Return to the Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Posted by LynneinPerth none (My Page) on
Wed, Sep 14, 11 at 19:55

I have a magnificent old wisteria, which is intermingled with a white climbing rose. The rose has the most vicious thorns, making it very difficult to prune both the wisteria and the rose.

I would like to replace the white rose with a hardy and long flowering thornless white rose, suitable for our hot and dry Perth climate. Do you think Climbing Pinkie or Climbing Iceberg would be suitable.

I have included a photo to show you what it looks like now (hope it works - I haven't tried linking a photo before).

Any suggestions would be appreciated.

Thanks,
Lynne


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

I've just noticed a typo in my post - I meant to say I'm looking for a thornless white or pink climbing rose. Does climbing Iceberg have many thorns?


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

I like the one that is there. Probably nothing else you could plant under that big old Wisteria could compete with it, especially if the rose was small.

Climbing Iceberg is not really thornless anyway. Just when you start to depend on that characterization, it will sprout a big prickle and get you. Better to just wear the leather gloves and deal with it.


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Ditto. Getting any rose to compete successfully with an established wisteria vine is problematic. What you have looks beautiful, so I'd say leave that rose alone. For pruning, arm yourself with a leather or denim jacket, a hat, and some welder's gauntlets that are available at modest cost at stores that carry a lot of tools (in the USA, Lowe's or Home Depot). Gauntlets make growing roses so much easier.

If you want to add a second rose to the mix, 'Zepherine Drouhin' is thornless and vigorous enough to compete. It is medium pink with a powerful fragrance.


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

What a magnificent combination you have there - If it were my garden I would celebrate it (with gauntlets on :-) ) It is so beautiful I wouldn't change a thing.


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Yup. Too beautiful.

Even Pinkie has some thorns. At least mine does, and it manages to draw blood every time I prune.

You could try planting something away from the rose you already have to see if it could get going, and then if it did you could remove your white rose without telling us :D

Renee


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Thanks for the compliments! I think there's an old saying that goes something like "Don't be disappointed that the rosebush has thorns, be grateful that the thornbush has roses". I'll try and remember that the next time I prune, LOL.

I'll see how I go next pruning! Maybe I might do as Renee suggests and plant something new to see how it fares and how I like it before doing anything hasty with the old rose.

Thanks for the advice. Lynne


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Based on the lovely photograph of the two plants and on your description of the rose's thorns, I'm wondering if that rose is Rosa laevigata . . . If it is, I can't fathom having to contend over time with those two plants intermingled. Good grief!!

If it is Rosa laevigata (known in the U.S. as the Cherokee Rose), then YES -- get rid of it as soon as possible. The once-blooming R. laevigata is a fine rose if grown where you can maintain control. Ditto wisteria. Planted together? I don't think so . . .


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

I have no advice. Just wanted to add that the present combination is gorgeous!

Kate


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Leave it as it is! It's SO beautiful,and my guess only worked out so well out of good luck; it's the sort of thing that,if you try to do on purpose, might fail. So my vote would be,leave it as is,or at the most try adding something like a Z. Drouhin,as suggested above. bart

P.S. how far apart are the base of the rose and the base of the wisteria in the photo? Because, of course, I would love to try to create such an effect as you have in this picture (though as I said before, it's very risky and iffy),and need to know how to space the two plants. Thanks! bart


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

I'm not in your zone, but thought I'd mention Kathleen Harrop, it's thornless, light pink.


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

That is jaw-droppingly beautiful. A yellow/apricot, think Crepuscule (mostly thornless), would be breathtaking mixed with the purple. How you would fight the wisteria off until the rose was established, though, I haven't a clue.


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

  • Posted by seil z6 MI (My Page) on
    Sun, Sep 25, 11 at 19:47

That truly is magnificent! Like the others I wouldn't mess with it. Any new rose coming into the mix is going to be very small and probably won't get enough sunlight under that wisteria to thrive and grow quickly so it would take many, many years to get the same affect. Leave this one and plant something new and try it and see how it does before you do anything radical with the old one.


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

I love wisterias and yours is a magnificent example of what a glorious display one can get as a reward for correct and consistent pruning. Which brings me to the point I will make here - the addition of a climbing rose as a companion will make the pruning of both a night mare. I know this from experience - this has been the 7th year I have been stubbornly trying to manage the co-habitation of a Wisteria floribunda 'Rosea' and climbing Peace. It can be a bit of a nightmare.

So,I would say to forget about a climbing rose. I have underplanted another wisteria, trained as a standard with the English Rose, A Shropshire Lad. Now, that is a more manageable combination.


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Yes, but how far apart have you spaced your rose and your wisteria, cactus joe? I really want to try this; I know it may be a bit crazy, but what the heck...I mean "nightmare" garden situations come up anyway, all the time, for example, growing New Dawn as a free-standing shrub in my climate-Tuscany, Italy- in the middle of the garden...BAD,BAD move. I'm actually going to try moving this monster rose to some other place where it can just do what it wants,without me having to prune it.The fact is, it just doesn't give an impressive enough of a show to make me be willing to go through the mess of trying to prune it every year. But for something as spectacular as a rose-with-wisteria combo,well, I'd be willing to deal with that. I, too, love wisterias,especially the purple ones...cheers, bart


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Not for cold climates and not thornless, but Belle Portugaise could handle a wisteria just fine. That is one strong growing rose and the color would be romantic with the wisteria. One of my favorites if you have the space. Also, the flowers smile down from above in a charming way. I had one in a jacaranda tree.


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Thanks for the compliments and suggestions.

Bart 2010 - to answer your question, the rose and the wisteria are planted about 4-4.5 metres apart. The rose is growing up on the left of the photo, just below where the flowers are. The wisteria is planted at the far right of the photo, where that large cluster of blooms is hitting the ground. Overall, the wisteria covers about 11 metres across the fence. But it does send out runners along the ground and tries to put down roots along the fenceline. Plus it is very heavy, so you need a strong wall to support it, like I have. It is really magnificent, and I think worth the effort. I would think the minimum distance apart for planting would be 3 metres, based on the age of my plants.

Thanks windeaux for identifying my rose - I've always wondered what it is - it is very pretty and old fashioned, I just wish it bloomed more often, so I could enjoy it for longer! And obviously, the thorns are a bit of a nightmare.


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Thank you very much, Lynne! cheers, bart


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Just a note to add to the chorus that it is beautiful as-is...

Did you add another rose to yours?


 o
RE: What Climbing Rose to plant with my Wisteria?

Please tell me my 3 year old will look like yours! Mine is surrounded by mostly Austin's. the runners seem to shoot out in every direction, but they have not yet affected the roses. This is early spring so u cannot tell, but there is a New Dawn that happily coexists with this tree. I know the standards are a lot easier to control. Your vine is beautiful.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Roses Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here