Return to the Ponds & Aquatic Plants Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
New goldfish in the pond...

Posted by annaca CA 9 (My Page) on
Mon, May 3, 10 at 12:59

Hi,

We just introduced some goldfish into our new pond couple of days back and so far we have not been able to see them :(
Are they hiding or dead? And if they are dead any idea how long it will take for them to come out? And another thing, except for 2 Fantails, all the others were the 27 cents feeder comet goldfish, though we did select as far as possible the multicolored ones, sort of like fake Shubunkins :) ... How long would it take for them to grow to a reasonable length? Right now they are pretty small, but their tank says they will grow to 12" ....


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: New goldfish in the pond...

Lots of times fish will run and hide when they sense movement above water. All it will take is one adventureous fish to come out when you are around and discover FOOD!!!! Before long they should all be eating right in front of you.

My fish (comets) took about 2 years to reach full length - about 10 inches. You will be surprised how much they will have grown by the end of the summer.


 o
RE: New goldfish in the pond...

Feed them two or three times a day and they will grow faster.


 o
RE: New goldfish in the pond...

I did see a few orange flashes yesterday, ,but after the pump came on in the evening,they have all disappeared... Hopefully they didn't get sucked in... :(


 o
RE: New goldfish in the pond...

I have the kind of pump in my little pond that sits on the bottom and it has a little pre-filter cap on it to keep things from getting sucked into it. But the pre-filter cap fell off and one of my little fishies did get sucked in. I'm very careful now to make sure that cap is always in place.

One of the things I do just before I feed them is to stand at the edge and shake the food canister. When they see me and hear the canister they come to the top. It took a while, but they learn to respond pretty well. After a while, instead of tossing the food on top of the water, get it wet and hold it in your hand and they will eat it right out of your hand. Once they get used to doing that, you can reach into the pond and they will swim into your hand looking for food. Cheryl


 o
RE: New goldfish in the pond...

Cheryl, your fish sounds so cute... I am really hope ful of my fish too... Today when I was adjusting a pot in the pond, I saw four of those little fishies hovering a couple of inches away... But so far, they haven't eaten the food I have given them...


 o
RE: New goldfish in the pond...

I did exactly what the OP did, I started my pond off with 16 of those Petsmart 27 cent feeder fish.

I've still got 5 left after 2 years and they seem to have topped off at about 6 inches each. I could tell a whole story about each one's loss. I followed the direction of "don't start your pond with expensive fish" (in case they die) but never thought about what happens if they live! I barely had room for 2 Koi with them.

They did breed last spring and I managed to keep some with me (they do get eaten in the pond!) but 3 are living happily on my desk in a 1.5 gallon tank.


 o
RE: New goldfish in the pond...

I did the same thing last year and bought 10 little feeder goldfish to help "establish" my pond. The fist few months I did not see much of them and thought like you they were dead. finally I started catching glimpses of them and now they are anywhere from 5 to 8 inches long. I also had them eating out of my hand and theought that was so cool until I noticed they were coming right up for the dog also. I thought if they'll do that then what's to stop a predator from getting them, so I stopped. They still practically coume out of the water at me when I walk up and will follow me all around the pond when I am working. We probably have between 50 and 60 come6ts, shubunkins, koi and fancy tail goldfish. We have this many because a friend gave me some of his last spring and they were all pregnant!!. They are a joy to watch.
jerrie


 o
RE: New goldfish in the pond...

That is encouraging... So far I have been able to see 6 at a time... Considering they are feeder fish, they look very cute... we tried to get the multicolor variety as much as possible... One even seem to have a very promising long tail... I never knew comets could swim this fast! I guess there is a reason they are called comets :D ... But the 2 fantails are the bravest and the cutest... And I love the way they swim, almost waddling... unlike the sleek comets...


 o
RE: New goldfish in the pond...

I have 23 cent wal-mart gold fish that are 10-11 years old.One is over 12 inches long.They have had babies several years.We lost our old fantail last winter.
The first batch of babies I brought into the house for the winter.Put them in a fish tank by spring they were over 3 inches long.
My pond has a veggie filter which has kept the water clear.Still have algae.I winter the fish in a big stock tank in my greenhouse.The babies are in a tote with a veggie filter made from a plastic coffee container.
We are building a new pond for the babies.
The last picture in the web shots album *pond* shows the veggie filter.There are also pictures of the pond under the *gardens* album.I really enjoy the fish and they do know when I shake the can it is time to eat.
http://hardincountykeepsakes.blogspot.com/

Here is a link that might be useful: webshots


 o
RE: New goldfish in the pond...

Hi
i had a complete wipeout of my tropical fish due to the freaky winter. I was fearing mosquitoes so got some feeder gold fish (10 for a buck) I was onlygoing to keep them until spring and then replace with tropicals but they went from under an inch to over 5 inches and even spawned !! They disappeared for almost a month though I kept placing food in the same place everyday, Finally they got the idea . I fear I've created more of a problem than I solved the adults are going to be tough to catch and the fry?? lol. Have never been able to keep goldfish due to herons and egrets but so far they've left these alone .
for some reason. I still have 7 for sure and I know I lost one the first day. I was going to feed them to my marine fish when I got replacements but way to big for that already lol.. never dreamed they'd grow that rapidly let alone spawn ?? Oh well yet another lesson in "ponding" lol gary


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Ponds & Aquatic Plants Forum

Instructions

  • You must be a registered member and logged in to post messages on our forums.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review the contents and make changes.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • It is illegal to post copyrighted material without the owner's consent.
  • HTML codes are allowed in the message field only.
  • No advertising is allowed in any of the forums.
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.



 
Click here to learn more about in-text links on this page.