|
| I finally got around to being thrilled to purchase two David Austin roses, own root, this spring. One for my sister; 'Heritage' & for myself; 'Alnwick' I'm totally pleased & can't wait for the buds to open... May I ask which one/s you have bought & what are your favorites? I'm asking, as I'm very tempted to purchase at least another this autumn .Please name your selection & which attributes you like (or dislike) about it. This may help me determine the cv. I order next. Thank you, for your opinions about your Austin rose choices |
Follow-Up Postings:
|
| For the past year or two, I have been pushing Lady of Shalott (golden apricot) and the shorter rose Munstead Wood (dark magenta/purple). Both have outstanding colors, are quite floriferous, and have good disease-resistance. Others I really like are Septer'd Isle (light pink), William Shakespeare 2000 (red/magenta/purple), Queen of Sweden (light pink with pale apricot flush). A couple shorter ones that are excellent are Molineux (yellow/gold/apricot highlights) and Pretty Jessica (pink). All the Austins I listed have good to excellent disease-resistance. There are many other terrific Austins also--but I ran out of space for more in my garden. Kate |
|
| Wild Edric, an Austin rugosa. I've had him since spring of 2012, and he is now over 6 feet tall. Love him! Blooms repeatedly, with the most beautiful shimmery purpley/pinkish/reddish flowers that appear to change color with the angle of the light. Fragrant too. Needs very little care (as in ZERO fertilizer since a little fish emulsion in 2012, no soil amendments) and thrives in dry heat of our scorching summers. He's low water too. Mine does get some dappled shade in various parts of the day, depending on the time of year which time of day it occurs. Absolutely no disease. Mine is on multiflora and from Pickering (who sadly no longer sells him). From descriptions from camps, it doesn't appear he likes wet weather all that much, which may explain partially why Pickering no longer carries him. But for my drought stricken area he seems ideally suited. I have 2 other Austin rugosas, both of which I like but neither are quite the stellar performers as Wild Edric, although both are quite healthy. These are the white Snowden, and the cool pink Mrs. Doreen Pike. Both are own root and arrived as bands, so WE did have a headstart in size. I forget exactly when they arrived, but after WE, likely late 2012. Mrs. Doreen Pike has been doing the sleep, creep, leap thing, and this year she is definitely leaping, even during some unseasonally early toasty weather. Snowden is in a lot of shade and is climbing up a grapefruit tree. These 2 have little repeat, at least so far. Flowers are stunning. I do feed them both infrequently with a little fish emulsion but do not amend the soil, nor do I mulch them. Snowden has particularly dark green foliage. Both are quite dry heat tolerant. Others that I have and really like are Huntington Rose and Happy Child. HR is a BIG one and tolerates a fair amount of shade. Many-petalled globular flowers that nod. Arching growth. Very healthy and vigorous. Grafted on multiflora. Recently moved to a spot I could see the plant better, which is smack dab in the root zone of a huge ash tree. Multiflora is tough though, and the plant is taking off, sending up new basals. Happy Child is a much more diminutive plant. Very healthy too and gets the most beautiful pure yellow flowers packed with petals. Own root. Prospero is another good one and also quite small in size. It has gorgeous dark red flowers filled with petals. I've grown it twice and twice it has gotten killed through no fault of its own. First time was my fault as it got zero water for most of a year when the sprinkler adjacent was broken, and I didn't notice. The second time, as a baby plant, it was placed in a spot that was the favorite fire hydrant location of my pony-sized dog. Not many plants can survive that treatment.;) Melissa |
|
| I've grown very few of the most recent ones, and I have to say my favorite is still one of the earlier ones, Potter and Moore. Mine is own-root and it's a graceful, rather small bush with lusciously full pink flowers with an old-rose look. The foliage is quite healthy. There is very little scent that I can detect. My second choice, which is grafted, is Bishop's Castle, also a full bloom in a delicious cool pink color, and this one is quite fragrant and also healthy, although it had mildew earlier this spring, which is now almost gone. Both roses stand up well to my hot and dry climate. Bishop's Castle tends to get long canes, but when I deadhead I cut the branch back quite a bit, and that has kept it small. Ingrid |
|
- Posted by caldonbeck UK (8) (My Page) on Mon, May 26, 14 at 0:17
| I would say princess alexandra of kent is the best all round of theirs. It is compact, very strong in growth (thick stems), has very large flowers with strong enough pedicels to support them, good fragrance, good rain resistance, very healthy - my favourite rose for sure. |
|
| My personal favorite is Munstead Wood, heavily fragrant and richly colored. |
|
| I don't have many but I do have a couple of very atypical Austins (which is probably why I like them so much) - Scintillation, a procumbent single pink, flowers only once but truly stellar - complements Raubritter. A repeating (but sparsely) rambler, Snowgoose. I was given this and, being a bit apathetic about Austins (fussy, water hungry), I left it in its pot, ignored, unwatered, unfed and unloved for 3 years 3 YEARS! It refused to die. Finally, out of respect for its sheer tenacity, I planted it. It now covers my horrible old shed in startling panicles of unusual, creamy white blossom (a very apt term for the blossom-like look of these long petalled, almost quilled blooms). Have not improved my idleness though, and it remains unfed, unpruned and unwatered (but not unloved)......but a sterling (and fragrant) performer, if a little untidy (mea culpa). Ah yes, the modest Crocus Rose. Nothing that special but healthy (always a plus) and quick to rebloom, fitting in well everywhere. |
|
- Posted by UrbanHorse 8 Oxford UK (My Page) on Mon, May 26, 14 at 18:01
| Last year i have bought: Crown Princess Margareta -3 bushes-grafted Evelyn-2 bushes-grafted Eglantyne-grafted Port Sunlight-grafted Claire Austin-grafted Wildeve-grafted Benjamin Britten-grafted Shopshire Lad-grafted Lady of Megginch-2 bushes-grafted Me and my BF we love ....love...EVELYN ! Beautiful apricot colored flowers with strong tea scent with fruity note,healthy and strong foliage,can grow to an enormus size-(in warmer climates with liquid seaweed fertilizer)- great cutting rose too-will last a long time in a vase! EVELYN-summer 2013
|
|
- Posted by gnabonnand Zone 8 Texas (My Page) on Mon, May 26, 14 at 18:13
| UrbanHorse, you have convinced me with that photo and your description of 'Evelyn'. Perfect! |
|
- Posted by Gardenmama63 7a (My Page) on Mon, May 26, 14 at 19:57
| This is like having to pick a favorite child! I love them all but some stand out. For consistency of largish blooms over a long period my favorites are Princess Alexandra of Kent and Jubilee. A close "second is Abraham Darby, which has an incredible scent. And third is Jude the Obscure.... I also love my Lady of Shallot but have three of them in a separate spot because the orange/salmon color is difficult to tie into my pink/burgundy/purple color scheme. Mum stead Wood, WS2000 and LD Braithwaite are all nice reds and hard fifth me to choose between them. Young Lycidas took four years and I was about to take it out but it made a leap last year so it stays for now. But it has lots of thinner arching branches. Scepter'd Isle is a big disappointment. The heat of NoVa means it's flowers break up after a day and I seem to spend an incredible amount of time picking up petals from underneath the two bushes. Beware the scent: visitors to my garden have a strong like or dislike for it. Other disappointments: John Clare..ordinary and no scent. Gertrude Jekyll: overhyped in my view... I got most of my roses from David Austin Texas as container plants and a couple from the Merrifield Nursery.. Enjoy your choice! |
|
- Posted by mauvegirl8 Texas (My Page) on Mon, May 26, 14 at 22:43
| Looking at the picture of Princess Alexandra of Kent makes me happy to have it in my garden. I ordered it back in fall for this year's spring delivery. Should explode in blooms any day now. Houston just had a much needed healthy dose of rain. That photo of Evelyn is beautiful. |
|
- Posted by the_bustopher 6, MO (My Page) on Mon, May 26, 14 at 23:18
| My favorite Austins are Lady of Shalott, Sir Edward Elgar, Windrush, Munstead Wood, Lady Emma Hamilton, and Crocus Rose. |
|
- Posted by Kippy-the-Hippy 10 Sunset 24 (My Page) on Tue, May 27, 14 at 0:25
| My favorite for continuous bloom, reasonable thorns and nice scent is Darcey Bussell. I like Crocus Rose and Bishops Castle and am looking forward to Golden Celebration getting bigger. |
|
| I echo those who mentioned Munstead Woods which is turning out to be the best red Austin I've grown all-around with good health, rich fragrance, etc. I also love Sharifa Asma for a perfect pink! |
|
| l've really enjoyed your input & especially to those of you, for having included their photos. I'm dumbfounded at their beauty. William Shakespeare, Prospero, Braithwaite were all on my mind, plus the pinks shown/mentioned. But after just ONE look at that 'Munstead Woods'. I'm totally smitten! Thank you very much for all your input & if some of you Northerners are waiting just awhile longer to share, to show full blooms in all their glory, please do so... |
|
| Another reason you made a great choice: Munstead Wood just won "Best Fragrance" in the 2014 Biltmore International Rose Trials. I didn't get this rose only because I needed my burgundy to be a climber, so I ended up with Tradescant, which I'm loving so far. If I ever need a shorter burgundy, I won't hesitate to consider Munstead Wood. I hope yours brings you lots of joy! jannike |
|
| In addition to Munstead Wood, I also like Sharifa Asma, Gertrude Jeckyll, and have high hopes for the founding rose, Constance Spry. Mine is as yet too young to tell. It was a gift from Carol Markell, who knew I admired it, and I treasure it in memory of her. Leander is also quite magnificent as a climber and is my DH Tom's favorite among the Austins. We have two. I have three quite young Austins that may turn out well given time. They are Golden Celebration, Molyneux, and Jude the Obscure. I'll give them time. An old favorite Brother Cadfael grew backwards for several years and this spring I removed it. Just yesterday I came across an old photo of it as a year old plant. I had forgotten how lovely it once was. Rosefolly |
|
| It's hard to pick a favorite... I grow many Austins and find they are wonderful roses. These are grafted plants. Bishop's Castle has lovely dark pink blooms with great fragrance.
Evelyn has a scent reminiscent of fresh peaches. The large blooms have a mix of pastel shades.
Sharifa Asma has pale pink blooms that remind me of the old Alba roses.
|
|
I've been a sucker for Pat Austin for the last 14 years after that Munstead Wood the only rose I thought worth while 2 have 2 of! Form Fragrance color it really is a modern reproduction! |
|
| Constance Spry has been mentioned, so it's worthwhile to follow up with a little more information. I believe that Constance Spry is Austin's first release and it is still one of his best roses, although it only flowers once a year. Constance Spry makes a 6' shrub in zones 5 & 6 with long wiry canes that need to be pruned back a third so the flowers don't bend the canes to the ground. Constance Spry suckers some, so will make a nice thicket over time producing a generous number of large, cupped, light pink, flowers. If given support the long canes can reach 12’ and will reward the grower with nodding flowers of a soft pink that reveal a circle of golden stamens when fully open. |
|
- Posted by cjrosaphile z8 Pacific NW (My Page) on Wed, May 28, 14 at 22:57
| Everyone has such a different opinion. My favs are Crown Princess Margareta and Mary Rose. . .and Christopher Marlowe and Sharifa Asma. . .such torture to decide. Crown Princess is pictured. Did just get Jubilee Celebration and the smell is amazing. |
|
- Posted by Summerseve 6a (My Page) on Wed, May 28, 14 at 23:22
| I love Mary rose, it's a blooming machine! |
|
- Posted by mariannese 5b (My Page) on Thu, May 29, 14 at 5:11
| It has taken me 10 years to reappraise the Austin roses after some early failures with Abraham Darby, Constance Spry (but it lived for 10 years) and Graham Thomas. To overcome my disappointment I decided that I didn't like their looks or the colours in my garden of traditional rose colours. My husband still doesn't approve of them. So far I like my new Austins Crown Princess Margareta, Lady Emma Hamilton, Lady of Shalott, Munstead Wood and Summer Song. Munstead Wood is perhaps the best. I made a new hot bed apart from other roses to fit in the odd burnt oranges and yellows. |
|
| he continued input & absolutely stunning photos! That Munstead Wood, sure is a beauty... mariannese, maybe if you grow some blue or purplr perennials & or annuals, the colors you already have, would appear to mix well and contrast the orange & yellows of your Austins. Just a suggestion. I prefer mainly the reds & pinks, of the Austin rose color selections. While white would go with just about anything. Though my other flowers are so eclectic, the color range of numerous various other types of flowers are 'just what they, for what they are...." Sometimes they go together well & others don't, so they just get moved about. As I'm starting a new garden, with some brought with me from the move, many are still in pots & when I finally figure out what looks good where it's at, then in it goes! |
|
- Posted by caldonbeck UK (8) (My Page) on Thu, May 29, 14 at 16:45
| Seeing as you're leaning towards MW, I thought I would share my pic of it last summer again. It is healthy, repeats well, fragrance is excellent. It doesn't have the nicest growth is my only slight niggle, a bit bare legged, but it's a minor thing. |
|
| Golden Celebration -- it is magic. That rose stopped me in my tracks and the scent took my breath away. Its hardy and the blooms are gigantic. The color is very vibrant and doesnt work everywhere, but it is an absolute standout. |
|
- Posted by Gardenmama63 (My Page) on Fri, Jun 13, 14 at 22:42
|
| I would love to see a picture of someone's Mary rose. Also is anyone growing Sophie's rose? I'm trying to decide which one I want, may have to get one of each if I can't decide. MW is so lovely too. Actually they are all beautiful to look at, it's hard to pick :). |
Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum. If you are a member, please log in. If you aren't yet a member, join now!
Return to the Antique Roses Forum
Information about Posting
- You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
- Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
- Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
- After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
- Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
- We have a strict no-advertising policy!
- If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
- If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.
Learn more about in-text links on this page here














