Here's the background info.
-Looking for two that will go together.

-Currently I have quite a few OGRs and Austens and a couple floribundas. I've a cottage garden style where most of roses are sandwiched in with perennials. Would need a HT that might kinda fit with the style.

-Some disease resistance. They will go in the no-spray area of the garden near the patio where people and dogs hang out.

-Open to color. 4.5 ft high max.

-Was looking at the Paul McCartney rose as comments indicated it was shrubbier/ fuller in nature than the standard HT. Is that true?

-Doesn't need to be a cutting flower. I don't take flowers inside due to my husband's allergies. Just enjoy them outside.

I understand lots has been accomplished regarding black spot, diseases, etc., and when I find some that fill this criteria, will most likely grow more - they are beautiful!

It gets blackspot in my no-spray garden, but holds onto its leaves better than some of the other Hybrid Teas.

It's a vigorous rose, 4 feet tall here. It's a fantastic Hybrid Tea for a cold zone.

The fragrance is like apple with a hint of Tea Rose.

Sheer Bliss is another beautiful Hybrid Tea, with lovely porcelain blooms, and great fragrance. It shrugs off winter here, is 3 1/2 to 4 feet tall. It's also a good bloomer and vigorous.

Perfume Delight is somewhat new to the garden, planted last year, but it has been excellent so far.

Frederic Mistral and Liv Tyler are great roses, as well.

Pink Promise pics:

A few modern shrub roses worth trying; Aloha, Chinatown, Elmshorn, Feuerwerk, Fruhlingsduft, Romanze, Sleeping Beauty (aka Dornr�schen), and Westerland. They are often forgotten or ignored by those who grow old rose varieties, but they are really worth a second look.

Florence

Yves Piaget is new to the garden, planted last spring. The blooms are really beautiful with a rich color and very fragrant. It's great to add a burst of color in the garden/landscape.

Liv Tyler is very fragrant; it's relatively new to the garden, but repeated well its first summer. I think the fragrance was strong enough to waft. A sturdy rose, good grower so far.

1. HTs are not the hot house flowers everyone seems to think they are.

2. No matter what zone you're in every yard has micro climates and I'll bet you already know where your hot and cold spots are in yours.

3. You've gotten some good suggestions but talk to people locally who grow roses. A good nursery or a rose society will know which ones do best in your area. They'll also be able to give you better information about how a rose will grow in your area. Something that only gets to 4ft. for me might be 6 or 7 feet in CA so no one would think to suggest it for me if I say I want a 4ft rose. There are also different strains of diseases and what might be clean for me wouldn't necessarily be so for you because you might have a different strain of black spot than mine.

4. I know a lot of people who live in WI that grow beautiful HTs!

Yves Piaget is somewhat new to the garden, time will tell if it's as hardy as Frederic in my garden setting. Frederic is very tough, Pink Promise and Sheer Bliss as well.

Paradise blooms like a rose on steroids. Big, FAT steroids. Electron grows well, but seems quite slow between flushes.

I do not do any winter protection. Every year I tell myself that I'm GOING to do some, and then I get lazy and do nothing. Don't forget that the default (on HMF) on some of those listings is 7b--even though there are folks who grow some of those in lower zones. If you find one that strikes your fancy, click the "Gardens" tab and see if there's anyone near you or if it's grown in a lot of other zone 5 gardens.