I have both and Fire n Ice is a much smaller bloom than Love. in my opinion it should have been classed as a miniflora. They do look very similar and they also are both slow growers and have a long repeat interval. They are both also black spot prone.

I had Fire 'n' Ice. Agree with seil, bloom is much smaller, and blows fast. A variety with similar coloring is Brandenburg Gate, which has much better form and holding power for me.

I also have both, and I can't say that either of them have any fragrance to speak of to my nose. I'd give Fire 'n' Ice the edge for having a somewhat lighter reverse than Love, but it's much less hardy in my zone. I've had my original Love for 5-6 years, and replaced Fire 'n' Ice several times, only lasting a maximum of 2-3 years each. It might be one of those roses that isn't good on its own roots, since it's a dinky little plant - or maybe it's just a miniflora, as Seil says. I agree with her that neither is a frequent or prolific rebloomer.

Cynthia

Diane_NJ:
Brandenburg Gate looks like an excellent rose, but unfortunately, I don't see it available anywhere.