alaska fish emulsion not organic!?

11 years ago

wow, i was diggin through stuff to fertilize my veg. garden and saw a side note on the Alaska brand fish emulsion that said not for use in organic crop production. Then I took a closer look that the contents and it has ammonical nitrogen and like .75% nitrogen slowly available from fish.

It SOUNDS as if it's only partly organic, partly synthetic.

Featured Answer

gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)

8 years ago

Henry, in addition to this being an old thread, the poster you referred your question to is not know for being a fount of knowledge. He was pretty much just a troll, baiting other posters (one in particular).

Scott's does NOT own Alaska Fish Fertilizer. It is owned by Lilly Miller which in turn is part of the Central Garden & Pet Company, which is a marketing umbrella for various lawn and garden and pet supply companies. They compete against Scotts for much of the same product market - soils, fertilizers, seeds, pesticides, etc.

Alaska Fish Fertilizer 5-1-1 is OMRI certified and labeled for use for any garden purpose including edibles (vegetables and fruit). The issue with heavy metals (mercury) is not relevant. MANY fertilizers contain heavy metals - several are common plant nutrients. It is the amount/concentration that could possibly be at issue. WA State Department of Ag undertook a comprehensive analysis going on 15 years ago (which they have updated several times) that evaluated every fertilizer and soil product used in the state for heavy metals and compared them to "acceptable levels" based on what is found in soils naturally and what could be the expected application of the product based on lbs/acre/year. The cut-off acceptable levels are more stringent than current EPA heavy metal standards. If the product exceeds these acceptable levels, they prohibited from sale in this state. Alaska Fish Fertilizer IS approved and a report of its heavy metal analysis is on that website.

WA State fertilizer heavy metal database

Comments (14)

Kimmsr
11 years ago
It is, at least currently, on the Organic Materials Review Institutes approved list.
quillfred
11 years ago
My jug lacks the OMRI stamp of approval and states (in fine print of course): not for use on food crops. Grrrr.
Related Professionals
Cary Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Medford Landscape Contractors · Aberdeen Landscape Contractors · Estelle Landscape Contractors · Hilo Landscape Contractors · Nashua Landscape Contractors · National City Landscape Contractors · Ponte Vedra Beach Landscape Contractors · Watertown Landscape Contractors · Aventura Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · King of Prussia Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Oak Ridge Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Saint Louis Park Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · West Bend Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Westford Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures
west9491
Original Author
11 years ago
that is what caught my eye...here i thought i was going completely organic. oh well, even a little organic is better than none...haha. besides, worms don't seem to mind!
nico_girl3
11 years ago
I bought some for my veggie garden and I just noticed that it said that about not for use on food crops. Is that notice for only if you are trying to use only "certified organic" products or is it not safe at all for use on food crops? I have a 3 year old son who helps me in my garden so I need stuff that is safe for him to be around. I also got som seaweed fertilizer, is this stuff safe or ok to use on food crops?

Thank you for any info!
Kimmsr
11 years ago
For a product to display the OMRI certification the company must pay for that privilege, some choose not to and even though listed they cannot, legally display the seal. This does not mean they are not approved, just that they do not want to pay to display.
As consumers we do have a choice about this if we do not purchase products without that OMRI seal, and let those companies know we will not purchase their products without that seal.
mackel_in_dfw
11 years ago
Scott's owns Alaska Fish Emulsion, they have billions to get it approved. Fish emulsion is old school organics, and contains unacceptable levels of heavy metals that will disqualify one's soil from organic certification, and render one's veggies toxic with time.

Kimmsr, with twenty-five years on the lecture circuit, you should know your sh@t by now, son. Now your saying a little bit of mercury shouldn't hurt your kiddies...who needs organic certification when you got kimmsr.

You have a moral obligation, period, to zip your lip when you don't know the answer, especially when your advice will do harm to the health or pocket book of others.

I've warned you kimmsr in the past, don't make me have to get beligerent, and bust out a can of Kimmsr Kryptonite. I know you hate that.

Mackel
Henry Waxman
8 years ago
Mackel,,, do you know if this product has received approval for 'organic veggy gardening'? And did the formula change to remove the metals which were previously spoken about in this thread?

thank you.
Henry Waxman
8 years ago
excellent,,,, glad I asked.
hummersteve
7 years ago
Mine also has the OMRI stamp and with that could not say not for organic production or the stamp wouldnt be there.
Raven Galarza de Gold
7 years ago
So, I just bought my first gallon of Alaska fish emulsion. My friend picked it up for me. I am severely chemically injured so I live way out in the wilderness away from any toxic load. Organic gardening all the way. I used the fish emulsion today and my skin, mouth and insides are on fire. I have a headache. Its a chemical reaction. Ive used other fish emulsions with no problem. Im making my own. But I feel so ill and its a definite chemical burn.

I was fine moments before I opened the gallon. My body never lies or exaggerates. Disheartened by the lack of clarity in what is legitimately organically processed and what is not.
Henry Waxman
7 years ago
Raven, from 1 gardener to another, I hope you get better.
Raven Galarza de Gold
7 years ago
Henry... youre a gem. Thank you for being so kind. Going to shower it off, eat and rest. Try fertilome. Its def a clean product. Hugs for kind posting!
HU-724947576
last year
Okay well I came across this thread searching for the metal levels to it, still haven't found... & It has that omri stamp now, (for whatever that's worth.. fda & all the 3 letter organizations are blatantly captured now so) but the ingredients haven't changed....