Return to the Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Knockout roses under pine tree

Posted by redecoratingmom 8 GA (My Page) on
Mon, Nov 28, 11 at 15:20

Ok, I've been searching the site and cannot find the answer to this question. Maybe its crazy, but I want to know if anyone has had success with planting knockout roses under pine trees? I have a tall, sparsely branched pine tree in my front yard and I'm itching to plant something wonderful and colorful under it. So that led me to think of knockout roses. I'm concerned about the light shading the tree provides and the acidic soil. Will that spell doom for the roses?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

Go ahead and plant a few. If the pine tree is sparse they should do very well.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

Most roses do best with 6 hours or more of sunshine, but some can get by with somewhat less--but they may bloom less also, and may be a bit more susceptible to blackspot disease. I imagine Knock Outs might do all right where you want them, but I wouldn't plant them any closer than necessary to the pines.

Don't think the acidic soil is that much of a problem--unless the soil is terribly acidic. Wouldn't the big thick roots to the pine tree be a problem, however?

Did you think about some hydrangeas under the pine trees instead of roses? That might work better.

Kate


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

I've seen KOs growing in all kinds of strange places here, so I anticipate they'd do okay as long as they aren't too crowded by roots. Agree with Dublinbay that hydrangea might be a more natural choice, as they like some shade and don't mind acidic soil.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

  • Posted by seil z6 MI (My Page) on
    Mon, Nov 28, 11 at 20:53

I say go for it! I've seen KOs growing and blooming just fine in all kinds of situations. I thought roses liked an acid soil?


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

I don't think they're too picky--ours is on the alkaline side before amendment and they do fine. KOs can only be taken down by rose rosette as far as I can tell, so I'd second the 'go for it'!


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

My neighbor has two canary island pines that I am forced to live with. I grow hydrangeas, geraniums and ferns. Farther out-at the edge of the pine shade I planted a Lyda Rose and two Bonica roses. They are all doing ok. All of them are still blooming right now.
I just got the Lyda rose this spring and it is a blooming fool. I heard it did well in part shade and she sure is. To me,the blossoms look like dogwood so I have a nice forest look going (IMO).
Try it-you can always dig em up and give em away.if it doesnt work out.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

Wow, thanks for such quick replies! The roots might be a bit of an issue. Yet, I did plant some azaleas in the same spot a couple of years ago in the dead heat of a GA summer. Needless to say they didn't make it (long story). I remember when digging there I did hit root a few times but I got them planted. Are knockouts deep rooted?
I have considered the hydrangeas before but I'm just not crazy about them. I want to like them, I really do, but its just something about them...maybe its the leaves. I like plants with smaller leaves (weird, I know).


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

Root competition can be an issue--both pines and roses have shallow root systems. Redbuds ought to be a better companion for roses--they have deep root systems that make them tough to transplant. One of the reasons for redoing entire beds is that it allows me to remove the invasive root systems that run all through our yard. Similarly, I prefer to transplant roses as dormant bareroots--this allows me to separate the invasive roots from the roses.

Invasive roots are worst when it comes to transplanting potted plants--they can zoom into that rich potting mixture and choke a plant that hasn't had a chance to become established.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

  • Posted by jim1961 z 5/6 Central Pa (My Page) on
    Tue, Nov 29, 11 at 12:16

Nothing ventured nothing gained... Try it and see what happens.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

Okay, I think I'll go for it. Nothing ventured nothing gained is right Jim! I am worried about the root situation but, hey, Home Depot and Lowes have a 1 year warranty on perennials so I won't lose much besides labor. I really want some roses in my front yard and this is really my most practical location in the sense that I don't have to dig up something else to plant them. I just renovated a bed in the front and that experience has scarred me for life haha. Definitely not eager to do it again. So a couple of question before I set out:
1. Should I dig up the whole area, add amendments, and maybe raise the grade a few inches, or should I just plant them hole by hole?
2. Any guesses on how far from the tree I should plant? There's a smaller pine next to it and it has some unidentified shrubs planted right up to the trunk. The shrubs and tree has survived all this time but it just doesn't seem right.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

  • Posted by jim1961 z 5/6 central pa (My Page) on
    Thu, Dec 1, 11 at 15:05

1. Should I dig up the whole area, add amendments, and maybe raise the grade a few inches, or should I just plant them hole by hole?
2. Any guesses on how far from the tree I should plant? There's a smaller pine next to it and it has some unidentified shrubs planted right up to the trunk. The shrubs and tree has survived all this time but it just doesn't seem right.

------------------------------------------------------------

I need to think about your situation for a bit....


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

While you might not lose much by growing a rose under bad conditions, *somebody* is losing money when you ask for your refund. From what I understand about how plants are sold by big box stores, it will be the nursery growing the roses that takes the loss. I would personally not feel comfortable asking for a refund if I purposefully didn't respect a plant's cultural needs.

On a completely different note, probably the biggest risk to plants under the pine tree would be dryness. I would be willing to bet that lack of adequate water is what killed your azalea, and roses need more irrigation than azaleas do.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

Merilia, I completely understand where you are coming from, actually you sound a lot like my husband in that regard (the-man-who-refuses-to-return-anything). Believe me my plan is not nearly that diabolical or crazy to set out to intentionally kill plants in hopes of a refund in the distant future. "Yes, lets purchase a small lot of plants, transplant them where they have no chance for survival,watch them slowly come to demise, then dig 'em up months later all for the thrill of the return process...muwahahahah!" Just kidding. Seriously, I really want the plants to thrive which was the motivation behind me posting this question. If this idea has no chance of working, I really want to know.
As far as the azaleas, I do agree that a lack of water killed them but am not sure it was solely because of the pine tree. Here in the south, azaleas are about as common as grass. No respectable garden here would be complete with out some. Many of the ones grown are typically planted around pine trees (also as common as grass here) and they thrive. Mine, on the other hand, were planted out in the middle of the front yard, by a woman in her last trimester of pregnancy, at the peak of a scorching GA summer in the middle of a drought. As you may have guessed, the hotter it got, the bigger I got and less often was I willing to drag out that hose and stand in the heat for 15-20mins watering them. So they slowly became twigs. But you'd be glad to know that I did NOT return them. Nope, they became so twig like that the guy who cut our grass couldn't tell otherwise and ran them down with the lawn mower.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

Lol! That's pretty darn funny..thanks for giving me a smile today.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

I am a bit concerned about what success you may have. I do not have pines but did try a similar event under the canopy of a Norway spruce. Trying to dig a hole was a lot of work as the area was full of spruce roots. Digging "too many" holes would definitely hurt the spruce.

In my case it was just a few so I took the chance. I chose
shade tolerant plants but water was the issue. I had to water them every day or they wilted in summer. The vast
root system of the spruce would just suck the area dry.

I gave up the following year and put a few potted plants under the spruce. Perfect! No damage to the spruce and I did not have to water as often.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

How about the other way around: adding a conifer to an already-existing rose garden? I was thinking of adding a couple cypress trees to provide a bit of shade and a vertical accent...any thoughts? bart


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

I think that if you want color you may want to go with summer blooming perennials that like shady conditions rather than the roses-- the root systems of the perennials are not as deep as a rose has. I definitely think the pine tree is going to win the battle for food & water competition with the rose. Another thought is to plant shade loving annuals for that color in the summer.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

Can you plant them far enough away that they will not interfere with each other bart...?

Since the original person created this thread I have seen KO's planted under trees or close to trees and they are not doing so well... In the 3 cases I have seen...


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

How far away would it have to be, do you think? bart


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

Probably 20 ft away from the tree trunk--and if it is a Norway spruce, about 30 ft away from the tree trunk. (I speak from experience about the Norway spruce--with time it will take over an entire corner of your yard.)

Kate


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

I was thinking more of Italian cypress trees...


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

  • Posted by seil z6b MI (My Page) on
    Sun, Jun 8, 14 at 10:55

I don't think any tree is a good idea in a rose bed. The tree roots will take over and the roses will have to compete to get enough water and nutrients. Besides that shade will reduce the amount of bloom. Roses love sunshine. If it gets too hot you can always erect some type of shade for them temporarily.


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

Seil, you are in a zone 6,in Michigan. Here in Italy,in my garden with it's south-western exposure,most roses really welcome a bit of shade.In fact, that's why I want to do it! but not in a bed with the roses, natch...bart


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

I know what you mean, bart. I always strategically plant 1-2 trees in the southwest corner and 1-2 trees somewhere along the western property line. Those spots give the best shade from our boiling hot late-afternoon/August sun. The flowers and bushes are planted in between or under the trees (shade plants) or to the east of the trees (which cast long shadows after 4:00 in the afternoon).

Morning sun is a whole different ball-game--take advantage of all the morning sun you can get.

Kate


 o
RE: Knockout roses under pine tree

I grow a lot of Knockout roses (200+), and many of them(150+) are under four Spruce pine trees, I cut down the lower branches for the sunlight, and they're are doing very well, I water them once a day during the hot and dry summer days (above 75°F/24°C). The hottest day here is under 90°F/32°C. They're wonderful landscaping roses, fill your gardens with colors, so my old garden roses can just take their time with no hurry....... :-)

This post was edited by Summerseve on Mon, Jun 9, 14 at 0:01


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Roses Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here