Return to the Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Munstead Wood/Lady Shallot/Lady Emma Hamilton/orPrincess Anne

Posted by KingCobb 9/TX (My Page) on
Wed, Nov 13, 13 at 15:17

I am debating between these 4 rose for next year. I have read really good things about 3 of them, and Princess Anne just looks very different from most Austins.

Munstead Wood-I have read great things about, but I already have Ebb Tide, Falstaff, and Twilight zone which bloom their heads off for me so not certain this color would add much....

Lady of Shallot--Intrigues me a lot, closest color I have to it would be Easy Living which makes a much smaller bloom.

Lady Emma-Also intrigued, but I have two Lady Hillingdons-a bush and a climber so again afraid of color similarities.

Princess Anne-Like colors, but haven't seen much about how good she does, other than having a lack of scent.

The other concern I seem to have about all 4 of these is they seem to top out at 3-4 ft. Most of my roses are much larger than this. I am looking to add something to the garden that contributes something new, but will definitely not disregard an exemplary rose just because of repetitiveness. So if there is another Austin ya'll would reccomend by all means let me know. I live near Galveston Texas on the Upper Gulf Coast.

If it would assist, here are my current roses:

Austins:
2 Graham Thomas
1 Heritage
1 Falstaff
1 Scepter D'Isle
Non Austins:
2 Belinda's Dreams
Don Juan
Golden Showers
In the Mood
Lady Hillingdon
Lady Hillingdon Cl
Ducher Rose
Olympiad
Easy Living
Easy going
Chrysler Imperial
Stainless Steel
Nacodoches Rose(Sorry Texas A&M I refuse to call it Grandma's Yellow)
Grande Dame
Love Song
Tahitian Sunset
Legends
Julia Child
Peace
Memorial Day
China Doll
Lasting Love
Serendipity
Ebb Tide
Twilight Zone
Yellow Lady Banks
America Cl
Rosarium Uetersen
Sexy Rexy


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Munstead Wood/Lady Shallot/Lady Emma Hamilton/orPrincess Anne

Who says they "top out at 3-4 feet"? In a warm climate like yours, most Austins get taller than Austin or even HMF say - sometimes MUCH taller. Your best advice on that is to find someone who grows them near you and ask what they really do in your climate.

Jackie


 o
RE: Munstead Wood/Lady Shallot/Lady Emma Hamilton/orPrincess Anne

Princess Anne does have scent, it can be strong. Couple of pics below of the roses you mention.

Lady of Shalott is a nice rose, slightly more orange tinged than LEH. It is completely unscented though. I would say it is larger than LEH at least over here.
Lady of Shalott photo 20130822_153745_zps61cbafdb.jpg

Lady Emma Hamilton is very strongly scented, nice shrubby growth, slightly smaller and has fantastic red/bronze foliage in spring. Also red stems which I love.
Lady Emma Hamilton photo 20130727_054801_zpsdee32871.jpg
Lady Emma Hamilton photo 20130727_054753_zps9fcc1fec.jpg

Princess Anne is by far my most reliable rose. It is super healthy an excellent grower and something a little different in character to most other DAs. It is uber thorny though which doesn't bother me but may others.
Princess Anne photo 20131001_182949_zpsf7ae11a0.jpg
Munstead Wood and Princess Anne photo 20130708_191412_zps52ee56d7.jpg

Munstead Wood is another reliable rose it is highly scented and blooms like mad. It is another with bronze foliage in the spring.
Munstead Wood photo 20130708_050718_zps536151ad.jpg


 o
RE: Munstead Wood/Lady Shallot/Lady Emma Hamilton/orPrincess Anne

caldonbeck, thank you for the gorgeous photos. I'm really beginning to wish I'd ordered Munstead Wood instead of Young Lycidas. Lady Emma Hamilton is really beautiful, even to someone like me who is not hugely fond of most apricot-colored roses.


 o
RE: Munstead Wood/Lady Shallot/Lady Emma Hamilton/orPrincess Anne

Thanks for the comments. I am also considering Tess of the D'Ubervilles or Spirit of Freedom if anyone has any experiences with those.


 o
RE: Munstead Wood/Lady Shallot/Lady Emma Hamilton/orPrincess Anne

Lady Emma and Munstead get sulky in the heat of summer here in Florida. They go semi-dormant. Queen of Sweden is a good rose in the heat. The plant keeps all its leaves through the summer. That's pretty excellent in my garden. These are also "tolerant" of heat in my garden-Windermere, Wollerton Old Hall (wants to be big), Jude the Obscure, Alnwick Rose, and James Galway.


 o
RE: Munstead Wood/Lady Shallot/Lady Emma Hamilton/orPrincess Anne

not a fan of tess. She throws up long octopus arms even here in the UK.


 o
RE: Munstead Wood/Lady Shallot/Lady Emma Hamilton/orPrincess Anne

Thanks I ended up finally deciding to order Lady of Shallot and Princess Anne.

Munstead Wood lost out because I wanted a flower with a higher petal count and Reagan doesn't actually carry LEH.


 o
RE: Munstead Wood/Lady Shallot/Lady Emma Hamilton/orPrincess Anne

Good choices.


 o
RE: Munstead Wood/Lady Shallot/Lady Emma Hamilton/orPrincess Anne

  • Posted by alameda 8 - East Texas (My Page) on
    Fri, Nov 15, 13 at 21:53

I am near you - about 3 hours from Galveston in east Texas. I love my Tess. I have her on a huge fan shaped trellis - she has very healthy foliage and lots of nice blooms. Two of my favorite Austins are Carding Mill and Abe Darby. Wollerton Old Hall, new for me last year, does get really big, don't find the blooms fragrant like Austin says, but they are pretty. Sophy's Rose is a really good one - healthy foliage, lots of big pretty deep pink blooms. Bishop's Castle is good. Lady of Shallot looks to be big. I have quite a few new ones that are healthy and growing - they will do better next year. Great big for me are James Galway and Scepter d'Isle - like them a lot. I have Lady Emma and Munstead Wood planted where they get full sun until 2pm - hope they like it there. I really like Ambridge Rose too. Love the blooms on Jude......mine is very small though. I am getting another Young Lycadis - my chickens were scratching in that bed and killed it. The color is a different, brighter looking pink that I really like. Englands Rose was new for me last year - it started off looking and blooming fantastically.....then it starting dawdling around. Am hoping it will get going again in the spring - it was really nice. I want to try Princess Alexandra of Kent - have heard good things about it.

Do any of you all plan to try the new Austins? I want Boscobel, The Lark Ascending.......not sure about the others.

caldonbeck, the photos are fabulous!
Judith


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Roses Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here