Return to the Antique Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Posted by jeff_zephyr Sunset 7 CA (My Page) on
Wed, May 5, 10 at 12:17

I decided to try gorilla hair mulch around my roses last year. It was highly recommended by the garden center. After a year of observation, I am really disappointed.

The biggest problem is that this mulch forms a waterproof barrier. Water gets trapped in the gorilla hair instead of percolating into the ground. This is a big problem for a dry climate like mine. Numerous times after it rained, I would lift the gorilla hair mulch only to see how dry the earth underneath was.

Weed actually grows on the gorilla hair! Weeding was actually challenging this year, because the unwanted grass and weeds actually root into the gorilla hair. As a result, I ended up throwing away quite a bit of mulch along with the weed.

Last, in our windy and dry environment, the gorilla hair actually gets blown away. I have to buy more mulch to replace the sections that disappeared.

Conclusion: I'll never buy this product again because it is a waste of money and time.

Jeff


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

What?


 o
I was hoping it was from Gorillas

So when it broke down it would be a slow release of N from the proteins...maybe a primate equivalent of feathers.
But
No!

It can be shredded redwood bark OR recycled shredded redwood.

Can you just imagine the neighborhood dogs sniffing gorilla hair mulch?

Here is a link that might be useful: One link for the recycled stuff


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

hahaha I had to look up "gorilla hair mulch" because I was sure you were talking about actual hair from a gorilla!

I'm sorry you had such a bad experience trying a new mulch, I always get frustrated when someone "Highly Recommends" a product and it turns out to be junk.

Natalie


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Thanks, Jeff. Good information. I don't see it being sold locally here, but if I do, I will stay FAR FAR AWAY. Thanks for the heads-up on the gorilla hair mulch.

Do you have any other experiences with other types of mulch that you want to let us new gardeners know? I currently buy what's on sale.

I should do the water check as you do after a rain to see if the water penetrates below the mulch.

I look forward to your answer and other experiences from folks on this forum as well.

Many thanks!

Audrey


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Stay away from clothes-dryer lint, too. Just not durable enough.


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Lol, I had to look up gorilla hair mulch also since everything you said about it fit with actual hair (mats, waterproof, blown away by wind). I was going to ask if you lived near a zoo and HOW MUCH you paid for it.


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Never heard of it either. Thanks for the information, in case I ever do see it.


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

I've just sent off for two gorillas. How much do you suppose the feeding and Vet bills will come to, and will I be able to harvest enough hair to mulch all 100 of my roses?


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Might keep the deer out of the garden....

Carol


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Carol's right, gorillas would definitely keep deer out of your garden :D


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

It's taken me a full ten minutes to pull myself together and stop laughing. TOO MUCH! as we used to say in the days of my youth.

Laura


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

My question is ...

Who's the poor sap that they hired to shave all these gorillas?

;P

BC:)


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

LOL! I wish it would keep the deer away. No such luck, as they nibbled happily on the roses without having to leave tell-tale footprints on account of the mulch.

Jeff


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

LOL

But any mulch will absorb the water first and unless it's a heavy rain it will not penetrate. During our drought, we were advised to had water under the mulch, or move the mulch away from around the plants to water.

I have coconut husk mulch in one spot and I do like it. But we've had lots of rain recently, so I haven't noticed any watering problems.


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Uh, so this was a joke?

At dinner I suggested to my honey that I may look into gorilla hair as a mulch to test it out for myself.

He almost spit out the soup (or was it my cooking?)


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

  • Posted by hoovb z9 Southern CA (My Page) on
    Thu, May 6, 10 at 12:05

No, not a joke, it's a marketing name someone made up to sell shredded wood products as a premium mulch.


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Here's what the University of California Extension Office says about gorilla hair mulch:

"A related product is shredded cedar or “Gorilla hair.” As a gorilla’s coat helps shed water and protect him from the elements, the bark with the similar name also tends to shed water, making it a good choice for a hillside, but not so good for moisture loving flower beds. Water won’t make it through the mulch to the roots of plants"

So probably some better mulch choices out there.


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Gorilla hair ia actually a very useful mulch on a slope. It locks together and doesn't slide down the hill easily the way most mulches will. I don't like it in a garden either, for lots of reasons including the ones mentioned here. The one that bothers me the most is that I get splinters from it all the time. I tried it once years ago, just as you did, and will never buy it again.

It is popular. I don;t know why. I do think that the garden center salesperson gave you the recommendation in good faith. They aren't always gardeners themselves. It probably is all right if you have drip emitters under it. For spray or rainfall, it is not good.

R


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

I agree about Gorilla hair not being the best mulch... but one thing it does very well is remain on a hillside - where any other kind of bark tends to wash/migrate downslope Gorilla hair will over time mat down and stay in place.


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

  • Posted by beth NorCA 9 (My Page) on
    Tue, Mar 1, 11 at 11:48

Hah! This is so funny. Jeff, if you're in CA, I assume you got the Gorilla Hair mulch that's from Redi-Gro in Sacramento. It's supposed to be shredded redwood. We carry it at the Ace Hardware store where I work. I've never used it, and now I'm glad I didn't try it! If your garden center orders other products from Redi-Gro, I would recommend trying the Redi-Gro Mulch if they have it. It's a finely shredded/chopped cedar mulch, I believe. I use it alot around my roses. It looks nice and retains moisture very well.


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

Man, there's some wierd stuff happening out there in California!

Here is a link that might be useful: Garden Musings


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

It is recommended as mulch for native plants in California. It is a by-product of milling redwood for lumber. For roses, I would stick to something else.


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

I noticed that with any kind of bark mulch there can be a problem with water not reaching the soil. I almost killed Young Lycidas before realizing that the poor thing had bone dry soil around it in spite of my faithful and very frequent hand watering. I've found that a combination of bark and vegetable matter is a better idea, and if I had enough leaves from my trees I wouldn't bother with purchased mulch at all.

Since I live near Wild Animal Park, I'm tempted to bribe the keepers to shave some of the gentler gorillas. I have a feeling the real thing would work much better than what you can buy in a bag. Since it's so hot the gorillas would feel much more airy without all that hair.

Ingrid


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

So kind of like pine straw, good on hills because it will stay put, but not for beds.

I use mostly bark mulch, but I've been buying a brand that is engineered to not keep water away from the plants. So far so good.

I did like the coconut coir mulch, but it was kind of a pain to do at first (it's compressed and you have to soak it so it expands). However, I've been on a real coconut kick lately and I've been saving the husks and will try to break them up and use as mulch. I think they will not break down so easily....


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

It feels nice to walk on. it's thick and springy. But it's very splintery to handle and tricky to shovel. I think it looks nice on slopes.


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

As has been mentioned, ANY mulch, with insufficient rainfall or sprinkler levels, can prevent the water from actually reaching the soil. There must be enough physical water to wet the mulch, exceed the amount the mulch is going to absorb and actually percolate through it into the soil. The same thing happens in the woods with the forest litter if the rain hasn't been heavy enough to provide enough water to penetrate that "mulch".

Wind in many areas is a constant battle. Of course, smaller, lighter pieces of any mulch will blow in strong winds. They also break down faster than large chunks or shards, which can seem as though they've "blown away". Try drier oak leaves or rice hulls if you really want a battle with the wind! A commercial "planter mix" I used to buy contained rice hulls. I had a truck load delivered to the old garden. The wind quickly took the surface layer of rice hulls from that pile, leaving sand particles and heavier pieces of shredded wood shards it contained, resembling a "desert pavement" surface.

I've used Gorilla Hair in many applications and found it excellent around roses and other landscape areas needing cover. It doesn't move downhill with gravity as easily as bark nuggets or chunks do. It isn't as easily knocked around by dogs running through it as bark. It doesn't provide as large spaces as bark to catch litter and provide insect hiding places. It requires less product (hence lower cost) to provide the appropriate protection against heat and water loss than chunks or nuggets. It doesn't attract dogs like manures can. Weeds and other seeds can germinate on any fibrous or fine textured materials, but they are significantly easier to pull up with their roots intact from a horse manure, compost or Gorilla Hair mulch surface than from hard baked soil. It remains fibrous so water penetrates it easily, provided there is enough water to being with. You do have to irrigate sufficiently to penetrate whatever material you choose as a mulch. In my climate, you can't rely upon the "rains" to do it properly because they just aren't happening as they used to.

The bags I've most recently seen have contained either cedar or fir product in place of the original redwood. Those two types are more quickly replaced than redwood and hadn't been suspected as potential carriers for Sudden Oak Death as redwood had. Redwood used to be inexpensive and easily found everywhere for bender board, fencing and general lumber. Fir and cedar have replaced it in many uses, so the "left overs" are generally more readily available and at better prices. Kim


 o
RE: Disappointing gorilla hair mulch

In addition to being the most water repellant mulch I have ever used, those little splinters also work their way into your skin. They itch for days.

In a year or two, or maybe three, it will be all gone, decomposed into the soil. I don't remember how long it lasted when I tried it, but it did not stay indefinitely. Next time consider bark nuggets if you want something decorative, or shredded wood from tree trimmings if you want something free that works but may not be as well groomed in appearance.

I use the free stuff myself.

Rosefolly

This post was edited by rosefolly on Sat, Aug 31, 13 at 14:12


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Antique Roses Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here