Return to the Antique Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Fragrant climber to grow in pot?

Posted by river_crossroads 8b Central Louisiana (My Page) on
Tue, Mar 19, 13 at 0:12

Hi all,

I am looking for a very fragrant antique rose that I could grow in a 3 to 5 gal pot. I need a climber but not a big climber. Climbing to about 8-12 ft but not very wide across, or one that I could prune and keep in check but would still be a repeat bloomer with lots of pretty flowers.

Thornless or small thorns. Disease resistant, black spot resistant, PM resistant. Perform well in my hot, wet, humid climate where the winters might be cold and wet and the summers might be hot and dry. Lots to want, I know!

Pink, purple, light yellow, or light apricot would be good. Bright red or warm colors will not go with my color scheme.

People around here grow climbing Cecile Brunner but say that she gets huge. Can she be grown in a 5 gal pot? Can she be pruned, kept in check and still bloom? Love the smell of bush type Clotilde Soupert, but climbing one sounds bushy & too wide for spot.

Have a big trellis but sunny side faces on concrete and only space in ground looks too small. Clematis in ground on shady side. Faces west, morning shade, afternoon sun but shadows from trees and bldgs so not full sun.

Looking for shade tolerant that can also take a few hours of hot, blazing sun. Search engines return nothing, of course Any ideas? Thanks so much for your time! River

See pics of trellis. Best sun is near entry way - entry way in middle, yellow edge. Can wrap wire around post then train over to trellis.
Click "Slideshow" or "Roll" above pics & use scrollbars to move through quickly.

Summer 2009
Combos 2011
Spring/Summer 2012


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Fragrant climber to grow in pot?

I wouldn't try growing a climber in a pot that small. I grow a Don Juan in a 30 gallon pot, and most bushes in 20 gallon pots. Maybe a mini climber? If there is such a thing.


 o
RE: Fragrant climber to grow in pot?

Hi opaka, thanks.

Yes, I found 2 mini climbers in my exhaustive search over the last several weeks, including reading the gw miniature rose forum. I can ask there about pot size. Just love the antique roses, their scent and their history, but I am sure that you are right, a mini rose is probably best for that spot.

OT as these are minis, just to share some pretty pics.

The smaller climbing mini that might fit is not fragrant, is thorny, but has interesting colors: miniature climbing Rainbow’s End, yellow with red/orange edge, supposed to turn entirely red with yellow underpinnings in a lot of sun.

miniature climbing Rainbow's End at Burlington Roses (Burling Leong)

The larger climbing mini is listed for a mild fragrance but gets huge, so not a good idea, I think, called Jeanne Lajoie. Click on small picture to see how enormous she gets tho' she's a miniature:

Jeanne Lajoie at Heirloom Roses

Thanks again, opaka, appreciate your help! Would also appreciate any info on a small antique climber if anyone knows of one! Thanks, River


 o
RE: Fragrant climber to grow in pot?

I'm wondering if 'Yellow Sweetheart, CL' might work for you. I haven't seen it in-person, but it is on-order for Spring. It's thornless, and fragrant, and is bred from minis (I think?). The HelpMeFind page for it lists a large eventual size, but perhaps it will work as a smaller climber in a pot. Kim Rupert would know best, as most of the pictures of it on HelpMeFind are his. If you can go to a 10gal pot, it'd probably work fine (just my guess).

:-)

~Christopher

Here is a link that might be useful: 'Yellow Sweetheart, CL' at HMF

This post was edited by AquaEyes on Tue, Mar 19, 13 at 12:54


 o
RE: Fragrant climber to grow in pot?

Those are so pretty! I'm sure you'll be happy with anyone you pick.


 o
RE: Fragrant climber to grow in pot?

A pot that small will be unsuitable for anything but a very modest sized rose. Even the so-called "climbing miniatures" will quickly outgrow a container that small in two or three years. 'Climbing Yellow Sweetheart' is a fine climber of modest proportions, but far too large a grower for a 3 - 5 gallon pot. I had one in a 25 gallon pot that outgrew that container in 3 years.


 o
RE: Fragrant climber to grow in pot?

  • Posted by seil z6b MI (My Page) on
    Tue, Mar 19, 13 at 15:34

I agree totally with Trospero. That pot is way too small. Maybe a 15 gallon pot but 25 is better. Even then it will have to be root pruned every few years.

I did not see the amount of ground space you thought was too small in your pictures. Even if the area has concrete near it the rose will grow roots below that and do better than in a 5 gallon pot.

Please don't think that a "mini climber" will be small or stay small. I've seen Jeane Lajoie growth 12 feet high and wide even in my cold climate! And I have Rainbows End and it's a very vigorous grower! I don't know of any climber that you could contain to such a small space and still be happy. There are some climbing sports of hybrid teas that tend to grow very upright in habit. However, they also tend to bloom only at the top as a result and not all that frequently as well.


 o
RE: Fragrant climber to grow in pot?

And I've seen an old Cl. Yellow Sweetheart that covered most of the wall of a garage.

Yes. Trospero and Seil are right. A container of 5-G size or smaller will guarantee you a rose that will not flourish or look good, and will probably die within a few years.

Moreover, in "hot blazing sun," surrounded by concrete, I suspect you'll have trouble keeping any rose healthy.

Jeri


 o
RE: Fragrant climber to grow in pot?

Thanks everyone, it is good for me to face up to the truth, pot too small!

Here’s my plan: to grow miniature climbing Rainbow’s End in a pot until it gets too big, then put it in the ground. It comes only as a band so pot will be fine now, just $7.95 + priority mail from Burling Leong at Burlington Roses, no great fortune to try this.

See picture below. I have a place just off the concrete that has lots of sun higher up but is too shady at ground level, shadows from trees and buildings. Judging by a 1 yr growth pic of this rose on the internet, it might be tall enough in 1 yr to go in the ground and get the sun it needs.

Goal: plant it in the ground next spring after early blooming wild gladiolus has finished blooming and has not yet died back to the ground and disappeared from view. Last yr’s pic below dated 3/29/12. I do have the place marked but it will be easier to work on if I can see what I am doing. Might work?

Thanks, Trospero, for saving me from a mistake. Thanks, Christopher, love the idea of Yellow Sweetheart, which I wish I could grow. Thanks, Jerijen, space below will be much cooler than concrete area where I was going to put the pot.

Thanks, Seil, here is the spot. I am listing plant names to give you an idea of the light, which is much brighter higher up. Wild gladiolus and culinary ginger (dark leaf in middle) can be moved, native monarda fistulosa beebalm at left and liriope at right are duplicates and can go.

Wooden support post to climb on just to left out of view, all support posts are in buried concrete which takes some space away from the plants. I can wrap wire around post & train rose.

One concrete sidewalk in front of gladiolus and another sidewalk just barely visible as gray concrete area to the right, 2 ft square area for rose but probably good soil underneath concrete sidewalks. Possibly big enough?

Thanks again, everyone, esp. for your patience since I have gotten OT from antique roses, much appreciated! River


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Antique Roses Forum

Instructions

  • You must be a registered member and logged in to post messages on our forums.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review the contents and make changes.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • It is illegal to post copyrighted material without the owner's consent.
  • HTML codes are allowed in the message field only.
  • No advertising is allowed in any of the forums.
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.



 
Click here to learn more about in-text links on this page.