Return to the Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

Posted by barbarag_happy (My Page) on
Fri, Feb 15, 13 at 15:39

Sunshine Daydream, the yellow KnockOut, Limoncello-- suitable for a nice mass planting in an organic rose garden.
No doubt there are others, suggestions and comments please!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

  • Posted by hoovb z9 Southern CA (My Page) on
    Fri, Feb 15, 13 at 15:58

Depends where you are. What is healthy in California may be a giant black pustule in Florida.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

Oops forgot! Hot humid coastal Virginia, just north of the Great Dismal Swamp!
And west of Virginia Beach...


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

Here it's :

Carefree Sunshine (another Radler rose, prettier than the Sunny Knock Out)

Limoncello (a bloom MACHINE),

Grandma's Yellow ("Nacogdoches Rose", up for designation as Texas' official yellow rose)

John


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

  • Posted by TNY78 7a-East TN (My Page) on
    Sat, Feb 16, 13 at 0:28

John, You can actually get Nacogdoches Rose to grow here? I've had mine 3 years and it hasn't done a thing! Is yours ownroot or on rootstock? Mine is ownroot, and I wonder if thats the problem...

As for blackspot resistant yellows, I haven't really come across many besides Limoncello. Even my Sunshine Daydream blackspots in my no-spray garden! A couple in the yellow family that are blackspot resistant for me are Caramella Fairytale & Music Box. I've also heard good things about Golden Fairytale & Teasing Georgia, but have no first hand experience with them. Other's have said Irish Hope does well, but mine is fairly blackspotted (but I may have a different BS strain than people who have done well with it).

Tammy


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

  • Posted by seil z6b MI (My Page) on
    Sat, Feb 16, 13 at 0:49

Julia Child is fairly blackspot resistant for me and blooms all season.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

John Clements used to claim that his rose Morning Has Broken (a single, if I remember correctly) was as disease-resistant as a rose could get. It has a very pretty shade of yellow and doesn't fade, or not very much (if I'm remembering correctly--haven't seen it for about 5 years now). I always wondered why it didn't take off and become more popular.

Kate


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

'Carefree Sunshine' has proven itself in the toughest blackspot areas, including my own garden. It can get some cercospora spot, but this is a much lesser problem. In some years, cercospora has it looking a bit ratty by late season.

It is one of the first repeaters to bloom, and it gives fast, heavy repeat bloom throughout the season provided it is deadheaded. The soft yellow color mixes easily in the garden, and the dense, bright green foliage is very attractive. There is a slight, fresh fragrance. With deadheading, mine stays around 4' high and has spread 6' wide.

This is a wonderful shrub rose.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

I'll second, or third, Carefree Sunshine. While we don't have any blackspot pressure, it does get cold (-5 a couple of weeks ago). CS comes back every year, is covered in blooms, has that light yellow that goes with everything (as mentioned earlier), and can be deadheaded with reckless abandon (i.e. just whack it back with some regularity, a glass of wine in one hand and some shears in the other). Even freezing down to almost the mulch line, it will be 3'x4' in June.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

'Carefree Sunshine' & 'High Voltage' have done well for me in respect to black spot resistance & surviving z4 winters.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

Wow, thank you ALL for these responses.
Kate, I too have wondered about Morning Has Broken (I actually ordered it but received Mme. Plantier instead--!!)
I think I saw a mass planting of Carefree Sunshine at the Museum of Art in Raleigh NC & it was gorgeous and healthy.
Great to have another vote for Limoncello-- bloom machine is what we're looking for, as the gazebo in the center of this garden is becoming popular for weddings.
Not all Texas roses can handle our humidity here, so glad to hear that Nacogoches is good elsewhere, makes me want to try it!
I love Caramel Fairy Tale but it does get BS here---we included 3 plants in a Fairy Tale border and hope its healthy enough to stay. Lions Fairy Tale is currently the standout in the Fairy Tale border-- always has blooms!


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

Morning has Broken is nice, not exactly disease free though, at least here in NYC. I've had it since it was introduced and it's not a single, but it doesn't have a lot of petals. Kind of nice actually. Very bright yellow against bright green leaves. But growing it no-spray, it gets kind of sloppy late in the summer. I was just thinking about that this morning and wondering if I should replace it with something else.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

Carefree Sunshine in my no spray north east Ohio garden.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

Tammy, my Nacogdoches Rose does very well. It's an own root from Chamblee's. Three years old, I think? I do spray occasionally, once or twice in the Spring, then I let my roses fend for themselves until Fall, when I MIGHT spray another couple of times. But NR hasn't needed much help. She's in full sun until 5pm, in an area with good air flow. That might help. I also dis-budded her the first year to force growth. I do that with most of my roses, unless I know they are rambunctious growers no matter what :)

You might want to dis-bud yours this year (early and often!), and make sure she's well mulched and fertilized. Sometimes they just get off on the wrong foot!

John


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

I would just like to add that the Great Dismal Swamp is aptly named.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

Buck roses such as Prairie Harvest and April Moon are disease resistant. There are also some yellow Easy Elegance roses.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

For an example of the Easy Elegance roses, Yellow Submarine has been hardy, healthy, steadily blooming, and a relatively non-fading yellow in my no spray zone 5 yard. Loosely shaped blooms and not any fragrance I can detect, but you can't have it all

Cynthia


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

I love the fragrance of Prairie Harvest, nice bush and it repeats well. Like many yellow shrubs it fades to almost a cream color tho! Does well early in season but loses most of its leaves as season progresses.
I am growing a Meilland grandiflora called Sunshine Daydream-- makes a nice low bush. Not certain if it will have the disease resistance we need, so I bought one to test!
Any reports from Gulf Coast or mid Atlantic on Nacogdoches rose? Our humidity here is about twice that of Texas!


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

I'm probably coming in her too lete now, but recently I was noticing some lovely pictures of Austin's Charlotte--that is one really good-looking yellow rose on a bush about 5 x 4. You might want to give it a second look also.

Kate


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

Sadly, Austins don't do well here. In fact the local botanical garden put in a huge planting (roughly 12 X 80 feet) and lost about 70% of the initial bushes. And they spray like maniacs, since the garden is composed mainly of hybrid teas.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

I have great results with Sunsprite. Have just planted South Africa,Teasing Georgia and Golden Fairytale. All three are supposed to be black spot resistance. JC does not do as well as Sunsprite for me in terms of disease resistance.

Checkout the rose list at NY botanic garden. They do not spray. I think they have Yellow Submarine.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

I don't spray, but the only two yellows that are quite winter hardy and that I have never seen infected with any disease after a few years in my garden are Golden Fairy Tale and Carefree Sunshine.

Golden Wings isn't bad here, but will get some late season BS. Same for Teasing Georgia.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

I forgot one. The Buck rose Golden Unicorn is also disease free here after 3 years. It is more apricot yellow than a true yellow, but a good rose. Just wish the blooms lasted longer in the heat.


 o
RE: Best No-Spray Yellow Shrubs

This is mid-Atlantic blackspot hell, so many roses which are perfectly resistant elsewhere don't do well here. Even the Bucks-- only the pink shrub Carefree Beauty hangs onto its leaves.
I have hopes for Caramella Fairy Tale, which we have in the garden. Elsewhere I've seen a lot of BS on Caramella FT but we have it in an ideal situation here, full sun all day. Cross fingers!
Am giving up on this idea for now. Others in the horticulture dept. were skeptical that ANY yellow rose would look good all season. So we are ordering an Earthkind tea, Mme. Antoine Mari, which has a uniquely delicate beauty. It's sort of a blush color with darker outer petals (we'll SEE just how dark they are in July & August!!).

Thanks for your help. Next season I plan to remove the worst of the nekkid Bucks-- Folksinger, Pearlie Mae and Golden Unicorn. So I may still get a chance to try a couple yellows.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Roses Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here