Return to the Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

Posted by poorbutroserich 6 nashville (My Page) on
Sat, Aug 4, 12 at 10:59

I'd love to hear from folks who would like to share their favorite 20 roses. I've read some posts about folks favorites and made lists, but I'm interested in ordering some HT's, FB's, Grandifloras, some Gallicas, some climbers, even some minatures. Rugosas? Species? I started last year with OGR's but found I really love the modern roses too.
If I'm going to invest this much time and money into roses I've decided I need to do raised beds. The roses I have now I dug out my terrible clay and replaced with garden soil.
They are thriving.
AND I just realized how much they would thrive on the poop of my two rabbits--if there is urine mixed in with the poop(dried not wet urine nor poop) would that be ok or would it hurt the roses?
Thanks again. I hope I am not a "pest".


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

Hi poor in Nashville. Of course you're not a pest! I don't claim to be a rose expert, but I always try to buy AARS varieties since those have been chosen by many experts. And if you're on a budget like I am, you might want to favor what's on sale, or in the bargain bin at Lowe's.


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

  • Posted by seil z6b MI (My Page) on
    Sat, Aug 4, 12 at 12:32

Many good on line nurseries are having sales right now and if you order now you can still plant them if you do it right away if you keep them well watered and maybe give them some shade for the heat of the day. It's no guarantee that they'll make it but I have done it. I don't plant any more after August though because I've found that, for me anyway, they don't get enough time to establish before winter and they die that first one. Otherwise I'd wait for spring to do any more ordering or planting. When the 2013 inventories come out in the fall you can order them and have them shipped in March (or whenever is best for your area) for spring planting.

Some of the ones that are really doing well right now, in spite of the heat, drought and black spot pressure, are Julia Child, Home Run and Dick Clark. All three are growing, blooming and spot free! Folklore is doing well too although it has a bit of BS. A couple that I keep around even though they spot a lot are Double Delight and English Sonnet. But I just love their blooms so much they stay! Austins are spot magnets and generally get huge but you can't beat them for fragrance.

Funny, I don't have any galicas which would do very well in my climate. Maybe I'll have to look at some of those for next spring!


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

I use horse manure because that's what I have. We had bunnies when I was a kid and my Nana swore bunny poo was the best in the world. She put it on everything.


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

yep, rabbit droppings work a treat, but compost them first as they will be too 'hot' to use fresh. Am not understanding what you have against clay - roses usually LOVE clay soil (even though we gardeners are not keen) I don't see why you need raised beds - can you just dump in plenty of composted rabbit droppings,and even straw or hay. Or you can use a clay breaker (granulated mix to open the structure of the soil). Or gravel. Clay is wonderfully fertile, great at holding onto nutrients and moisture and less bother, long-term, than a sandy stony but easily worked soil. It can be amended (as can sandy soil, but this is an ongoing battle)....in the long run, it is best to work with what you have - unless yours is particularly hopeless, I have never come across a clay soil which was not usable (unlike, say, a solid glacial till, comprised of flint and rock).

There is a danger in following other people's recommendations - what works for them may not do very well for you. Ask around locally (any clubs or societies you can join?). Anyway, the adventure is all yours. Have fun (there may be tears too).


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

Campanula, you are right about clay. I should just amend it with gravel etc. I cannot grow lavender in my soil no matter how much I try. It does well for me in pots but it seems I always get crown rot no matter how much I try to open the soil. My concern with the clay is that the roses would have wet feet.
thanks!


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

I hate to disagree with others, but I am N. Alabama which is pretty much the same conditions as Nashville. The red clay needs lots of amending, but it makes great soil with work. I take bunny poo (and wee) straight from the bunny to the beds...not too hot at all, unlike all other manures. Use Yesterdays News for your bunny's liter box and put that on too. It is NOT too late to plant here...it may be too hot...you might want to wait a bit longer until we get some rain. Our roses don't die from cold and the roots grow all winter since the ground doesn't freeze. I will have roses blooming at least until mid Nov...maybe later...go to the sales now!


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

I'm not sure that gallicas and rugosas would do well in a warm climate like yours. You might want to look into the old tea roses (not the same as hybrid teas) which would probably do very well for you and grow into big, gorgeous landscape shrubs. They really like warm weather.


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

BTW NEVER add sand or gravel to red clay soil, unless you plan to make bricks...add organic matter, as much as possible.


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

Oh, I agree, sand in clay soil is disastrous - a solid clumpy mess....but horticultural grit can be a lifesaver, particularly if you can get to any good depth. It counters the minute particle size of clay and can really help with drainage problems. Mind, we rarely get red clay in the UK apart from a few spots in the north of england - a white Kaolin type or grey/blue, even yellowish clay are more common here. And yep, organic matter is a great addition to clay of all types.


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

Hi Nashville! I'm just a few minutes south of you in Franklin. I'm new to this rose addiction too, but have some New Dawn climbers that have been in for a year and are very happy. The rest of my roses I ordered in small bands this spring and they are hanging out in pots until they get a bit bigger. I'll probably plant those in another month or so when the weather breaks a bit.

I have a new house and all I've done is amend my clay soil with copious amounts of (mostly) composted horse manure. I double dug my beds, added in the compost and now just use it as a mulch/top dressing. The perennials I've been putting in since I moved here have been doing great.

The clay found here--if you can fluff it up and keep it from compacting--is actually a pretty great growing medium. That's what adding organic matter will help you do. Here around Nashville we're in the "Central Basin". As a geological area it stops just north of the city, but extends South down below Maury county. It's a different geology than N. Alabama so it's not really the same red, gritty clay. It's been recommended to me to try Teas and Tea Noisettes (I'm more interested in the Old Garden Roses.)

You also might want to check your zone on the new USDA maps. I discovered myself that Nashville moved from 6b to 7a. Which makes us a little more hospitable to some of the roses that like warmer conditions.

Rabbit poop is suppose to be great in your garden. I've never used it, but know people who have used it straight without composting with no problems. I also know people that have successfully put fresh horse manure on their roses. If it were me I try it on just a few things and see how it goes.


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

I can testify that rabbit 'raisin-ettes' are not too hot for anything - I used to put them straight on my azaleas in gallon pots with no worry. I can see if you included a lot of bedding with a lot of urine it could be a problem - rabbit urine is very concentrated and very alkaline (fyi, vinegar is a great wipe up if you need it!).

I wonder if the 'too hot' school comes from breeders that use wire cage bottoms (too hard on their feet unless you're into "fur & fryers" :-P and scoop pee-layden poo up from the concrete floor?

My kids have always been house rabbits so they use a litter box, now with newspaper & hay, before I used Feline Pine (it's kiln dried so it's safe) which was great because I could throw that in the garden straight, even with the pee-soaked sawdust, although with that I took the precaution of watering well. Newspaper and hay needs to be composted but I put it in the city compost because I top the orchard grass with 3-way (oat, wheat, barley which all come up as weeds like you wouldn't believe, hard to get the heap hot enough to kill them). Plus, the dogs think the 'raisin-ettes' are the best.treats.EVER. (I've thought about using them for training treats, after all they are pretty inert, but couldn't get myself to ;-)

Lagomorphmom (Kerin)


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

Thanks for all the tips about rabbit poo and clay soil. It's great there are other lagomorph lovers out there!
subk3--i grew up in Franklin. Now I'm in Hillsboro Belmont. Thanks for the tips Ingrid!
Do any Southern gardners have experience with the Gallicas or rugosas? I'd like to try Noisettes too--and Bourbons.
I'm going to check into the "teas". Anyone have suggestions? I'm thinking of focusing on HT's and FB's and a few climbers but I'd like to get a couple of GFs and teas or noisettes.


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

My Nana put it straight on her plants, and nothing ever burned. Horse poo is another matter. Even that, though, unless you put it on real thick right up to the canes, doesn't burn. I think nothing of putting a shovel full of fresh horse poo around the drip line of my roses. It has to be a deep enough layer for it to start cooking before it damages plants. I have a trailer load of fresh stuff right now, and it's cooking so hot right now, when you stick a shovel in it, steam comes blasting out.


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

Interesting to hear about rabbit poo and ironic too! cause just today I bought "rabbit scram" cause I'm sick of them eating everything I plant.


 o
RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

Poor & Subk3, you should go visit Ann Peck (AnnTN, I believe). She is a bit northeast of you, but she is one of the most knowledgeable people in your area and has an old ad established garden where you can see how the roses look and discuss which ones will do well. Just put up a post to get her attention. She is also the expert on RRD.


 o
rabbits RE: how to limit choices? rabbit poo as fertilizer

Well Richsd, I can relate. My rabbits were free range before I realized I could not have a garden AND free range rabbits (DUH! what was I thinking). They now have custom hutches.
Anyway, something that worked for me is "invisible fence" spray from the co-op. It's full of rotten egg type smell and taste that lingers until it dries. Humans can't smell it but the critters can and will usually move on after a couple of bites. I sprayed the perimeter of my beds every two weeks and my free rangers "learned" to stay away.
Susan


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Roses Forum

Instructions

  • You must be a registered member and logged in to post messages on our forums.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review the contents and make changes.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • It is illegal to post copyrighted material without the owner's consent.
  • HTML codes are allowed in the message field only.
  • No advertising is allowed in any of the forums.
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.



 
Click here to learn more about in-text links on this page.