JOIN NOW LOG IN
iVillage GardenWeb iVillage GardenWeb THE INTERNET'S GARDEN & HOME COMMUNITY ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs Forums Photo Galleries Ask The Experts Tools & Directories        
Return to the Antique Roses Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

Posted by kandm 8b coastal alabama (My Page) on
Sat, Oct 17, 09 at 10:12

My husband picked these roses up for me at a Fall Native Plant sale and I'm wondering if any here have tips. I live in a pretty humid area of the Gulf Coast and I've read these both do better in drier climates.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

I grow them both in the upstate of SC and while we are not as humid as you are they both do well for me. I have found with MN that there are quite a few clones out there and some are better than others. Sometimes when it is very humid the blooms on MN will ball up but in I don't mind as they are lovely in spring and fall.

As with most climbing roses give them time to grow and settle in. You won't see as much blooming the first year and there might be more disease than you would like but they will grow through that.

Paul


 o
RE: Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

I can't say how they'll do in your garden, but they're both magnificent.


 o
RE: Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

Sombreuil was bad for BS and never thrived/bloomed well. SP'd him and never looked back. MN is doing well for me. Blooms frequently and stays well foliated.


 o
RE: Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

There may be some diseased selections of MN and some clean selections of same, but there's only ONE clone. Perhaps the confusion has to do with the fact that the term 'clone' may correctly be used as either a verb or a noun. At any rate, I think precision of language definitely matters (since language is, after all, the way we communicate with each other). Within the realm of botany, the term in question has a singular, very specific meaning. The indiscriminate (& usually incorrect) use of the word 'clone' on these forums has become a pet peeve. Sorry if any of you take offense. If you have a different clone, you have a different variety, it's as simple as that.


 o
RE: Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

I don't grow it, but I have seen a very huge, very old Marechal Niel in Tallahasse that seems to be doing quite well. It easily covers half of a tennis court fence, horizontally, vertically it's hanging over the top of the fence. Not so coastal but still hot humid zone 8.


 o
RE: Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

garden2garden:
That's interesting; where in Tallahassee is it? When I get back to Florida I go up there fairly frequently.
Melissa


 o
RE: Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

It's climbing the chain link fence around the old tennis court at Goodwood Museum. Have you been there?


 o
RE: Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

I did go to Goodwood once, and actually looked at the roses with an inquiring eye. How could MN have escaped me? (It's not like I'm not familiar with the rose: I have a twenty foot specimen here and it certainly is noticeable enough when it blooms.) Thanks for the info.
Melissa


 o
RE: Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

Overall, I'm pleased with my Sombruiel. Even though it's lost half it's leaves to BS despite 2x/month spraying it's blooms are nice with reasonable repeat. My only complaint is it's thornyness.


 o
RE: Any Advice for Sombreuil and Marechal Niel ?

jaxondel or anyone else,

I have a question regarding clones. I realize that some roses will make noticeable "sports" and these sports can then be propagated from vegetative cuttings. Usually the sports are identified by a new color, more petals, change in growth habit (bush rose sporting a climbing cane).

Isn't it also likely that a particular rose, like MN, can sport as well...but not in noticeable traits such as color, petal count etc., but just in vigor? And, if you have a large bush from which a propagator is taking cuttings, isn't it likely that cuttings from the vigorous "half" of the bush will be vigorous, while cuttings from a non-vigorous half of the bush would be non-vigorous? I would think that the roses would be identical in every way except vigor. Even though the same bush was used to make the cuttings (clones of the parent), in fact, they are not all identical.

So when someone has a particular specimen of a rose that is growing very well and another specimen of that same variety (perhaps purchased from another vendor)may not grow vigorously are in your garden, perhaps one rose came from a vigorous cutting while another came from a cutting that lacked vigor?

My reasoning may be faulty, but I really believe that there are specimens of the same "named" variety that are more vigorous than others...and, I'm not considering that some are less vigorous because they are virused...that's a whole other discussion.

Does anyone else feel that some specimens of a named variety are, in fact, more vigorous than others? I often hear people ask what vendor they got a particular rose from. Or they will comment that a particular vendor has particularly vigorous "clone" of a particular variety.

Robert


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Antique Roses Forum
 
 


iVillage GardenWeb: The Internet's Garden & Home Community  
  iVillage Home & Garden Network