I can't compare the three, but I can assure you that Lady of Guadalupe is one of the best pink floribundas out there--floriferous, good rebloom, good bs resistance. And pretty.

Here she is:
{{gwi:214264}}

I strongly recommend her.

Kate

Definitely OUR LADY OF GUADALUPE. Best repeat, best blooms, most floriferous. SEXY REXY, for me only blooms once in awhile and not many blooms. Could be the crappy soil. But other roses near it bloom lots, so who knows. GENE BOERNER is on the other side of the fence from OLOG, and it only blooms maybe twice and not a lot of blooms. But they are quite lovely.

OUR LADY OF GUADALUPE
{{gwi:214265}}

GENE BOERNER - as you can see it gets BS also
{{gwi:214266}}

Don't have a recent pic of SEXY REXY.

I would love to know where I can find OLOG. I lost her two years ago and I was sick about it. This rose was wonderful. Always in bloom,healthy and beautiful. I had her in a pot and it got water-logged while I was on vacation. I really miss this rose. Get it if you can! lesley

the only place I know where you can get Our Lady of Guadalupe is Jackson & Perkins. But I haven't searched to see if it is offered elsewhere. I vaguely remember a half dozen years ago that I bought my Lady from J & P back then also.

Kate

Thank you everyone, nice pictures. Sounds like OLOG is a really good rose, I think I'm convinced. The only place I could find it available besides Jackson & Perkins is from K&M Roses, they list it anyway. Their roses are on Fortuniana root stock

Hi Lesley, I have just ordered OLOG from Jackson Perkins. they are the only ones I have found it listed.
Maybe we will both grow outstanding lovely pink roses.
Judith

Tough call for me between OLOG and Sexy Rexy. I've grown Sexy Rexy for >12 years, and it blooms like crazy (lots of blooms with each flush and repeats very well). I finally got OLOG about 3 years ago, after circling it for years, and love it very much. Sexy Rexy is a more true pink, and has more petals and substance. Its blooms are flatter than OLOG. OLOG is a lighter pink, but has more classic HT form upon opening (less flat). It repeats very well, and while the blooms don't last as long as Sexy Rexy, they last well. Since you're in OK, you might want to check zone hardiness to make the choice. Like I said, tough call since they're both great roses for me.