Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
nothingness_gw

Do you know real name of this rose?

nothingness
9 years ago

Hello I new member. I see this board so long.
I think It interest board which have many information.
I request you about real name of this rose whom I wonder long time.

This old garden rose I wonder about real name of this rose
It Cecile brunner or Marie Pavir or other name

ps.because I can't use insectcide in my narrow garden
my rose it not complete

Thank you very much

other pic of this rose
http://upload.sodazaa.com/image.php?id=5088_5430FDBC
http://upload.sodazaa.com/image.php?id=5296_5430FE57
http://upload.sodazaa.com/image.php?id=F64B_5430FE57
http://upload.sodazaa.com/image.php?id=799E_5430FE57
http://upload.sodazaa.com/image.php?id=1C2C_5430FE57
http://upload.sodazaa.com/image.php?id=D4B8_5430FDBC
http://upload.sodazaa.com/image.php?id=778F_5430FDBC
http://upload.sodazaa.com/image.php?id=D8F1_5430FDBC
http://upload.sodazaa.com/image.php?id=6F32_5430FDBC

Comments (32)

  • bellarosa
    9 years ago

    Looks like Cecile Brunner to me.

  • cottonwood468
    9 years ago

    Does it have maroon stamens? Let's see a photo of an open bloom.

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    open bloom 1

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    open bloom 2

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    open bloom 3

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    open bloom 4

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    and last pic open bloom 5
    do you know real name?

    thank you very much

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    after open bloom it full bloom nearly wilt

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    nearly wilt bloom another pic
    thank you very much

    I hope my pic fine enough to know real name of this rose.
    I want to know real name of this rose so much.

  • dublinbay z6 (KS)
    9 years ago

    I would guess Cecile Brunner also.

    Kate

  • porkpal zone 9 Tx
    9 years ago

    Excellent photos! I agree that it looks like Cecile Brunner. How big are the blooms, and does the plant grow very large?

  • ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9
    9 years ago

    I have some doubt about this being Cecile Brunner since this rose has a more "ragged" appearance. The buds especially have a fuller, less elegant appearance. It also doesn't look like my Marie Pavie, but I have no idea what it actually could be.

    Ingrid

  • jerijen
    9 years ago

    Just for comparison, here is a photo of some very happy blooms on 'Mlle. Cecile Brunner, Cl' -- in Northern California. This plant is pruned down to a bush, but is pretty gorgeous in springtime.

    Do look closely at the leaves, to see if they match. See the elliptical shape of the leaflets -- and the way the leaflets behind the terminal one sweep forward. Take a look at the stamens in the open blooms, to see if they seem to match your rose.

    Jeri

  • AquaEyes 7a NJ
    9 years ago

    The rose in the original post reminds me of 'Marie-Jeanne'. I can't say for sure that's what it is, but the foliage doesn't seem the same as that of 'Mme Cecile Brunner'.

    :-)

    ~Christopher

    Here is a link that might be useful: 'Marie-Jeanne' at HelpMeFind

  • porkpal zone 9 Tx
    9 years ago

    Yes, now I notice the un-named rose seems to have glossier foliage than my Cecile Brunners. I still would like to know the size of the blooms.

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    most size of bloom is 2-3.5cm (line pass circle of bloom)
    size of bloom of this rose bigger regular miniature rose slightly.
    but smaller my another rose floribunda valentine slightly.

    It rarely to size of bloom close my floribunda valentine.
    and size never bigger floribunda valentine.

    I wonder and confuse about of this rose's name because
    most regular tree merchant when see my rose

    They call it Marie Pavie but I feel It not look like Marie Pavie
    when I look example pic of Marie Pavie (many pic)
    I feel It look like cecile brunner more

    There are only boss of old rose nursery only call It
    cecile brunner

    I reallly grateful for everyone's assistance
    Thank you very much

    leave of this rose it have some damage from insect
    because I can't use insectcide

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    bush of this rose
    It height and width nearby floribunda valentine

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    rose bouquet
    It have numerous bloom normal is 3-4 blooms
    but sometime It have near 20 blooms at end of big rose branch

    It have sub rose branch which have 3-5 blooms many branch
    concentrate at end of big rose branch

  • jerijen
    9 years ago

    Nothingness, could you get a photo of a whole leaf, showing particularly the lower leaflets, and MOST particularly the stipule (the part I circled, in this photo).

    Jeri

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    I'm sorry for I late
    can you see? Jeri

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    pic2

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    last pic

  • Vicissitudezz
    9 years ago

    Does anyone think this could be a Noisette? Or is it definitely a Polyantha?

    I'm still trying to figure these things out.

    Thanks,
    Virginia

  • jerijen
    9 years ago

    Virginia -- I don't think it's a Polyantha, because I see no telltale hints of multiflora showing up in the stipule.

    Those two backward-facing leaflets make me think there's some Tea in there.

    My mind is now drifting in the direction of the cluster-flowering Noisettes -- or maybe some Tea-Noisette that I don't grow.

    I'm not suggesting it's one of the two below, but maybe something of these types?

    Jeri

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    Thank you very much for your diligence Jeri

    I think this rose may be noisette too
    after I saw blush noisette.
    but It height 120cm-200cm my rose height and width nearby valentine
    I think It rather look like roseville noisette

    Last this rose seem not cecile brunner. but I still love it.
    It very very resistance although I can't use insectcide
    and this rose
    it hard to be rose disease in hot weather and high humid
    (My rose is in Thailand)

    I know that it hard to know real name of this rose.
    this old garden rose sale in my country so long
    and no one know real name. It call various names.

    in present It oldish to be rare rose
    and rarely tree merchant will have this rose for sale
    and must be old merchant to know this rose
    (but still not know real name)

    most rose gardener don't know this rose
    they know english rose more

    Thank you very much again Jeri and everyone

    This post was edited by nothingness on Sun, Oct 12, 14 at 8:00

  • Vicissitudezz
    9 years ago

    Looking at the HelpMeFind database, it looks like there may be more than one rose going by the name of 'Champney's Pink Cluster' (the first Noisette), but this rose looks like at least one of them.

    That rose dates to the early 1800's, and by 1844, Mr Buist wrote that it was "universally cultivated".

    Since your rose is pretty old, it seems that this could be a good possibility, but it's also possible that this is an old variety that is no longer in commerce.

    I thought at first that the flower looked like 'Princesse de Nassau', but your rose looks too pink, and the buds don't look long and slender enough...

    Whatever its name, it's very beautiful, and I'm glad you shared your photos of it.

    Best regards,
    Virginia

    Here is a link that might be useful: photo of 'Champney's Pink Cluster'

  • jill_perry_gw
    9 years ago

    I'm thinking China rather than tea-probably a mini.
    Jill

  • jerijen
    9 years ago

    As a parent? Or this rose itself?

    You make me wish we could see the plant. :-)

    Jeri

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    you come In the end Jeri
    Thank you very much Jeri for your assiatance
    you have so skillful really

    I think roseville noisette look like with my rose about 80%-90%
    (It nearest with my rose)

    And Virginia I glad to you like my rose
    Thank you very much

  • jerijen
    9 years ago

    One thing is -- there are many, many, many roses which are sports or seedlings of 'Champney's Pink Cluster.' It seems to have been a prolific parent, and all of those that I have grown were strong garden plants.

    If it doesn't have a name, you give it a study name. :-)

  • luxrosa
    9 years ago

    Hi there Nothingness,
    what part of the world do you live in?
    Perhaps someone else who lives in the same county or shire bought the same rose and you might find them at a local rose society. Also, if you live in a cold climate, I believe your rose may possibly be less likely to be a China or Noisette, though it could be related to one of those classes.
    I've grown or cared for in a public garden, all the roses mentioned so far on this thread and am of the opinion that, your rose isn't any of those.
    Although the foliage and pedicals are quite different, the bloom shape and color makes me wonder if your rose is related to Mlle. Cecille Brunner' which has been in commerce since 1881, perhaps someone might do a search on helpmefind.com of roses bred from Cecille Brunner, or open pollinated seedlings of it.

    Anyhoo, I went to the vintagegardens.com website which is a very good reference, though the nursery is closed. I looked at all the photos available on Polyantha roses and didn't see your rose there.

    by the way, I have a few questions that might help i.d. it,
    How old is your rosebush?
    -what is the largest it has ever been?
    which climate zone do you live in?

    is your rose fragrant at all?
    -is it sweetly fragrant?
    -or does it have a spicy scent,
    or a combination of the two scents?

    I love your rose and sure hope you find out its name, I like the thought of a study name; I'd suggest 'Grace',
    for it is full of grace.

    Good luck and best wishes in your endeavor,
    Lux.

  • nothingness
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    To Lux
    Thank you for your help
    I think this rose may be find real name
    but I still be answer information for you

    How old is your rosebush?
    1 year with near 6 months
    I mean still I bought from tree shop
    until now when I bought It's wild rose which install this rose's bud and have small size

    -what is the largest it has ever been?
    largest of this rose is nearby or equal valentine

    which climate zone do you live in?
    I don't know zone but It is thailand
    and rose live in middle capital city
    I think hot climate

    is your rose fragrant at all?
    -is it sweetly fragrant?
    -or does it have a spicy scent,
    or a combination of the two scents?

    I not sure about scent but it moderate fragrance
    I think scent similar to antique incense of thailand
    or antique purfume of thailand
    sometime near damask rose