Return to the Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

Posted by katefisher Z7_NorthernCA (My Page) on
Sun, May 4, 08 at 22:20

Today my husband and I picked up some goodies from Home Depot. One is Alaska Fish Fertilizer and the other Western States Vitamin B-1.

I am wondering if folks here use the Fish Fertilizer? I would prefer to use it as a drench but I read the Lilly Miller page which talked about spraying it on.

I want to use the Vitamin B-1 for some of the roses and other plants I have recently transplanted. My question there is can I use fish emulsion and B-1 on the same plant in the same day without totally over doing it?

I've never used either one of these products before so I'm kind of flying blind.

Thank you.

Kate


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

Spraying fish juice on the leaves is similar to getting a shot of novacaine for a toothache. It gets to where it needs to go RIGHT AWAY.

A soil drench makes the rose wait until the stuff gets down to the roots and the roots drink it up and then send it all the way throughout the plant to the leaves... it would be like taking a pill for the toothache...

Both do the same thing, but one is much quicker... (and you get the full effect without any of it being lost along the way)

Taking a pain pill and a vitamin at the same time has no effect on each other... same with the Fish stuff and the B1... go for it... the plants will be very perky :)


 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

I think more people use fish fert. as foliar than ground soak. I never did spray mine but have started. Feed and spray, best of two worlds.
I wonder if the vitamin is like Superthrive, which is supposed to be like a vitamin shot for roses.

Carla


 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

Problem with fish emulsions is the oil. Can cause leaf burn. I won't use fish emulsion in a foliar spray. Drench, yes. Liquid seaweed is my choice for foliar application.

I only use B1 for new starts, so I can't help there.


 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

Kate, as you know, we discussed that we don't fertilize newly transplanted roses until after we see new growth (10-14 days), which is the sign that the feeder roots are growing. That's the time to apply fish emulsion solution, extra dilute (50% of the labeled dilution), right over the top of the plant. Rose leaves can absorb nutrients, but the organ of the rose that is evolved and designed to do that job is the roots. The roots have the equipment to absorb nutrients in the most efficient manner. In another month, do another 50% dilution application. Roses love fish emulsion. Don't get it on your shoes! You'll have to toss them.

Since it's early in the season, you don't have to worry about the fish oil damaging the leaves up in Quincy within the next two weeks. It doesn't smell good, but the odor goes away soon. Brands of seaweed and fish emulsion are generally regional. The Alaskan product is a good product. As for B-1...never used it. I read a study somewhere that it didn't do a thing under controlled study conditions, so I save my money.


 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

Thanks folks!

I see you all are a bit varied in your opinions but all gives me great food for thought.

I'll experiment a little bit probably being prudent by beginning with the very diluted fish emulsion as a drench. I admit I would rather underfeed than burn and hurt my roses. I am all too aware of how much damage I can do in one day with my over enthusiasm:)

I have been moving around some other perennials and two young trees so perhaps I will save the B-1 for that. I aim to try rooting some cuttings this summer also and understand that folks use the B-1 for that purpose.

Appreciate everyone's time.

Kate


 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

Hi Kate,
Fish emulsion is beneficial as a soil drench and vitamin B1 has no effect on the roses. Repeated research by many universities and extension services on a wide variety of plants (not just roses) could not confirm B1 having any effect either way. In fact plants manufacture their own substantial supply of B1.....generally more than they even need. So drench the soil with the fish and leave the B1 vitamins for the humans.
Michael


 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

Thank you Michael.

Well I'm glad the B-1 was practically free. It was really inexpensive. I might try it for its intended purpose anyway. Is it useful as a rooting compound?

I will definitely use the Fish Fertilizer however. Going to start applying this weekend.

Appreciate your input.

Kate


 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

Diane NJ Is right the liquid seaweed is for the leaves. the fish fertilizer goes really good with rosetone in the alfalfa tea.


 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

Mine is actually Neptune's Harvest so I would have to check bottle to see ratio of fish emulsion. I think NH is safe for foliar.

Carla


 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

Thank you Sam and Carla.

Kate


 o
RE: Fish Fertilizier and Vitamin B-1

When you guys/gals foliar feed with fish emulsion, are you mixing per the label instructions or half strength?

My bottle of fish emulsions only says to mix 1 TBSP per gallon of water and to apply weekly. It doesn't specify whether that is foliar feeding rate or soil drench rate. I'm assuming its for a soil drench.

For foliar feeding, will mixing full strength (1TBSP/Gal) burn my roses?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Roses Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here