Return to the Organic Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Alternative to Round-Up?

Posted by estreya Southwest Washington (My Page) on
Thu, Jun 7, 07 at 13:00

Hello, everyone! My goal is to transition exclusively to an organic garden, but the use of Round-Up represents a time savings that i would dearly miss. Is there an organic alternative?

I've read about white vinegar being an effective "point and squirt" method for weed control, but i'll be planting fruit trees very soon and i'm worried about altering ph.

Any feedback? Must i completely give Round-Up up (up up and away!)?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

There are no organic herbicides that function as Roundup does (ie systemic and often kills the plant with a single application). Vinegar functions by burning the leaf tissue, and usually requires repeated applications to kill plants, unless they are sprayed at an *extremely* young stage.

If you really and truly want to be organic, then yes, you shouldn't use Roundup. If you want to be sustainable, and only spray when and what you consider to be necessary, then Roundup is maybe ok. You'll have to decide for yourself what you want. Personally, in terms of human safety, I think there are many more non-organic products that pose more of a health risk. But, again, that's something you have to determine for yourself.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

There is no organic equivalent to RoundUp. The reason is that roundup travels from the above ground portion of the plant into the roots and then kills the roots.

There are many weeds which ordinary household vinegar can kill, but many will just regrow from the roots. There is a stronger formulation of vinegar not available at groceries, but sometimes other places that is more effective, but even so it only kills what it comes in contact with, it doesn't move through the plant to the roots.

The good news is that vinegar isn't going to change your soil's pH. It simply isn't potent enough to leave any lasting impact on pH. It will result only in a temporary (hours to days) acidification in the area it was used.

If you will be planting fruit trees my question is why would you need any herbicide or any type for this? I also have fruiting trees and shrubs, but I just remove the sod from the area (3-4 inches down), use plastic edging around the area and top it off with 3" or so of wood chip mulch. It's not that no weeds ever grow, but they are very easy to control by hand as there aren't many and most aren't well rooted in the soil.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

  • Posted by estreya SouthWest Washington (My Page) on
    Thu, Jun 7, 07 at 16:04

Thank you for your replies!

Actually, justaguy2 (Do you know justaguy1? Did he meet an untimely demise? I suspect foul play!), the area where i use Round-Up is quite a distance from where the fruit trees will be planted. But i'm completely out of my depth as far as understanding how chemicals can travel through the soil, air and water. I thought to be prudent, i'd try to avoid using anything "bad" anywhere on the five acres i inhabit, even if the fruit trees are clear on the other side of the property.

Fruitgirl, you make a keen point about sustainability! I'll work on educating myself about the chemicals in Round-Up so i can make an informed decision. I have a feeling i'll end up using it sparingly.

Thanks guys!


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

the area where i use Round-Up is quite a distance from where the fruit trees will be planted. But i'm completely out of my depth as far as understanding how chemicals can travel through the soil, air and water.

RoundUp sprayed on a plant doesn't move through the soil at all. There have been cases of ground water contamination from it, but this is usually agricultural use where large quantities were used near either a water body or in areas with a high water table.

The biggest concern and it is indeed a significant one is airborne drift. Even a light mist will kill desirable plants and there is no hope of recovery once the product is on them.

With 5 acres you are pretty safe though. If you wish to use the RoundUp then do so on days with little or no wind and consider the direction the wind is blowing in for 100 feet or so.

If you find yourself with 'open' areas on that 5 acres where weed growth is a continual problem, consider purchasing wild flower seed in bulk and broadcasting it liberally in the area after cutting the weeds down. Wild flowers, particularly native ones, can often reduce the weed population and replace it with beautiful blooming plants.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

ha ha ha! I thought you were funny Estreya! :o)


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

estreya, the active ingredient in 'Roundup', glyphosate, is deactivated when it contacts the soil. That is why it is useless as a pre-emergent weed killer. The critical factor about applying it is the droplet size. You adjust pressure so that the drops are small enough to sit on the leaf of the undesirable plant but not so small as to cause misting. The concensus is that the product has a place in sustainable gardening but not in organic (certified) gardening.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

  • Posted by estreya SouthWest Washington (My Page) on
    Thu, Jun 7, 07 at 22:34

Thank you so much everyone! Wonderful information here. I'm sure i'll have lots more questions as i transition to a "sustainable" if not certifiably organic landscape.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

You didn't explain exactly what it is you normally use Round-Up for. When I want to kill all the vegetation in an area, I cover it with cardboard. So that is one possible alternative for you. Not fast, obviously, but you don't have to worry about breathing poison or anything. For individual weeds I just dig them out. Again, not fast, but completely harmless. That is mainly limited to things growing in my garden space that shouldn't be there.

Marcia


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

  • Posted by estreya Southwest Washington (My Page) on
    Fri, Jun 8, 07 at 3:08

You're right Marcia, i did lack specificity.

I do pull weeds as my back and their intermittent nature allows. However, there's a thick "bed" of river rock that separates the roadside from the lawn grass. As thick as the layer is, weeds still sprout up between the rocks. Unless i lift the rocks to get to the base of the weed, it just snaps off in my hand, completely spoiling my ordinarily sunny countenance.

In this particular area, i find it so much easier to just "point and squirt."


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

Glyphosate products simply are not acceptable things for an organic gardener to use.
The acceptable methods to control unwanted plant growth are mechanical removal, suppression with mulches, or maybe spraying with vinegar.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

This is why I don't use rocks for mulch.... I'd at least put down landscaping cloth. At my old house, I was taking up some lawn to put in a garden and found that some idiot had put in a path of small white rocks and then let the grass grow over it... it was a HUGE pain removing that. So, MY personal advice would be to remove the rock and put down landscaping cloth, then put the rocks down....then you should be a lot happier.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

I think you're right, heathen1. I'll have to add that task to my ever-growing project list. I really do want to end up with an entirely organic landscape, but i'll tell you this, the world seems geared toward just the opposite! I'm trying though, and learning, learning, learning ...


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

I agree that rocks are needed in some applications, especially to stop erosion. HOWEVER, some of the problems Estreya is now having won't be cured by putting down landscape cloth. There will still be dust and leaves blown onto the rocks, to settle down into the cracks, and weeds seeds will be blown along with them. They will still sprout, and there will still be things growing in the rocks. Spraying with vinegar, or hand-pulling, wherever you notice greenery growing in the rocks is about your only option when it comes to keeping rocks weed-free, unless you are willing to spray with a systemic. Even there, it's not a one-time thing - you may have to spray less often, but new weed seeds will still sprout and have to be sprayed. I would rather use vinegar than Round-Up, but that is my opinion.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

BUT, gardening is never done! It's why I like it! :o) You have to get your fingers dirty. You have to move plants that aren't happy. You have to continuously weed. You always have to get new plants (my favorite part). BUT as a person who's used a largish expanse of landscaping cloth due to an excess of weeds, it makes things easier... some deeprooted weeds won't take (hallelujah!) and the others are easy to pull up. It's the ONLY think I've used that has made my life of fighting bermuda grass easier. ALSO, if you have bermuda grass like I do, another thing to do is to sink a barrier beside the path... that with the landscaping cloth are a HUGE help for those creeping weeds.


 o
P.S. I forgot something.

I forgot something... because it was a large area, I put down a few layers of newspaper first. Not attractive, at the beginning, but I really think that it helped. I didn't use any weedkiller either.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

I too have an area covered with rocks that the previous owners left. They had put a tarp underneath, but I would still get crabgrass, trees and dandelions growing on it. I have to replace the liner soon after so many years of weeds pocking through the tarp, but I never had a problem pulling them because I only weed after it rains, so the soil is soft and the roots come out easily and whole. For weeds on cement cracks I use boiling water. It works better than vinegar for me. It also helps to not let weeds go to seed. Even if you pick the flowers if you don't have time to get the whole thing, it helps. I can tell the weed "seed bank" has steadily decreased. I wish I could say I don't use roundup, but I do use a few drops when the suckers of my neighbor's tree of heave pop in our yard. Just five drops poured on a drilled hole will kill the suckers down to the root if done in the fall when the sap is flowing downwards. But I try to dig them first. Roundup is the last resort I have against this tree, and over 7 years I have used only 1/10 of the container.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

Johnny's Seeds sells a Flame Gun that uses propane. You burn up the weeds. not the roots of course but it is easy and safe to keep doing it again until the weeds stop coming back.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

has nobody heard of using a simple hoe? you know that flat metal thing at the business end of a wooden pole like your mom and pop used to slice or flip up weeds. There are small ( narrow) 'spot'-hoes, wider 'path'-hoes etc.
And one need not even bend down!!
On top of all that... there is the issue of airborn chemicals of RoundUp, which can be devastating to those with respiratory issues.
I for instance have to keep doors and windows closed for two days when the complex'es gardeners do their thang. Yuck and double yuck!!!
In that case it is a matter of the landlord economizing on the cost of labour.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

I doubt the hoe would work well in a bed of river rock. One tool we love is the hula hoe!!!! Great for removing stretches of sod too!

I was at a friend's house once when they sprayed some weeds with round up. Problem was, the cats were not all locked in the house and the long haired calico immediately came over and started to roll on one of the wet just sprayed weeds. We had the fun of trying to give that cat a bath before she could lick her fur. Apparently there was something in the smell that attracted the cat.

I've experienced weeds in rock beds as well as mulch beds and if you are going to go to the trouble of lifting the rocks or mulch to put down weed cloth and then replace the stuff, I advise to get high quality, heavy weight, weed cloth as the cheap light weight stuff they usually sell to punters at the garden center is no match for the weeds I've experienced in central FL. I've pulled weeds out that brought the light weight fabric with em messing up a whole section of bed.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

I use the Burn Out II concentrate. I don't dilute it fully as they suggest, because it's not quite strong enough. It's made from clove oil and really does a good job - a safe alternative for pets, the environment and you. It's an all natural product.

Here is a link that might be useful: Burn Out Weed and Grass Killer


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

If you have 5 acres, is this river rock all along one side of the property? That would be a lot of river rock, and if you get some noxious weed like thistle or bind weed or knapweed or toad flax or Russian Olive or Tamarask, then an occasional jug of RU might be, in the over all scheme of things, the most reasonable alternative.

I enjoy watching my neighbors alternatively put down river rock and take up river rock, depending on the whims of the new home owners. Thats a lot of work. I know one earthworks contractor guy who does this professionally. He has a big dump of "lovingly used" river rock at his shop yard, from when the new home owners realize that 10 cubic yards or river rock is a lot of heavy stuff. It sits there for a year or so, the rain washes off the mud, and then he sells it again.


 o
Burn Out! No kidding!

  • Posted by estreya Southwest Washington (My Page) on
    Thu, Jul 26, 07 at 12:50

I've never heard of Burn Out before! Thanks for the suggestion, buttercup78 ...

Yes, it's quite a lot of river rock, along one side that sort of borders the road. It was freshly laid in this photograph, so it looks bold and really quite awful. But now that it's aged, i think it frames the yard fairly well, and also allows for effective drainage.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

Estreya, thats looks beautiful. I have 3.5 acres with borders along two roads, and by law we have to irradiate specific noxious weeds, or the county will come along and spray them for you - they sometimes over do it. That alternative to Round Up looks like it might be worth a try, the vinegar might stain your rock. If it were I, I would use the least obnoxious, see if it works, and if not, move up the toxic ladder.

I planted the ditches along my roads with perennial sweet pea, which seems to have a toxic effect on anything else, except some grasses. The only drawback is that it climbs my deer fence, and I have to go out when its dries and pull it off so to won't bend the fence down.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

When looking for alternatives to products such as Roundup, it's easy to assume they are safer. This is certainly not the case with many of them, including Burn Out II. It is much more toxic than Roundup; note the DANGER label classification, the highest ranking, and this wording in the MSDS:
"Contains acetic acid and is flammable and extremely corrosive. Contact with this product will result in severe eye irritation and possible permanent damage. Contact with this product will cause severe skin irritation and/or chemical burns. Breathing vapors will cause significant respiratory irritation, and pulmonary edema if prolonged. Ingestion of this product could cause burns and destroy tissue in the mouth, throat, and digestive tract."

Read the labels on these products carefully before use.

Here is a link that might be useful: label link


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

Good point, jayk.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

Oh, holy smoke!

Thank you jayk. I think i'll pass on the Burn Out II. :)


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

Thank you, thank you, thank you for pointing out the dangers. Because of some past comments I made (well, maybe the reactions to said comments) regarding the safety of vinegar vs. Roundup, I didn't want to say anything.

To the person who isn't diluting it fully: that's not smart. Using products (whether or not they are "all natural") incorrectly environmentally irresponsible. All natural doesn't equate to safe.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

I'm more concerned with Monsanto's profit from Round-Up than it's ingredients. Does anyone have a product by another company they would suggest that is fairly safe?


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

Monsanto's exclusive rights to glyphosate have expired and generic formulations are available. Wouldn't give them my $ either.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

So, what I have read about Roundup is that, along with the glyphosate that kills, there is a surfactant that gets the glyphosate to the roots. Is there a non-toxic surfactant that could be used with vinegar or clove oil to get to the roots? Seems like that would be almost as good as the hated roundup.


 o
RE: Alternative to Round-Up?

The early information in this thread about round-up and the soil such as: "RoundUp sprayed on a plant doesn't move through the soil at all." and "estreya, the active ingredient in 'Roundup', glyphosate, is deactivated when it contacts the soil." were not backed up by links to scientific studies.

The Round-Up can leave the roots of a treated weed, pass through the soil, and be picked up by the roots of nearby rose bushes. http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11104-007-9387-1#

AND

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S116103010900063X

The glyphosate could remain bound in the soil for long time periods.

"Glyphosate [(N-(phosphonomethyl)glycine)] is a widely used herbicide and it is known to compete for the same sorption sites in soil as phosphorus. Persistence and losses of glyphosate were monitored in a field with low phosphorus status and possible correlation between glyphosate and phosphorus leaching losses was studied. Glyphosate and its metabolite AMPA (aminomethyl phosphonic acid) residues in soil samples were analysed after a single application in autumn. Twenty months after the application the residues of glyphosate and AMPA in the topsoil (0�25 cm) corresponded to 19% and 48%, respectively, of the applied amount of glyphosate, and traces of glyphosate and AMPA residues were detected in deeper soil layers (below 35 cm). These results indicate rather long persistence for glyphosate in boreal soils."

http://www.springerlink.com/content/w1461w60366lk018/

Then, when you add fertilizer with P; the glyphosate could be released.

"The results suggest that re-mobilisation of glyphosate may represent an additional transfer pathway for glyphosate to non-target plants which is strongly influenced by soil characteristics such as P fixation potential, content of plant-available iron, pH, cation exchange capacity, sand content and soil organic matter."

http://www.springerlink.com/content/t7h6601566432076/


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Organic Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here