Very good!

I'd either crop edges [to emphasize the moon through the branches] or expand edges [to emphasize the darkness, making the moon a study in contrast]. But that's me. It's good as is, too. Worth enlarging and framing.

Lilo,that's a wonderful photo and I agree with Meldy about framing it. It looks very ethereal.

Beware le loup garou....

Well captured, Lilo - what a wonderful sight this must have been.

I just might tighten the frame all around basically except on the right - snug in the left, tuck down the top just a little bit and take a bit off the bottom. I don't think having it wider will enhance the image overall. But do one of each and see which you like - it's your moon after all:)

Great picture. Wished I could take a picture of a nightsky without interference of streetlights, neighbors houses and the reflected light from the next town.

lilo,
I love it!

I haven't looked at your second try, yet, but this one is beautiful. Is "ethereal" a good word for it?