Return to the The Garden Party Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Noisy and Expensive!

Posted by mwheel East. WV-Z.6 (My Page) on
Tue, Dec 13, 11 at 14:05

After the two torrential rains our area has had in the last three weeks, a large water stain appeared on our living room ceiling. We've been in our house almost 18 years and while the shingles were supposed to last 20-25 years, we'd been thinking about getting a new roof in a year or so. Of course, the leak/water stain decided for us.

After getting some estimates, we chose a company which has done other rooves (sp.?) in our neighborhood. We were told that if the weather held, the work could be done in two days. We were hoping for that, otherwise, there'd have to be a patch job and it would be two or three months wait for the temps to get warm enough to do the work.

Yesterday, the phone rang and a cheery voice said, "See you in the morning". Now, it's been pretty cold around here the last few nights; six a.m. temp this morning was 23.4 degrees, so we wondered if the job could be done. Of course, today's work was taking off the old stuff, so the temp didn't have to be 45 or above for the shingles to adhere. Tomorrow--if the rain doesn't come till late afternoon, the new ones can be applied.

We're very glad it's able to be done before Winter really sets in, but has it been noisy! A few times, it sounded as if someone was coming thru the ceiling. Our cat Maggie has been terrified and a nap is out of the question for DH.

That's the "noise" part of the title; I won't give specifics, but the "expensive" part is what DH and I are giving to each other for Christmas--and maybe a few more to come, too. The good part is that these shingles have a "lifetime guarantee"--whose lifetime I don't know, but I do know it won't be DH and I. :>)

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Noisy and Expensive!

Noisy and expensive, but priceless peace of mind once it is finally done. Whew. I'm glad you'll rest easier once it is done... and the noise abates.


RE: Noisy and Expensive!

Noisy and expensive is so true. While the work was going on, I would have loved to take off and spend a few days on the Coast, but someone had to take care of my animals, and though Joann is always willing to do that, she had a full-time job then, so that was out.

RE: Noisy and Expensive!

We had ours replaced about five years ago, and I agree with rob "but priceless peace of mind once it is finally done.".

RE: Noisy and Expensive!

Ours was replaced this summer. We'd been budgeting to do it in <5 years, but a big hail storm came in April and insurance replaced it for "free." We were pleasantly surprised.

The noise really got to us too. But the most annoying thing was that the roofers pounded out the rhythm for "shave and a haircut" every couple of seconds... without the requisite "two bits!" Steve and I drove ourselves batty singing the absent refrain. We also watched in awe as one of the roofers climbed over my clematis on the back fence to go pee (?) in the trees behind our house. I made Steve go reiterate our bathroom invitation while I cringed inside.

RE: Noisy and Expensive!

I did ours twenty years ago and it is due again. At least this time I wont have to take off and haul away the shakes then lay ply wood. By code comp can be three layers thick before it has to be stripped again. Key word, insulation.

RE: Noisy and Expensive!

I had our roof replaced soon after we moved here.
It leaked a year later around the boot on a bathroom vent.
When the air-conditioner leaked and messed up
the ceiling in Katrina's computer room, I paid many bucks to have both ceilings fixed.
It looked wonderful until the heavy rains a couple of weeks ago.
Now Katrina's newly done ceiling has leaked again and the air-conditioner guy
came out and took pictures and videos to show me that the
roof was leaking around another boot. he says the roofer
should replace all vent boots when he re-roofs a house.

Well, lord luv a duck! How was I supposed to know that!

I called the roof guy and he came immediately.
He and the air guy did new vents and boots and checked out everything.
I am going to have the plaster guy come back and do the ceiling again.
I'm waiting til after another hard rain to be sure.

I hate being in charge.

Good luck to all of you with new roofs.
May the roof gods smile on you for many years
and may Mother Nature take a liking to you. ;0)

RE: Noisy and Expensive!

I had a new roof about five years ago. It was in the summer and temps were high, I worried about those roofers.My granddaughter was with me that day and because of the noise we left to have a very long lunch.

RE: Noisy and Expensive!

  • Posted by mwheel East. WV-Z.6 (My Page) on
    Wed, Dec 14, 11 at 14:04

So far, so good. Even though it's cloudy, the rain has held off and the temp is almost to 50 degrees.

Janis, thanks for the tip. I'm going to make sure to ask if the *vent boots* were replaced; Michelle, we also offered bathroom access, but saw one of the workmen using an *open-air* facility in a secluded corner of our VERY small back yard!!

DH and I totally agree with the sentiments about peace of mind. Although we would have preferred to have a new roof put on when we chose, now it's done--almost--and we hope we won't have to think about it, anymore.

RE: Noisy and Expensive!

That's one of the things my 'new' job paid for- almost 30 years ago. I expect to be shopping for the replacement at any time now, but so far, no leaks. It did leak in one place when first installed, and again, and again, and again... occasionally but not always with every rain. There's an inside valley where the south-facing section meets the west-facing section and while the roofers did a better-than-standard job of replacing the 6" flashing under the new shingles, what no one thought about was that this particular valley -and the gutter below- was the junction of the primary storm-facing roofs which meant that storm-driven wind and rain hit that area full force. That roofing company kept sending out people who ran all sorts of tests trying to *make* it leak [unsuccessfully] before one guy arrived during a near-tropical storm and figured out that the flashing was fine for most applications but needed to be much, much wider to protect the sublayer from wind-driven rain. The hammer-guys came back and lifted a wide section of shingles, replaced the standard flashing with a special extra-wide section and [whew!] we've had no leaks since. Some things are learned the hard way; but the final expert said he was going to make sure his company took weather-direction into consideration in the future.

RE: Noisy and Expensive!

We are thinking about getting the roof done again but this time the old shingles have to go, we don't trust the roof structure.
Almost all of our neighborhood had roof damage 5 years ago from a hailstorm and their insurance paid, of course it left us alone.

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the The Garden Party Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here