Return to the Perennials Forum
| Post a Follow-Up
toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
Posted by
campanula UK Cambridge (
My Page) on
Sun, Sep 14, 14 at 11:53
| I have been a stubborn tricyrtis refusenik for the past 15 years until today - middle daughter proudly informs me she has bought several for me as a 'gift'. Am uncertain whether to be overjoyed or making plans to bury them in one of the gigantic compost heaps. I know these creepy looking plants have their fans so remind me what I might be missing if I fail to plant these in my woodland (I have plenty of huge aconitums to camouflage them if I have to be seen to plant them somewhere). They are purple and white spotty things (Gah). |
Follow-Up Postings:
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Be sure to plant them as close to the front edge of your walking path if you want to have any chance of viewing these very unique Autumn flowers. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| eew, camp, you lucky girl. You could plant a trio of plants with spotted flowers that have appendages sticking out them and then set a big garden gnome smack in the middle and call it the 'Creepy Garden'. I don't know what its is but I find these plants creepy. Something about the spots maybe? The colors? The bizarre factor? I think this would work: |

RE: toad lilies - oh YES
| | |
| Sorry! The bees and I love 'em and I look forward to their late season (October) blooms every year. Makes me grin watching the bees on them--for some reason they go for the bottom of the flower. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Well it certainly wouldn't be the first time I have had a violent change of heart.....for many years, kniphofias were absolutely verboten (I think it was the pronunciation difficulties more than anything else)....until I grew a 'Toffee Nose' with anomanthele lessoniana (aka stipa arundinacea)...at which point I became evangelistic (and tedious). |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Have to agree to thumbs down on the kniphofias. Grew them one year and yanked them out less than a month after they bloomed. Could not see any value in growing them. "Beauty is in the eye of the beholder" notwithstanding, I could find nothing about them to admire. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| I like the kniphofias and grew them a few years back. I saw a mass planting along a sidewalk with a lot of dried red chile rista's hanging above and behind them from a carved wood frame on an adobe building in Santa fe that was gorgeous last time we visited. In fact, I've been thinking of growing them again. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| I do not care for tricyrtis either.I do like Tiger lily, but most spotted leaves creep me out particulary pulmonaria and brunnera. Give me dark green brunnera anyday. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| I've never warmed up to toad lilies which is strange because I've always been drawn to plants with unique looking flowers, like the Silk Vine (Periploca graeca), odd little flowers and they stink, I still have this growing in the planter around the koi pool. I sometimes scratch my head as to why I still have it. Annette |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| It is beyond me how anyone could not find toad lilies and other spotted lilies as anything other than beautiful and exotic, but beauty is in the eye of the beholder I guess. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Funny, I was thinking the same thing about the Red Hot Pokers. I imagine it is a matter of a persons surroundings and personal taste but then with gardens its always personal to each. To me,Toadlily's look like a deformity that sprang out of a dark, dank, creepy place. R. H. Pokers look bold, warm and bright, like fiery torches out in the open air. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Sorry 'campanula' to take it a bit OT but TR mentioning "Red Hot Pokers" reminded me of my love for these plants. A couple of years ago GW member a2zmom posted a stunning picture of Kniphofia "Alcazar" she had taken from her garden (I have included it below). I went out soon after and finally found "Alcazar". I planted 2 that Fall and neither survived the mild winter. And yet I tried again with "Early Sunrise" which I planted in 2013 and much to my surprise it made it through this past epic winter. Who can figure. |

RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| I like deformities, oddities and polkadots. HEY , Campanula , Check your Email . Sorry for being off topic. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Perhaps it's the newbie gardener in me, but I do find myself drawn to plants that can serve as 'conversation pieces' (though my choices are limited as most of my garden is in shade). I planted toad lilies this year and I am a fan, though I do recall reading at one point that the spotty look is caused by a virus that can possibly spread to other lilies...? Oh well, I guess we'll see if my daylilies come up spotty next year! Interestingly, pulmonaria/lungwort is named for the lung disease it resembles, so I can understand the creep factor on that one. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
spedigrees, To me, spots are pretty only on geckos and freckles are pretty only on redheads. lol. To each his own. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| That does it. I am getting Kniphofia seed to sow this winter. I saw a variety that has glaucous blue leaves when this plant came up last summer & they come up easy from seed. I'll let you guys grow the Toadlily's. Speaking of spots, I like the spotted Manfreda's, they look great with tufted grasses like Mexican Feather Grass and Blue Fescue. When I first heard of them & saw photo's I thought they were ugly and diseased looking but in real life, especially with the grasses, I did a 180. Its a matter of where something is planted sometimes. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Urk, spotty foliage has always been a bit of a turn-off for me too although I do have a slightly gothic bohemian style (this is code for messy and idle). So, toadlilies - what do you grow with yours? How are they with tree roots. Most importantly, are they robust or do they need coddling (they won't last long if so). Kniphofias - what are you waiting for Tex - get on it. Mine won't be making a trip to the woods.....but I rarely regret changing plants (boredom threshold of hyperactive infant). Hot Pokers are like asters or phlox - possible to rub along without them for a few years, only to be 'rediscovered' anew every decade or so |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
- Posted by dbarron Z6/7 (Oklahoma) (My Page) on
Mon, Sep 15, 14 at 17:43
| For me, toad-lilies needed coddling. I think they would have been a lot happier in a cooler, wetter climate. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Re toadlilies: I don't believe in being prejudiced against any perennial that works/can work. As far as I'm concerned, the biggest plus for toadlilies is that they bloom at a time of the growing season when the number of blooming perennials is diminishing. Nevertheless, I stopped using them in order to rid our garden of lily beetles. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Well.....I'll tell ya what I'm waiting for......in winter I plant seeds indoors of some plants because its how I get through it otherwise I get sort of pitted out due to lack of garden diversions, namely some sort of progress to observe, the daily check and all that. Red Hot Pokers is now on the list along with a few others. I don't believe in planting any plant I don't like but never thought of it as a prejudice, that sounds sort of serious. I only have so much space. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Hereis a not so red hot poker that has the name of a disease that I kinda like is Kniphofia typhoides. I like word games and associations in the garden. Things don't have to be purely visual. |
Here is a link that might be useful: K. typhoides
This post was edited by wantonamara on Tue, Sep 16, 14 at 0:32
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| But here is the one that I have been lusting for for about three years. Kniphofia multiflora Cream |
Here is a link that might be useful: K. multiflora
This post was edited by wantonamara on Tue, Sep 16, 14 at 15:00
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| The K. multifloras come in orange to. I have found them in plant form for $25 in the states but so far, no seed here. I have found them across the pond |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| TX ranger, You sent me some seed several years back of some that grow and grow and grow and they started sending multiple blooms I think I will have to move them this year. Their display does not last for long. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| My toad lilies grow without any coddling in an area where they compete with maple tree roots. They are just starting to bloom now, a bit earlier than usual. Maybe due to a snap of cool weather. I consider them a tiny treasure. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| I consider them a tiny treasure. And herein lies the problem for me......in the land of giant thuggish perennials, I foresee bullying and overlying from the badly behaved yahoos which colonise the woods.....but being a cheapskate, I will be planting them (since they were free, which tends to trump all other criteria when it comes down to decision making). |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Free! Understand about trying a plant that is free. While the blossoms are tiny the plants themselves are not. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| I would love to hear about any thuggish perennials that like dry shade if you know of any. Sometimes a thug is exactly what's needed, if its halfway ornamental I am in the market for it. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| Like mnwsgal, I consider them a tiny treasure. My clump of toad lilies planted under a mature crabapple tree several years ago have multiplied--politely--and now form an impressive clump heavy with blooms. Stems remain upright without staking and require zero "coddling" from me which makes them high on my list of valued perennials in marginally dry shade. That they attract and sustain pollinators makes them valued additions to my garden beds. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| I have Tricyrtis hirta in my garden for more than 10 years now. Its under a 30 year old weeping beech. It can cope with fairly dry ground but I do water it occasionally in the summer. Ideal conditions are humus rich soil in semi shade that does not dry out to much in the summer. Here (The Netherlands) it starts flowering at the end of August and goes on into October. I think it is valuable because of its late flowering. The flowers are charming but must be seen up close to really appreciate. It does spread by stoloniferous roots but so far has not been a nuissance. Every spring I chop some bits of to keep it in place. Tricyrtis hirta wakes early in the year and new growth can be damaged by spring frost but plants quickly recover. In my garden slugs and snails love the new growth of Tricyrtis so keep an eye on those creatures. Christopher Lloyd described Tricyrtis as "strangely compelling" and I think that is a excellent characterization. |

RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| I'm so amazed (and laughing) at the comments in this thread. I never thought anyone would consider Toad Lilies creepy. I was introduced them about 10 years ago, given a few plants which have multiplied under my apple tree and now are in bloom. I love them. They remind me of orchids, which my sister and her husband grow competitively. And red hot poker...I have been trying to grow this from seed for about 5 years with no success. Well, as they say: Beauty...eye of beholder. Nice pic. GardenPrince. |
RE: toad lilies - oh dear
| | |
| northerner, It really is in they eye of the beholder. I have a sister who loves colorful tropical, green, big leafy stuff and would she would definitely go 'ga ga' over the toad lilies. I like blues, duller colors, native grasses and wild looking scrubby small leaved plants or anything native. We usually head off into completely different directions when we go to TLC, a large privately owned nursery here. Its about all we can do to fake our mutual "admiration" of each other's purchases. I am usually giving hers the sideways doubtful look and she returns the favor along with an eyeball roll. What I don't understand is when people take it personally as they do sometimes here. If we all liked and planted the same exact things...... well, that would definitely be creepy. |
Post a Follow-Up
Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum. If you are a member, please log in.
If you aren't yet a member, join now!
Return to the Perennials Forum
Information about Posting
- You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
- Please review our Rules of Play
before posting.
- Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you
will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your
post, make changes and upload photos.
- After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in
order to see it.
- Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
- We have a strict no-advertising
policy!
- If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit
our Test forum.
- If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we
will be happy to help.
Learn more about in-text links on this page here