Return to the Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Posted by Sara-Ann z6b OK (My Page) on
Sat, Sep 6, 14 at 17:05

There are several roses that have been pleasant surprises this year, especially during the spring flush. My first two flushes this year were great, the third one just so so, but I am satisfied overall; The two that surprised me the most were Pink Peace and Liebeszauber. Pink Peace, because I used to have it, I liked it, but it didn't bloom nearly as much. Liebeszauber, because it is new to me (last year) and I didn't know what to expect, but it is proving to be an outstanding red for me.

Others that deserve to be mentioned are: Belinda's Dream, because it has lived up to my expectations. Peace, because it has given me so many lovely blooms, it never disappoints. Climbing America, because it is finally beginning to live up to my expectations after all these years. Tiffany, it's just a good rose. Love Song, the blooms are always gorgeous, I love the color.

I should also mention Zephirine Drouhin, Mme Isaac Pereire and Reine des Violettes, because even though I haven't seen many blooms since the spring flush, I thought they all did wonderfully for their second season and the blooms are so gorgeous, I love them!

The red rose is Liebeszauber.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

  • Posted by seil z6b MI (My Page) on
    Sat, Sep 6, 14 at 21:16

I have to agree that both Pink Peace and Love Song have been wonderful roses this season. Julia Child also is a great one for me. But the two best surprises were Moonstone and Tiffany. They were both new this spring and grew and bloomed like weeds for me!

Moonstone photo moon2014_07270017_zps74874648.jpg


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Seil, those are both so beautiful! I think maybe where you are Tiffany is a prettier pink, I love it here, but that color is perfection! I always think the touch of yellow adds to the beauty of Tiffany. Your Moonstone is gorgeous too! My Julia Child roses are doing good also.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Viking queen . took a few years . but now it's the perfect rose.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Two have impressed me.

The first is my new hybrid musk Felicia. I don't know why, but I have no pic of her, but her blooms are so delicate--wonderful pastel mix of white, peach, and yellow. She is only a bit over one foot tall so far, but broke out in a big bloom in mid-summer. Can't wait to see what she does next year as she matures.

The second rose that keeps on surprising me is Munstead Woods. Everytime I look at it, I'm amazed again (and again) at how gorgeous those dark burgundy/purple blooms are!

Kate


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

I second Julia Child. A new one for me that has really done exceedingly well is Deja Blue.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Viking Queen looks like it would be a very good rose, seems like it would be more widely grown, or is it more for colder climates? Felicia is beautiful, there are some very nice hybrid musk roses, I need to learn more about them. Kate, I always love seeing your Munstead Wood, I love the richness of the color. And yes, Julia Child is definitely a winner!


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

I have grown Erfurt in the past, but it was too far down the hillside for me to see the blooms. Now that I have some new Erfurts, they are a pleasant surprise. Another is Nur Mahal.

I need to try Felicia and a few other hybrid musks.

Sammy


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Sammy - Several years ago I sought the advice of a Consulting Rosarian through an email that I sent. He recommended Nur Mahal and several other Hybrid Musks for this area, Ballerina, Vanity, and Mozart were three that he also named, indicating that Hybrid Musks do good around here and also Bourbons. I have intended to get Nur Mahal, but haven't yet. About the time he gave me this info was around the time my rose growing got put on hold.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Sydonie definitely. Whatever the class is, HPs/Portlands have a poor reputation here, but Sydonie is now on its fifth flush -even if the flushes were smaller at first- and up to about 4' or 4.5'. I recently started winding it around a 6' tripod in case it wants to get tall here. The blooms are lovely and very strongly scented with the classic Damask fragrance. It hasn't suffered from any mildew or rust which are regular problems here. I'm very happily surprised by its success. I got mine from Rogue Valley in January as a band.

 photo IMG_2233_zpsba45065e.jpg

(With Salvia guaranitica)
 photo IMG_2541_zps57e0ce59.jpg

 photo IMG_2562_zps05275990.jpg

Jay


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Jay, that's fantastic! What a great surprise for you, I love success stories! Beautiful rose too.

This post was edited by Sara-Ann on Mon, Sep 8, 14 at 10:30


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

The rose which has surprised me the most is Bonica. I have 7 of them along a drive purchased at (dare I say) Walmart 8 years ago. They bloom from March until October if I deadhead. I love this rose because it is so faithful.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

I would imagine that is quite a display, would love to see pictures if you ever have a chance to take them. The blooms are lovely on Bonica.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Great thread sara-ann! The roses that have been a pleasant surprise this year have been Frances meilland, freckles, dream come true, quietness, McCartney rose, polonaise, and the very best one has been pope john Paul. It really amazed me with the incredible amount and size of the blooms. My roses have been trial and error but this site has been so helpful. Now the bigger surprise will be if I can figure out how to post pics of my roses! Lol


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Oooops! I forgot Beverly. She s been fabulous!


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Bayourose - I would love to see some pics of your roses too! I need to try Beverly again, I read good things about it all the time. The McCartney Rose is a good one for me, vigorous and a good bloomer. I love Francis Meilland, beautiful and fragrant, mine just needs to bloom more. I can tell my PJPII is going to be a good rose, just needs to become established, it's a lovely rose. I'm glad you have so many that have been such pleasant surprises!


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

After what happened to just about all my roses from last winter, My most pleasant surprise came from a HT. Remember Me just shrugged everything off and went about doing what it does best. Growing like a weed, putting on some of the most beautiful foliage I've seen and pumping out those beautiful blooms non stop. I have 2 planted about 12" apart so it looks like one huge bush. I will be adding 2 more to my garden this coming spring. Plus I will be getting 2 for my Church's garden and 2 for my work place's garden. One of the few HT's that doesn't need any spraying for any fungus disease's. Just water it, feed it and enjoy.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Ohh I have so many.
I ordered from Palantine for the first time this year. All thanks to Nanadoll.
I ordered TWO ASCOTS AND ONE BRIDE'S DREAM.
They both arrived as giant bareroots in Mid March..very late for North Central Texas. I planted them and they took off and were blooming by May. They are even taller than Crapemyrtles that I have had in ground for 5 years!

PRINCESS ALEXANDRA OF KENT and PRINCESS ANNE have also been phenominal. They have flowered in so many flushes that they have outperformed Carding Mill which is touted as a heat loving rose.

My final drum roll is for.....
MUNSTEAD WOOD, MOLLINEAUX, BURGUNDY ICEBURG and POPE JOHN PAULII. I am truly impressed with these roses.We have had a slightly milder summer, but still Texas hot. These roses just never stopped blooming! The Austin Roses were the ones that truly surprised me the most because they are often so maligned.
Just some of my success stories. What a great year for gardening this was!


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Ken - Remember Me is such a beautiful rose, so unique, how exciting to have all those lovely blooms!

Shopshops - I would be in Rose Heaven if I had all those beautiful Austins doing so well and the others too, sounds wonderful! I miss Nanadoll so much, she is certainly an asset to this forum.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

I love this one but don't know its name.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

The roses that have suprised me the most are my climbing pinkies that I planted this spring, they haven't bloomed much but man oh man have they grown! I am constantly tying up new canes and most of them are 6-8 ft by now, I totally did not expect that this year. I am so excited for the spring to see them covered in blooms!


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

Boncrow- Sounds great! Hope you post pictures next season.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

I would have to say mine would be the Fragrant Cloud we bought from the local (mom&pop) garden center. Looked scraggly and woe-be-gone when I got it, but now it's so, so beautiful. Absolutely disease free and the blossoms keep coming strong.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

REGINA LOUISE -- Got it from RU last year, it got burnt by the sun while trying to put out its first two flushes, ALL the new canes and buds got scorched and wilted, it was a very sad sight. Never would I think that within the same summer, it could shoot out another flush again with so many fragrant blooms on long stems, it's such a work horse. Meanwhile the moles have been digging underneath it everyday!

HONOR--Oh Honor! I feel very touched by how hard it works to produce flush after flush after flush, even in the extremly hot drought. The poor Dear had its soil hollowed out by the moles, and I had not watered it much. The minute I firmed the soil and watered it, it perked up and started giving me beautiful flowers again! I truly have a lot of repect for this rose.


 o
RE: Which roses have been your most pleasant surprises?

I also want to add how great my Julia child is doing, she was planted late June and is doing awesome. I am so impressed with her I will be adding 2 more next year!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Roses Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here