago

    this is a great thread. thanks all.
    sue

  • julysun
    15 years ago

    Great thread, thanks all!!!
    Julysun

  • highjack
    Original Author
    15 years ago

    Since this thread was resurrected I can report this phal. is happily growing in a 3" pot with tons of roots. One of the original leaves is still on it with several new leaves to keep it company.

    It hasn't bloomed yet, but it is alive and well and growing.

    Brooke

  • vtandrea
    15 years ago

    Just a newbie plea to experienced orchidists: when telling about these really interesting trials and theories, please use full words. I can usually puzzle out what most abbreviations mean, but I'm still working on Brooke's sentence: I decided to do this with a scrap I almost killed trying to transfer it to s/h.....

    What is s/h??

  • stitzelweller
    15 years ago

    I love seeing updates on these "old" threads!

    s/h = semihydroponic

  • orchid126
    15 years ago

    GREAT GROWING! GREAT TIPS! THANK YOU!

  • highjack
    Original Author
    14 years ago

    Another update but this time with the bloom from the rootless wonder {{gwi:150757}} It took two years to get the bloom. I can blooms phals from flask in the same amount of time :>)

    Brooke

  • xmpraedicta
    14 years ago

    congrats!! this is why I grow orchids - the gratification of those two years must be sweeet!

  • msmarion
    14 years ago

    Grampa always said patience was a virtue. LOL You done good!

  • lindakay
    14 years ago

    Great thread. Learned a lot today.
    Linda

  • brummanextra
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    resurrecting an old thread - hope someone still reads it! I have a miltonia (who really knows could be a miltoniopsis!) which having struggled for 2 years since I rescued it was finally growing a new shoot. Suddenly it is wilting - no roots! I have cut the young shoot away, applied rooting hormone powder, and put in a plastic flasking pot with damp sphag, Maybe I will check out K-L-N to se if it's better but I have no great hopes for this plant. In fact getting fed up of constant orchid deaths - wish I could get free from this addiction!

  • arthurm2015
    8 years ago

    Why? Look in the link, the second and third orchid from the top are Miltoniopsis.

    Start a new thread! Tell the readers where you are in the world and describe your growing conditions. Constant orchid deaths are not good!

    Oncidiinae Sub-tribe Hybrids

  • Darlene (GreenCurls)
    8 years ago

    I agree with Arthur. Start a new thread so people can provide you with advice. Constant orchid death is not good. But occasional deaths are unavoidable if you are trying new things.